Way I see it the whole hatch shit spawns from a community wide perception issue.

A lot of killers have this perception that they need a 4k for a win. Which is obviously wrong when a 3k is a win and a 4k is mostly circumstantial and can be heavily RNG based on things outside of your control.

A lot of survivors have this perception that getting the hatch magically turns a loss into a win. Which is obviously wrong, they definitely lost the match, the hatch is just a consolation prize for the losing survivor.