>>81592157
>Am I the Asshole?
Yes.
Why didn't you just fucking ask?
You wanted to LE SURPRISE him? How gay.

>>81592177
>I don't know what his problem is. Fucking ungrateful.
You fucked with this prized possession that he had since high school. He enjoyed his guitar the way it was.
Even if he was complaining about it to you, some people just like having little things to complain about to others.
Imagine doing something that has a net negative on their life and expecting them to be "grateful" for it.