Search Results
7/1/2025, 9:36:19 PM
>>7628913
>What valuable criticism can you give that's not feelings based if you're not even skilled in the art of creating that thing?
I can criticize the subject matter and stylistic choices. The gacha slop image is generic. I couldn't tell it was shichigatsu if you put it in a row with 5 other pieces like it. With their earlier works, they're easily distinguished as pieces by that artist and they look unique.
What criticism can you give other anons when you haven't posted art?
>The westoid mindset of everyone being a critic with nothing to show for it is the main reason for the current downfall of the arts.
I actually agree with you. Indeed I too get pissed off when I see tumblr troons invade a thing I like and claim it for themselves (dungeon meshi) and dictate what it is (muh autistic laios, muh farcille, muh sexy senshi, muh hairy Namari), but it doesn't apply here. Do you think a Japanese person with a degree in the arts is going to say that an fgo character portrait is just as good and important as a work by one of the masters? Obviously not, it would be inferior both in subject matter and technical ability.
You have to post art. Let me see just one thing you've made. Here's a copy I made from a japanese artist. 'That's not yours' or 'all you did was copy, that's not impressive' you might say, but it's more than you've posted and I'm not calling you shit at drawing or anything. You're calling other people shit at drawing + not posting your art and this makes you a disgusting rat who ruins this board.
>What valuable criticism can you give that's not feelings based if you're not even skilled in the art of creating that thing?
I can criticize the subject matter and stylistic choices. The gacha slop image is generic. I couldn't tell it was shichigatsu if you put it in a row with 5 other pieces like it. With their earlier works, they're easily distinguished as pieces by that artist and they look unique.
What criticism can you give other anons when you haven't posted art?
>The westoid mindset of everyone being a critic with nothing to show for it is the main reason for the current downfall of the arts.
I actually agree with you. Indeed I too get pissed off when I see tumblr troons invade a thing I like and claim it for themselves (dungeon meshi) and dictate what it is (muh autistic laios, muh farcille, muh sexy senshi, muh hairy Namari), but it doesn't apply here. Do you think a Japanese person with a degree in the arts is going to say that an fgo character portrait is just as good and important as a work by one of the masters? Obviously not, it would be inferior both in subject matter and technical ability.
You have to post art. Let me see just one thing you've made. Here's a copy I made from a japanese artist. 'That's not yours' or 'all you did was copy, that's not impressive' you might say, but it's more than you've posted and I'm not calling you shit at drawing or anything. You're calling other people shit at drawing + not posting your art and this makes you a disgusting rat who ruins this board.
Page 1