Search Results
7/25/2025, 4:39:10 AM
>>42392815
Since it came up again, here's the image for the Two Timelines Theory that shows which episode goes where.
Though, I now think the divergence point is actually UniCon, with Hot Pot Party being strictly in the Stallion timeline.
Since it came up again, here's the image for the Two Timelines Theory that shows which episode goes where.
Though, I now think the divergence point is actually UniCon, with Hot Pot Party being strictly in the Stallion timeline.
7/19/2025, 6:42:35 PM
Okay, so you've all heard of the "Two Tamers Theory", which tries to explain why there's such a stark difference in artstyle and story focus.
But I came up at least I hope so, it'd be kinda embarrassing if someone else already brought it up before with a different interpretation.
What if the issue isn't that there are two creators, but rather two creations?
Bam, Two Timelines Theory!
Its main goal is to explain there's little to no overlap between the two major stories in Tamers MLP, even though they logically should.
Why do we never see Flawless interact with Arinos or Care Package? Because she literally doesn't exist in their timeline.
Why do we not see Cadance and SA in stallion episodes? Because they never got back together.
Why does Twilight just abandon the family she loves in the middle of the apocalypse? Because she and Trixie never even became a thing.
The point of divergence is Fluttershy's hotpot party, but it's hard to represent that in an image, since right after it we have Pinkie's sleepover, which takes place in both timelines, since the fillies also have fucked up eyes in Outbreak.
Mind you, we probably only see the "stallion version" of Hotpot Party, and it's my belief that there's a different version where Pinkie talked with Twilight about Trixie instead of with Soarin about Braeburn, which is what ultimately causes the divide.
So yeah, fuck Ponk for dooming us to an eternity of boring gay melodrama.
I'm sure there are a billion things that disprove this, like Flawless showing up on the reflection during the Toola Roola and Starsong episode, but I think it's still an interesting thought experiment to see just how different these two faces of Tamers MLP truly are
But I came up at least I hope so, it'd be kinda embarrassing if someone else already brought it up before with a different interpretation.
What if the issue isn't that there are two creators, but rather two creations?
Bam, Two Timelines Theory!
Its main goal is to explain there's little to no overlap between the two major stories in Tamers MLP, even though they logically should.
Why do we never see Flawless interact with Arinos or Care Package? Because she literally doesn't exist in their timeline.
Why do we not see Cadance and SA in stallion episodes? Because they never got back together.
Why does Twilight just abandon the family she loves in the middle of the apocalypse? Because she and Trixie never even became a thing.
The point of divergence is Fluttershy's hotpot party, but it's hard to represent that in an image, since right after it we have Pinkie's sleepover, which takes place in both timelines, since the fillies also have fucked up eyes in Outbreak.
Mind you, we probably only see the "stallion version" of Hotpot Party, and it's my belief that there's a different version where Pinkie talked with Twilight about Trixie instead of with Soarin about Braeburn, which is what ultimately causes the divide.
So yeah, fuck Ponk for dooming us to an eternity of boring gay melodrama.
I'm sure there are a billion things that disprove this, like Flawless showing up on the reflection during the Toola Roola and Starsong episode, but I think it's still an interesting thought experiment to see just how different these two faces of Tamers MLP truly are
Page 1