Search Results
6/20/2025, 5:29:29 AM
Ok so because a lot of people are probably going to bring this up over and over inevitably, better to get it over with now
The Thinking Critical guy claims in this video that he got info from someone in the industry who has access to Penguin House and Lunar order numbers, and found out that Amazing Spider-Man's orders for May are around 48,000 (he also says later in the video that both #3 and 4's sales were below 50,000) and the orders for One World Under Doom were around 40,000 in May. When he says orders I assume he means orders to retailers like the old Diamond charts and not the ComicHub chart that charts sales to customers.
Eventually this will probably spread around other social media or something, people will debate whether or not the info is real or if Thinking Critical is part of Comicsgate or something and probably at some point Marvel will have to argue against it or get their proxies to do so, if it's untrue.
But I will say that this kind of explains how odd things have been lately, like putting Marvel Masterworks on hiatus and Iron Man supposedly getting canceled after ten issues and the weird way some people are acting online getting defensive about ASM and lashing out
The Thinking Critical guy claims in this video that he got info from someone in the industry who has access to Penguin House and Lunar order numbers, and found out that Amazing Spider-Man's orders for May are around 48,000 (he also says later in the video that both #3 and 4's sales were below 50,000) and the orders for One World Under Doom were around 40,000 in May. When he says orders I assume he means orders to retailers like the old Diamond charts and not the ComicHub chart that charts sales to customers.
Eventually this will probably spread around other social media or something, people will debate whether or not the info is real or if Thinking Critical is part of Comicsgate or something and probably at some point Marvel will have to argue against it or get their proxies to do so, if it's untrue.
But I will say that this kind of explains how odd things have been lately, like putting Marvel Masterworks on hiatus and Iron Man supposedly getting canceled after ten issues and the weird way some people are acting online getting defensive about ASM and lashing out
Page 1