I can imagine Carol owning a gun and/or going to a gun range to shoot for practice or fun, but Rudy holding a gun or being anywhere near one doesn’t work for me.
I feel like years ago on their early dates, Carol took him to a gun range and she’s perfectly fine with it, but Rudy has to force himself to fire one shot after he almost doesn’t go through with it and Carol looks disappointed, but he can’t get himself to shoot anymore after that.
Is that weird?