>>718399989
Just for you, anon. Kind of sorted, but I'd move the Dualsense and IINE two spots right if I had to use them exclusively since they have the worst d-pads (especially the IINE) outside of the garbage bin.

>>718403526
Gulikit Elves 2, Saturn pad with a prominent pivot. I've heard votes of confidence from fightan autists on Tegenaria Lite being an improved DS4, but can't vouch personally.
I think most mech d-pads are fine too, but many people seem to not like how hard you have to press for diagonals on them, even if they typically otherwise have clean inputs.