1>3>2>4 but I love 4 dearly and it only slightly goes below 2. The vibe and atmosphere and feel is amazing and I love the varied locales(forest especially) and comfy/unsettling feel of being in your apartment. Loved looking out the window. Also Eileen was awesome and fun to have with you. Wish she was with you the whole game. Ghosts and impaling them on swords and everything - good shit. This game, while rough around the edges and different, was awesome! I often wonder if it had come out like originally planned as some random Konami game, and not a Silent Hill, if it would be more beloved as a cult classic. Being silent Hill 4 almost seems to hurt the game somehow for many.