I'm actually playing it for the first time bros.
All I can report so far is that i'm beyond pleasantly surprised. I listened to /v/ for once (had no choice because I initially had a shit PC and only a PS4 so didn't try it out on release) but I managed to get it on a sale a year ago and ran out of games recently so I installed it.
>combat is unironically 10/10 (katana + Pistol build with the odd sniping)
>city is beautiful
>Main story is surprisingly engaging at least so far
>waifus aren't ugly (CDPR have yet to let me down here)
>gigs are some of the most fun i've had in RPG missions. Literally just Deus Ex Human Revolution tier police station levels but with actual gameplay that doesn't amount to button click cover systems + QTE tier stealth takedowns. (shit ton of ways to do them too)
Haven't gotten close to completing it either and I haven't started the DLC (which I hear is great). Unless this game turns into MGSV The Phantom Pain and begins literally recycling missions or some retarded shit, I don't see how this game could ever be anything but pure KINO