>>63949424
I'd skip both and get a 1-8/10x LPVO for a 17, unless it's a dedicated bench shooter or a 20.
More than that is kind of overkill for magnification as a general BR setup and a 1x setting is great for carbine-style shooting within 100 yards.
LPVOs really shine on BRs like the SCAR in my experience and I've had a lot of fun with the Vortex 1-10x from 50 out to 400 yards.