Honestly I'd recommend playing Jill and Isabella's routes as well as Sage's, they all serve different quirks.
Sage is the popular, sexy and wild young girl, like the anon above said, retard proof but then you have Jill for the incels, she's so naive that at some points her route can truly be retardedly hilarious, it's worth it just for that imo. And Isabella's is more of a "forbidden fruit" style of run but I was pleasantly surprised by it, I was expecting it to fall of a cliff in terms of quality and engagement once we finally "conquered" her due to the the thrill of the chase ending but pinkcake is honestly doing a good job, you look at her in season 1 and in season 3 and it's night and day, fucking great character progression.
It's only Josy and Maya's route that I have an issue with, I honestly can't bother or care to deal with those two at the same time. And it's not like I don't like them, I like Maya, Josy seems like a bit of a brat, but I found their route extremely mid.