That one Slenderman game that is half walking simulator freaked me out. I legit dropped it halfway through at the part where you’re in some sort of basement in some wooden shack and there’s some witch looking woman there. I just went “fuck this” and dropped it. Might come back to it later. It’s genuinely unsettling when you KNOW something’s coming for you and it knows your exact location. With shit like Amnesia you can at least hide and take things at your own pace, but with Slenderman you have to keep going and never look back.
That said I did get a little freaked out by this one pseudo-jumpscare in Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs though but that’s mostly because I was high as shit at the time. Also the teleporting electric pig was genuinely fucking unsettling. Just its whole existence being this sort of horribly disfigured experimental creature that constantly warps in and out of reality as it chases you down and probably feels incomprehensible pain just felt like an unsettling thing to think about. Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs felt genuinely unsettling at times in a way that the original game didn’t. The original Amnesia was just edgy and dark but aMfP gave me this horrifying feeling of sinking deeper and deeper into a horrible place no human should be in. Especially since you had that map thing that showed you where in the facility you were and teased what came next. It was dreadful to think about what horrors awaited you at the bottom of the facility.
I mean, just look at this fucking thing