Finished F/SN and it was ok. Fights weren't that interesting, the SoL scenes were lacking and I disliked how a lot of the side characters just became completely irrelevant in some routes. I enjoyed the the scenes where multiple characters interacted (especially characters that weren't on the best of terms or were strangers beforehand), needed more of those desu, not just one-on-ones talking about upcoming battles and info dumps or how Shirou is still able to move and fight when everything hurts and he was barely able to lift his arms/legs just seconds ago. Rin best girl, HF best route. 7/10

I've also started the Tsukihime remake and have finished Arc's route. Almost all of the flaws from F/SN still apply here. I loved the mansion scenes with Shiki's sister and the maids, sadly they all took a backseat for Arc once her route got to the midpoint or so. Maybe Ciel's route will be better. Mahoyo is still the best TM work I've read/seen desu.