No, but it had its short sparks of being decent enough, early 2000s gamespot is the best (and only) example I can think of.
But in my experience throughout gaming's whole lifespan, gaming centered journalism has always been garbage
>journos would boycott 2D hand drawn games in favor of ugly early 3D
>journos would publish fake cheat codes for no reason at all
>journos thought that japanese games going more edgier/more american in the early 2000s was actually a good thing!
>most journos play like crap
>most journos don't finish the games they're reviewing