>>529580894
Sonic is a reincarnation of the wind. Silver is a reincarnation of the wind. The wind can be sensed by both Amy and Elise; that's why they both mistake Silver for Sonic and Sonic for Silver.

Elise and Amy both proved that they can sense souls, as Elise could sense Sonic's soul at the end of 06, and Amy can sense Sonic with Sonic Radar. Amy can also sense other beings, as proven by Heroes and the Sonic Channel stories, when she easily sensed invisible Espio. Amy rejected Werehog Sonic at first because he didn't look like Sonic, but she still sensed that it was Sonic. You can't mistake a huge, hairy beast like that for Sonic if you didn't have access to the Sonic Radar like Amy does. Also, notice how Amy never mistakes anyone for Sonic who isn't also mistaken for him by other characters.
>Elise thought Sonic was Silver
>everyone thought Shadow was Sonic
That's because these characters both have Sonic's essence. Shadow is an artificial wind, but it's still the wind. The Black Wind.

>>527580132
Holy avatarfaggot.