Red Dead Redemption 1 is superior to 2
>no shitty aim sway that makes you miss on purpose
>not limited to two rifles
>great soundtrack
>better characters
>less tedious hunting
>horses aren't annoying (i.e. they don't run into trees face first or trip over small rocks)
>better honor system, 2's removes missions from your playthrough
>less convoluted story, don't even remember a quarter of 2's story

People only think 2 is better because they think more = better