>>718442267
>There isn't a single genre controllers are the 'best' at.
3D platformers.
WASD or arrow keys are ASS for controlling a character in 3D space. Really, anything that requires moving a character with more than 8 statically strong directions of input is superior with a analog stick.
Perfect controller setup for just about everything is a Wii Nunchuck with a few extra buttons and one of those mice with a shit-ton of buttons on it (pic related).