>>28642101
>country still not mentioned
>climate and scenarios partially disclosed only after a reply
Here's a hint how to ask questions to increase the probability of real answer. I don't think there is a lot of people here knowing these exact models of tires, let alone having driven all three. Maybe post a pic of all three, some tires are easy to rule out just by looking at them (like those obviously 4season not winter dedicated) and pics tend to attract attention.
As for the spikes, see pic. Sorry to learn you're not allowed, they are probably the best against black ice.