So I'm new to wargaming and ttrpgs. And surfing this board I just have one question....is there any one edition of any game that tg can kind of agree on that was actually "good"?

I know about the current Horus heresy drama, I know the drama around all Warhammer editions, the DND hate, and even now bolt action complaints.

I know the stereotype is that people will always bitch about new editions but I am genuinely curious if there has ever been a rough consensus on a good edition/game system.