>>3775358
>>best story
Persona 3 and it's not even close.
>>best cast
Also Persona 3 and you know it's right.
The squad feels like an actual group of immature teenagers stuck with each other not because they want to, but because their duty compels them to fight for mankind.
Unlike P4 and P5 the rest of the cast doesn't just revolve around the MC and instead has their own little bonds and feuds going on.
>>best MC
Persona 5 because he's cool, which is the most important thing for a self insert MC.
>>best visuals
Persona 5 as well.
>>best music
Persona 3 and 4 mog Persona 5 badly, but of the two I always preferred P3's OST over P4's.
>>best gameplay
Persona 5 OBVIOUSLY.