51yo here. Just finished playing this. Didn't complete the dlc because it was more of the same and I was already bored of it.

Pros
-Gunplay and environmental destruction are great.
-Aesthetics, Story and Setting are top notch.

Cons
-Loot system felt like a last minute addition. It's bad and it hurts exploration. Is disappointing when you discover a hidden secret and the reward is a mod with 15% more Zoom or HP on melee attacks. Made me not want to explore.

-Low enemy variety made encounters boring, repetitive.

-Weapon forms are the usual weapons you see in every other shooter. Handgun, machine gun, nade launcher, laser. I expected more creativity with the games setting and powers. It's a morphing weapon and the protagonist have super natural powers. There are records showing the service gun can turn into anything including swords but they played it safe and boring.

I give it a 7/10. Max Payne is better. Now to try Alan Wake 2.