>>528297535
>Was she, though? Are they, though?
I want you to explain to me what you think it meant when Kris told the voice on the phone that Susie has the guitar, the voice said "I'll be right there," and then two minutes Carol inexplicably shows up at the house in the middle of the day when she normally NEVER leaves town hall for any reason and immediately beelines to take the guitar off Susie, and then makes a point of seeing Kris out (being completely unsurprised to see Kris there despite Noelle implying Kris hasn't regularly visited in years).
>why would she emphasize You in the same SOUL red
This is brainrot shit, it's the same MSPaint red text that's been used since Undertale, Carol does not control the color of her text in the dialogue box, this isn't fucking Umineko

>>528297613
It is Kris's SOUL. Either effectively in that it's the SOUL inhabiting their body, or it's always been Kris's SOUL and we've just recently taken possession of it.

>>528298383
>I think it's because Carol has it backwards, she thinks she is working with (You), but she is being decieved by Kris
That doesn't make sense with the voice on the phone telling Kris that they need the SOUL while they're talking about their secret evil plans.

>>528187383
>>528188246
She's talking to Kris. Kris is conspiring with her, we are the one fucking things up.