Search Results
7/21/2025, 7:31:38 PM
>>127119201
Incredibly idiotic, I am actually convinced you are baiting, that or you think MCR are better simply because they are the most acessible out of these.
For all their career MCR wrote simplified Pop versions of what came prior, first they were just simplifying Thursday's sound as everyone else was at the time, then they hyper-focused on the theatrics, Glam Rock influences with Black Parade, yet aftewards, unlike Thursday, they had nowhere left to go hence why their next album was an absolute crapshoot of doubling down on Glam.
Don't get me wrong, what they did, they did well, but acting like MCR is the best "Emo" band is an opinion born out of arrogance and refusal to approach music that dares to stray away from Verse-Chorus formula.
I agree with the anons prior, JEW are much better just due to Clarity alone, all your opinions about MCR being better technical players doesn't matter to me as they never wrote songs as rich, layered nor interesting as For Me This Is Heaven, they never dared to move away from radio-ready music, their music is fun but not adventurous.
Even when JEW went to a Emo-Pop/Pop Punkier route their music is still far richer than MCR's, Bleed American/Futures at their core are more ocmpelling record than anything MCR ever made
Thursday absolutely dominates MCR, I don't think there's a debate for that unless you really don't know what you're talking about or you value instant gratification over everything else. MCR is not capable of masterpieces like Autobiography of A Nation, they don't have Geoff Rickly's amazing lyricism.
This list just screams you want immediacy, not depth. Might sound pretentious, but the fact SDER/Thursday are at the bottom of your list is incredibly telling, it just screams musical illiteracy.
Incredibly idiotic, I am actually convinced you are baiting, that or you think MCR are better simply because they are the most acessible out of these.
For all their career MCR wrote simplified Pop versions of what came prior, first they were just simplifying Thursday's sound as everyone else was at the time, then they hyper-focused on the theatrics, Glam Rock influences with Black Parade, yet aftewards, unlike Thursday, they had nowhere left to go hence why their next album was an absolute crapshoot of doubling down on Glam.
Don't get me wrong, what they did, they did well, but acting like MCR is the best "Emo" band is an opinion born out of arrogance and refusal to approach music that dares to stray away from Verse-Chorus formula.
I agree with the anons prior, JEW are much better just due to Clarity alone, all your opinions about MCR being better technical players doesn't matter to me as they never wrote songs as rich, layered nor interesting as For Me This Is Heaven, they never dared to move away from radio-ready music, their music is fun but not adventurous.
Even when JEW went to a Emo-Pop/Pop Punkier route their music is still far richer than MCR's, Bleed American/Futures at their core are more ocmpelling record than anything MCR ever made
Thursday absolutely dominates MCR, I don't think there's a debate for that unless you really don't know what you're talking about or you value instant gratification over everything else. MCR is not capable of masterpieces like Autobiography of A Nation, they don't have Geoff Rickly's amazing lyricism.
This list just screams you want immediacy, not depth. Might sound pretentious, but the fact SDER/Thursday are at the bottom of your list is incredibly telling, it just screams musical illiteracy.
Page 1