Named IDs heavily depend on how they're actually handled.
For example Nellyshu and the Fullstops still feel like the sinners themselves and what they would have been like if they were put into this specific situation, how they would act and other things.
And then there are the bad ones like the bloodfiend trio that are just exact copy pastes of the characters its referencing and the original sinner is nowhere to be seen.

So I have no strong opinions about them, sometimes they're good sometimes they're good. Not replying to anyone in particular, just felt like giving my own thoughts on it since its the topic.