>>96751086
>Literally false and wrong.
It's niche stuff, but it's stuff.
Souls can dissolve, they can split and they can be involved in a lot of shit.
Eldar reincarnated at will, lacking a will to continue, they would accept death and move on, not to mention you cannot possibly consider all the eldar currently alive as indicative of all the eldar that ever lived because of slaanesh both changing how they behave and express, and devouring the vast majority of their race.

If you make wild claims and ignore the perfectly viable possibilities that go against that, you're not arguing in good faith, you're just closing your eyes and repeating your own fanfiction as if doing that would make it correct.