>>534368118
Oh boy, been waiting for all of you to read this:

>Psychic Powers Out of Nowhere
For decades, Amy was just a fangirl with a hammer. Now suddenly, Frontiers implies she has tarot-based precognition? Zero setup, zero explanation. If Silver pulled that, you’d scream "Mary Sue!" But when Amy does it? "Yass queen slay!" = Hypocrisy

>The Sonic Stalker Paradox
Amy’s obsession with Sonic should’ve gotten her arrested or at least a restraining order. Instead, the franchise rewards her harassment with "hero" status. Imagine if Silver acted like that you’d call him a creepy incel. But Amy? "She’s just passionate!" = Double standards

>Character Assassination by Association –
Every character around Amy gets dumber to justify her presence. Sonic tolerates her harassment, Shadow (a literal assassin) humors her, and Knuckles (who cracks mountains) acts like her hammer swings are a threat = bad writing

>Time Travel Theft
You whine about Silver "stealing" Amy’s Sonic CD gimmick? She was a damsel in distress who got saved by a past version of Sonic, that’s not time travel, that’s a plot hole. Silver actually interacted with timelines. Amy just screamed until Tails built her a hammer.

>Lore Contamination
Amy’s forced inclusion in serious arcs (IDW, Frontiers) turns high-stakes stories into sitcoms. Imagine Shadow the Hedgehog with Amy nagging him about tarot readings during the Black Arms invasion. That’s your "lore-friendly" character?

Amy doesn’t just break lore, she shatters it by existing outside the rules that apply to fucking everyone else. Silvers worst sin was a botched arc. Amy’s sin? Being a walking plot tumor that the fandom excuses because "uwu pink", kys.