I've read well over 100 VNs over the years. Umineko is still the best. I've read them all, you can try me if you don't believe me. I can also describe in detail the things I dislike about Umineko if you think I'm just a fanboy or something. I'm just saying that I can do the same with whatever VN you will claim to be better, and I guarantee you that I will find more numerous and severe flaws there. Rance, Muv-Luv, Chaos;Head, Baldr Sky, White Album, Muramasa, Utawarerumono, Dies Irae, Kimi ga Nozomu Eien, Clannad, Summer Pockets, SakuMoyu, doesn't matter.