>>536905106
I think it's CS1 and 2. To name an example, people say CS1 is peak comfy, but to me it was always OG Sky and playing the demo just reaffirmed that for me. I just don't think a lot of Class VII and Rean were interesting characters. 2 I think handled a heavily foreshadowed plot point terribly and on top of the third path just having been playing into Osborne's hands, which to be fair I guess should not be very surprising since the noble alliance held most of the cards and had the upper hand so it makes sense to disrupt their operations and shit.
I also don't think the games made that good a point of showing that Class VII is when these kids finally found a place they "belonged" to.
3, 4 and Reverie of course have faults too, but the hate for 4 in particular I really just don't get, and I say that as someone that thinks the Curse is wack.