>>715893875
It's 1.
It's not just significantly better written, but it understands it's a third person cover shooter and has a lot of fun with it. The shooting actually feels fun and dynamic.
2 went to hard on muh realism and as a result it often feels sluggish and awkward, and the cover system kinda retarded.
2 does do a lot of things better though, like the environments, hunting, horse riding and some other stuff, but 1 is truly the superior game even if 2 is a good as well.