>>716441924
2 has the best combat because long rolls, parrying, and signs are all restricted to the same resource, vigor, and the more vigor you burn up, the less sword damage you do. That means you have to actually git gud, use potions, use bombs, use traps, use positioning, and conserve vigor instead of treating it like a rollslop game. Witcher 2's combat is the ultimate pleb filter because it punishes you for being a shitty and doesn't let you bullshit the system.