>>95880266
>doctor
No. Not even someone who is a career doctor, but someone who knows how to administer first aid; basic knowledge of treating injuries, infections, burns, and poisoning.

>both should probably overlap with 3 be capable of identifying the plantlife that's useful in their respective fields
Why? That's not how D&D does it.

>depending on how rare they are in setting
Not only are hunting and defense guns readily available, but the means to learn their use is extremely accessible, like how magic is literally everywhere (except for a couple character options for the sake of sacred cows) in D&D.

The idea behind my post was to draw a comparison of only one person in a party having one practical and readily-available skill to a system that does the same thing, and see how people would try to justify it.
It doesn't make sense for five campers going into dangerous woods to pigeonhole one major role to each person, so why would a group of adventurers in a world filled with ubiquitous magic do the same thing?
The fact that pretty much nobody saw this demonstrates the long-term effects D&D brainrot has had on the people of this board.
Now cry about me saying bad things about D&D, because you have no arguments against anything else I said.