>So like I guess I'd like to know in general what kind of visual traits in MCs you guys find appealing and also off putting
>>3806317
Hidden eyes are a character trope that makes any character cooler, no matter if the eyes are hidden by the character's hair, glasses/visor, a blindfold or something else, it also helps to give main characters a neutral expression but still giving room to interpret what they are feeling at any moment
>I wanted everyone to be under the impression they are just human.
>And any hints otherwise to be quite hidden.
You could make your MC's eyes a revelation, like they don't look human at all once you get a good look at them