So after consulting the Faraam Set figure I got with the collector's edition of Dark Souls 2, the Faraam set is more blue than I originally thought. The highlight on the cloak is almost exactly 1:1 on the figure, and I used AP scarab green as the shadow; with a 50/50 of each for the midtone. The fur I did Paynes Grey, a dark grey, and then 50/50 grey/ivory.

I think I'm going to avoid using any washes on this model if I can. I felt like I had so much more control even if the shadows aren't quite where they're supposed to be. And it'll make me a better painter in the long run.