If Yamato had Edward Weevil’s hulking, scarred, and brutish appearance—wild beard and exaggerated features—the One Piece fanbase would likely react with mixed feelings. Fans who admire Yamato’s fiery spirit, defiance of Kaido, and Oden-inspired resolve might still embrace her, seeing the contrast between her noble heart and monstrous look as a daring narrative twist. However, many would find Weevil’s comical, thuggish design jarring, undermining her poignant moments, like her stand against Kaido or Wano’s liberation, making them feel unintentionally absurd. Her gender identity, already debated, would face further scrutiny with Weevil’s hyper-masculine appearance, potentially alienating fans who connected with her original androgynous appeal. Discussions on platforms would likely split, with some praising Oda’s bold subversion and others criticizing the tonal clash.

The push for Yamato to join the Straw Hats would likely weaken. Fans valued her strength and bond with Luffy, but Weevil’s appearance might feel visually and narratively out of place on the Sunny. In the Wano morning scene with Nami, Momonosuke, and Robin, Yamato’s absence from the crew feels more fitting with such a design, as her imposing look suits a Wano protector role over a Straw Hat’s dynamic. Fans might debate her strength as an asset but argue her appearance makes her less cohesive with the crew’s vibe. Acceptance would likely dip, with fans divided on whether the design enhances her arc or detracts from her emotional depth.

actually we love yamato here