Here's the top ten films of '25 according to The New York Times:

The Big Parade
The Last Laugh
The Unholy Three
The Gold Rush
The Merry Widow
The Dark Angel
Don Q, Son of Zorro
Ben-Hur: A Tale of the Christ
Stella Dallas
A Kiss for Cinderella

The New York Times top ten films of 1925 were:

The Big Parade
The Last Laugh
The Unholy Three
The Gold Rush
The Merry Widow
The Dark Angel
Don Q, Son of Zorro
Ben-Hur
Stella Dallas
A Kiss for Cinderella