>>149856488
Allen was a deserving MVP. Here are MVPs that I would change. Note that no non-QB can ever be more valuable than a top-tier QB like Peyton putting up absurd numbers.
>2021
Brady over Rodgers
Almost identical advanced efficiency metrics, with Brady doing it on much higher volume
>2012
Peyton or Brady. Near identical efficiency, Brady on slightly higher volume. Denver 13-3, Patriots 12-4. Either one winning would have been the correct option. I think this is a great co-MVP year.
>2011
Probably Brees over Rodgers. Both with historic efficiency, Rodgers slightly, slightly higher, but Brees much higher total volume. I value Brees' volume over Rodgers' 15-1 vs 13-3 edge. But It's not a robbery one way or the other. Co-MVPs perhaps? Yeah, I think this should have been co-MVPs.
>2009
Brees over Peyton.
>2006
Peyton over LT (QB > RB)
>2005
Peyton over Shaun Alexander (QB > RB)
In this objectively correct scenario the updated MVP count would be.
Peyton - 7
Brady - 5
Rodgers - 3
Brees - 2