>>718281218
The second one is awful, but the third is genuinely great and was directed by the original writer. It's maybe more bizarre than scary through much of it but it's really good.
>>718281306
I used to have a whole angle about it but I can't remember most of it. I'm pretty sure it was actually 4 that took the most from it, the dead serial killer who comes back and all. The distant roaring you sometimes hear is 100 percent from it though. It's really distinct.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JT0Im48hjRk

Never the less, yeah people always wanna make big theories about silent hill's message and meaning when you should instead watch lots of good classic horror movies.