Previous Thread:
>>96252817>Most recent bracket system updatehttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-april-22-2025
>Outline article introducing the bracket systemhttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/introducing-commander-brackets-beta
>Current banlisthttps://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned
>Former Commander website, where you can learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committeehttps://mtgcommander.net
>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internethttps://www.edhrec.com
>Deck list site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choiceshttps://www.archidekt.com
https://www.moxfield.com
https://www.tappedout.net
>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identityhttps://managathering.com
>Gay Bolashttps://e621.net/post/index/1/nicol_bolas
>Card searchhttps://scryfall.com
>Make custom cardshttps://magicseteditor.boards.net
https://mtg.design
https://mtgcardsmith.com
>Proxy a deck or a cube for cheaphttps://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM
>How to proxy using any printerhttps://mtgprint.cardtrader.com
>Preconshttps://magicprecons.com
>TQWhich color, or color combo, is the most privileged?
>>96255377 (OP)>gay bolas back in opConfirmed faggot
>I play Simic
How to spot a subhuman NIGGER in 2 seconds
>>96255394Yes Bolas is a fag.
>>96255337summerfags from reddit
>>96255397>>96255404damn what if that little shrimp was emrakul...
>>96255354>he's still going>I said one thing about bug chasers and went to sleep, this fag is still crying about itkeeeek
>>96255377 (OP)>TQDUDE
>appears at your tableI KNOW ITS BORING
>evades several years of bansBUT
>warps the entire metagame around itself just by existingI CAST
>backed up free counterspells for your interactionTHASSA'S ORACLE
>gets immunity to bans thanks to GC listI AM HOLDING THE PRIORITY
>ruins an entire generation of playersBEFORE IT RESOLVES
>creates an offshoot format solely because nobody wants to deal with itI CAST DEMONIC CONSULTATION
>is in a color combo that can easily find both piecesNAMING
>package is so small every UBx deck can include it for freeNIGGERMAN XDDDDDDDD
>wins the game
>>96255418Wrong pic, I meant to posted this
>>96255425Why is this card not banned? Unironically explain to me how it benefits the game.
>>96255425Truly a Thoracle vs Angel's Grace meta.
>>96255032bracket 2 is such a wet fart of a joke
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>96255425You know the worst part is that EDH has degenerated so far I don't even think this is the biggest outlier issue anymore. It's self-contained value engines that allow you to draw all the tutors/countermagic/combo pieces into your hand.
>>96255430I have seen thoracle appear in a single game that wasn't cedh, and it was in a mono-U merfolk deck. It's an underwhelming winmore card without ad naus/consultation instantly clearing your deck for it to win the game.
I think I might be into futa now, commanders for this feel?
>>96255573felothar, breya, vannifar
I love Thalia. I wish I could kiss her but I can't and never will. I love to imagine her buttermilk hair shining in the moonlight, I wish I could keep watch with her from the stone parapets of Thraben and see her bluish eyes reflecting little orange pinpricks of torchlight. I wish I could hear her voice, sweet but strong. I wish I could carry her when she is injured in battle, take her to safety. I would take a hundred arrows in my back for her, as many as it took to kill me, to keep her safe. I would bleed for Thalia without question. I understand why Odric did what he did. Even after 3 years I still love her, part of me does. I don't know what it is. Maybe just an idea. My girlfriend left me because I couldn't get hard for her. Is probably have the same problem if I married Thalia. I am utterly worthless scum. I had my testosterone measured and it was only 600. I'm in shape but still skinny and weak. So not really in shape. I am too weak to even die for Thalia as cannon fodder to keep the beautiful guardian of Thraben alive. Sometimes I imagine her ramming her rapier up to its beautiful basket hilt into my scrawny chest and purging my worthless existence from this world. I don't feel like that other times, but when I think of her true beauty and purity and perfection and virtue, I cant help feeling utterly worthless by comparison. Lost my job and maybe I will just play Magic til the money runs out. In some ways it hurts too much to play a deck with Thalia in it.... In other ways it is just the sort of pain that I need.
>>96255425That's cool bro, here draw some extra cards.
>>96255733>imagine defending this butt ugly art>it's good because it's oldthere, some takes so bad they are funny
So I recently got into commander by playing some precons, and I had a lot of fun. I was thinking of trying to make my own deck and stick to a theme while doing it. My friend said going tribal is an easy way to start (e.g. all goblins with Krenko as commander), but some guy at our LGS who we were playing with said that's bad since tribal sucks and doesn't teach you how to build. What should I do?
>>96255928That guy likely got his shit pushed in by Krenko.
Just pick a playing style/commander you like, scryfall for cards that work well with it, put some lands and draw cards in. It doesn't matter if it sucks at first, you can just build from there.
>>96255928what theme do you like, anon?
>>96255942That was exactly my idea.
>I like red, red is fun>goblins are cool>oh dude Krenko can make exponential amounts of goblins>what if I make a deck where the entire board overflows with goblins I guess it's just a question of which goblins to use, as well as any sorceries/artifacts and instants I'd want to include.
>>96255950Goblins. It seems absolutely silly to me to just be running around with a gorillion 1/1 token goblins, buff them up, and then murder massive legendary creatures with swarm tactics.
>>96255928Ignore the faggot saying tribal sucks and build a good (non-pushed) creature tribal deck. Remember that it doesn't just mean all vamps or cats, you can have fun dumb things like haste tribal.
Tribal is an excellent way to deck build because it forces limitations and creative thinking on you while you learn to deck build, as opposed to just making a good stuff slop pile with budget X/Y/Z. That's why you avoid the pushed races when you make your first deck(s) because it's too piss easy to build busted shit with elves/goblins/dragons/zombies/wizards/etc.
>>96255953Keep in mind that Krenko decks live or die depending on if they can get haste or not since no ne will let you untap with that thing on board.
>>96255984Yeah I figured. Thankfully red has a lot of options, like even Tannuk from the new set.
I've been looking at self mill builds to get ideas. Is there a reason nobody runs these? They are very strong in other formats.
>>96255994What makes you think no one runs them?
>>96255953also people will focus you for playing an infamous combo commander, no matter if you have it in the deck or not
there is muxus if you want another option for a lower power deck
>>96255998None of the builds online I see have either. Sometimes they have the delve murder spell, but thats about it.
>>96256006I guess they're afraid of one time +1s or +2s and just use Rhystic and Fish. Either that or they feel bad removing cards from their grave.
>>96255994I run them both in Sin, delve is great and lets me control Sin's inherit randomness a bit by weeding out pieces I don't want to revive.
>>96255999My friend did that last week, sorta.
>Eldrazi deck with Ulalek>he manages to get an early flash option>whips out Zhulodok>makes TWO Zhulodoks and cascades 4 times>proceeds to wipe everyoneThat shit felt like cancer, and it kinda makes me want to build an Eldrazi deck some day.
>>96256026pretty much every tribe can pop off but eldrazi are known for those high end bombs if left unchecked
>two zhulodoksone would have died to the legend rule but ulalek can still copy that shit later to have 4 cascades yeah
>>96256091I guess that's what happened. All I could think was "wait he get to cycle through his deck FOUR times and gets to play shit for free FOUR times?" It just ended up with 3 titans hitting the board and everyone getting deleted because Ulamog had Annihilator 8 on him. I took a cursory glance at the cost of Eldrazi cards, and they're all batshit insane.
>titans go for $40 each>most of his lands were in the $50-$100 range>even some of the spells were $50+>entire deck was hovering near $2,000And here I am trying to make a Goblin deck for like $100.
>>96256091Also, since my brain didn't work much that night, how DOES Ulalek work? From what my friend told me:
>Ulalek can pay CC to copy something if you cast an Eldrazi spell (AKA everything in a tribal deck, for the most part)>this makes a duplicate copy of the spell (including creatures, which create a token copy which has all their abilities)>IF you have flash, you can slap down a bunch of things at instant speed, and because everything is flash, it's all on the stack, and thus you can copy the entire stack instead of just one spell/creature for a single cost of CCIs that right? Beacuse if so, that seems fucking wacky.
Look at me, I'm now the spellslinger deck.
How do we feel about shapeshifters in tribal decks?
>>96256164Perfectly fine. Anyone complaining about it are bad at making decks.
>>96256164They're funny guys, and it fits their lore for them to be sneaking into random tribal decks.
>How do you do, fellow [insert random species here]?
>>96256164Kind of a necessary evil for any smaller tribe with less support. I'm glad they exist even if it's not the best solution.
>>96256106eldrazi are the most popular tribe so yeah the prices are up there if you don't print yourself. however, the feeling of beating someone running better/expensive cards with a budget deck is the feeling I try and chanse every game
>>96256141yeah sounds about right and it is powerful flash just makes it instant speed which is even more so. he could copy everything on the stack on his turn anyway but flash enables that he can put more things on there essentially. explaining it is a bit cumbersome and sometimes when I try tell how things work in the game (even after the basics) it feels like I'm making shit up so I get it lol
>>96256175>explaining it is a bit cumbersomeIs there some sort of guide on exactly how it works? I still need to wrap my head around him.
this mfer gives some serious pedo vibes.
even the way he talks gives off "i fiddle with kids and spend some afternoons near schools".
>>96256164>tribalits kindred
>>96256164Are there any good ones outside of green? I only ever use Realmwalker and Masked Vandal
Made my Terra deck a simple Alesha-esque deck with as many legendaries jammed in as I could. 56 creatures. It's been pretty cozy thus far.
>>96256246Tauren Mauler and the 1/1 unblockable one have their niches
>>96256224I tried, but most people just give the explanation I was given (
>>96256141). I was hoping there was a more detailed guide, unless that's all there is to it?
>>96256246Mirror Entity is one of the best wincons for wide white decks.
My friends and I want to do another deck exchange and we need to exchange names soon, but we are still trying to pick a restriction. Last year we did where everyone had to build partners, it turned out really well.
What would be another fun restriction? One thing I was thinking was we'd randomly pick a popular tribe, like humans or goblins or something, and we'd have to build that. If any anons have an idea I'd love to hear it.
>>96256316well it's because the rules of the card are tied very closely to the base mechanics so to explain how the card works one would have to explain all the basic mechanics like the stack. in all simplicity, eldrazi sometimes have these cast triggers that go on the stack at the same time they are, that is before resolving anything. they can then copy those by paying CC. if they have flash, they can respond to their own spells at instant speed by putting more stuff on the stack and THEN copy all that shit. that's it
He looks like he gets fucked by human men.
>>96256570such a shitty card
>>96256589Goes infinite with Gitrog
>>96255427Please stop larping as a Christian on the internet anon its weird.
>>96256219My guy you're a 19 year old zoomer. Calm down and get a real hobby lol
>>96256570I had him in my sidisi zombie brew but took him out.
>wake up
>Reddit atheist still seething and rage posting
Top kek
>>96256741>new thread starts>bitch about old thread because your ego wont allow you to move on (despite being wrong here)>someone replies to your botching 6 hours later >heh I slept after making a fool of myself no one else did!You need to go back to church my guy and read about how Jesus behaved because you are not a Christian
Since warp is still considered as casting the spell can I reduce its cost?
>>96256760Yep, AND you can negate the "downside" of warp with Sundial for extra funny shenanigans.
>>96256768Nice, just the confirmation that I needed.
>>96256760You sure can fella!
>>96254949To be fair, the dragon line is literal flavor text.
I've got a buddy who will sell me full sets of lands for $5 per set. Which sets should I get from him for general edh deck buulding? He's got all the stuff like bounce, pain, triome, fetch, shock, etc.
>>96256543If you would lose the game, you win the game instead.
No conceding, no infinite combos, no Pact of Negation etc
>>96256797if you can't afford buying all of those proxies for $5 a set then you have bigger problems
>>96256844>proxiesSir I only use legitimate WOTC product.
>>96256756You don't have to keep replying you know, but by all means keep seething and acting schizo, you're not really beating the allegations here kek
>>96256797Why would anyone do this
>>96256850>doesn't deny his inability to buy multiple $5 setsngmi
>bring friend of mine whose good at competitive card games to commander night last few weeks
>hes totally new to mtg in general
>has won 3/6 of our last matches
>one of our guys is fucking pissed and feels like said friend is intentionally downplaying his ability and is threatening to find a new group
Hes genuinely new to magic, but hes grinded other games like yugioh and hs for years, and hes definitely downplaying his ability.
I only started commander last year and made this group myself. First time I've seen one of our players get so heated about something. The table constantly tries to coach him on optimal plays, which he ignores, and wins anyways, so I'm wondering if they view it as a respect thing.
bigbutt
md5: 0ab015d1f66e78180556538175eb72f7
🔍
They didn't need to make the game much easier for new people.....
>>96256797Your "buddy" is ripping you off
>>96256874Yeah it's pretty fucking egregious. Like they couldn't find anything else to do other than make a 1:1 improvement of an old beloved card?
>>96256871What deck is he playing and what is the meta in your group?
>>96256920>>96256897Since he was a yugioh player, I imagine he went to reddit and made a fast combo deck and the timmies are upset their wurm decks are losing on turn 5. I don't know, but I'm pretty sure this is close to accurate.
>>96256920Hes playing other peoples decks and just rotating right now.
Like last night, he won with a blue/black faerie control deck.
A couple nights prior he one with someone's mono black mill/GY deck.
I tend to play a lot of mono red, but the meta with our group is usually a lot of white with a fuck load of token generation, or voltron.
>>96256932Negative, he pretty much plays whatever I or someone else gives him at the moment. But I wouldn't be surprise if he did that with his own deck when he builds one this weekend.
>>96256906I believe there's a lot of truth in what someone once said about this kind of thing:
"It's not powercreep to print a better version of a card nobody is playing".
>>96256941>Hes playing other peoples decksabsolute slill issue, they're mad he (a new player) is beating them (experience player) with random decks (that they made and he is unfamiliar with), so they can't even use decks and cards as an excuse
>>96256943Disingenuous. No one is playing either of these except in the casual 99-card format, and in those instances Doran works fine as toughness matters. Instead of a pushed-to-shit wincon with obscene draw engine slop stapled on.
>>96256974It's balanced because he costs one less mana!
>>96256974Hi, welcome to the casual 99-card format. We hope you enjoy your stay.
>>96256986For one more mana, you got a defender enabler, sac outlet, and draw/discard engine, WOWZER!!!!
>>96256989>stopped reading halfway into the sentence
>>96256974I've been of the opinion for a while now, that wizards has been progressively shaping commander to much more closely resemble the pacing and tempo of 60 card formats, not as a side effect of pushed cards, but intentionally
Eventually they don't want it to be "the casual format" but "THE format"
I am NOT going to be baited into an argument with mentally unstable people today!
IT'S. NOT. HAPPENING.
>>96257018You're reading into it. It's just an easy way to sell cards.
>card, but strongeris how you get your average Timmy to throw out their previous card and get the new card
>>96257013Man I wish I didn't read the first half either but here we are. You want disingenuous? You owe the 2/2 1G bear a fucking apology.
>>96256089>they secret laired my wifeI feel insulted.
>>96256871Reminds me of that Cardmarket commander game where Mengu beat the crap out of the others and he rarely play the format.
>>96256589You and I are enemies now
>>96257034Your wife pleases colossi for mana.
>erm, your deck is too TUNED for bracket x
What the fuck does this mean? Do you just have to give yourself brain damage until you forget basic fundamentals of deckbuilding to play at brackets under 4?
>>96257107you're too good at deckbuilding that's what it means
>>96257107I unironically have this trouble with my friends who are all very amateur deck builders just getting back into the game with FF cards and even my bracket 2 decks get called out for being to well tuned because I have some ramp and an actual mana base in them and know how to keep a man curve under control.
>>96257139I just don't understand the delineation. Do you have to take the precon mentality and just have a random pile of 10 cards thrown in that have nothing to do with your strategy?
>>96257107its a compliment, you have autism.
>>96257107>>96257149From what I've deduced, since I've been in a similar situation:
>any random pile of shit = 1>precon straight out of the box, no changes = 2>you bought a few cards for like $50 or less = 3>you have some big boy cards (ancient tomb, etc) = 4>you're sweaty = 5
>>96257149>good mana base that hits your pip requirements>understanding how your deck should curve out>avoiding clunky creatures that don't have immediate value>having a plan B and C>comboing out with cards that do something else for you outside of the combothese aren't things the average casual understands
>>96257198Ancient Tomb is a gamechanger and therefore bracket 3
>>96257107It either means your friends are bad at the game or you're doing the retarded bit where you claim brackets are based on "vibes" and you are therefore justified in making cracked decks because daddy isn't going to give you the belt over the number of tutors you've jacked into your "Bracket 2".
>>96257204Everything but that last one is just knowing how to deckbuild. Combos are cringe though.
>>96257221you'd be surprised how many people still play 36 lands with a 4cmc average
3275
md5: c373d45f75c778e92729526ac2839aab
🔍
>bigger lgs chain getting massive restock of ff precons
>prices still not adjusted from the release stock pricing
>yshtola still highest cost even if cardmarket has been dropping price to 3rd from the roster
This doesn't make sense. Shouldn't these stores start to adjust other stores are adjusting to market price?
>>96257221Except for A+B+C+D+E+F combo
>>96257246>buying precons>has presumably played EDH for more than three yearsJust stop being a buyfag tourist
I want to run this lil nigga in a deck because I like its effect and Samwise is my favorite character in LOTR but I hate dealing with extra mechanics like ring temptation. Granted, I can just hypothetically run this as my only tempt card and I would just have to deal with it for a bit until my ring-bearer dies, yeah?
>>96257249Nah, when I moved away from combo or random "I win" cards ala Craterhoof or Hailfire, I started having way more fun playing.
>>96257253This
Don't do what I did. I have about a dozen shitty precons taking up precious space on my nerd shelf. As soon as I started having kids space became more of a precious commodity than money.
>>96257233ngl
based
I keep a bad deck around just in case I run into people like that.
>>96256164Fine as long as you're not running maskwood nexus, then you're just lame and boring
>don't mind playing with game changers
>DO mind people trying to win on turn 3
Why is there no slot between brackets 3 and 4? The power gap is colossal.
>>96256164>weI don't care. Being overly concerned about what people put in their decks is cringe.
>>96256164My friends fucking seethe when I slot a bunch of changelings to pad out a tribal deck. But then they seethe if the tribal deck has a single creature outside its type, so I've just gone on to ignore every single criticism they've made.
>>96257277>dozensShouldn't you be more comfortable with just couple? I see it a little crazy to have more than pod sized amount of decks.
>>96257233>mfw run 36 lands with a 3.4cmc averageI like to live dangerously
>>96257302exactly
so whats the real difference between brackets one and two anyway? are there people out there really trying to brew decks worse than the average precon? and are these people upsetty spaghetti enough to warrant their own bracket?
bracket one should be precons, 2 should be upgraded precons including some game changers. then 3, 4 and 5 should be whatever's left I dont really care.
>>96257326There was a time where my friends were way more into edh than they are now and I got into the habit of buying every set of precons when they came out because they would come to me to buy them. I would keep the leftovers and sell them once they went up in price. I got left with a lot of the worst ones that are still like 30 bucks and a bunch of japanese ones that I thought would be cool but nobody wants.
>>96257336bracket 1 is sovl
bracket 2 is winning soul
bracket 3 is middle ground
bracket 4 is waifu
bracket 5 is cedh
>>96257336Bracket one is a worthless bracket. It's less played than CEDH, the idea being you didn't build your deck to win or even play. But to show off a stupid theme like "Look I have every letter of the alphabet on the board."
The truth being, if you're running a bracket one deck and you want to "power match" other bracket one decks, you're actually a loser. You should sit down with your bracket one gimmick at a real table without telling anyone that you're essentially playing a different game than them.
They'll realize when all the cards in your deck start with J.
I dislike "precons" and "upgraded precons" as the basis because it implies that building your own fucking deck is the exception and not the rule.
>>96257352Your waifu deck a shit
>>96257355>You should sit down with your bracket one gimmick at a real table without telling anyone that you're essentially playing a different game than them.>They'll realize when all the cards in your deck start with J.not gunna lie, I have been on the receiving end of this and it was pretty funny.
The theme was something like
>cards from sets released in x monthand it was fucking atrocious
>>96257355How many lands can you possibly fit in a J deck?
>>96257366Only a retard would view it that way
>>96257381It's precisely how it's worded
>>96256864$5 for all 10 fetches is cheaper than MPC.
>>96257366I mean for people first getting into the game and figuring things out, I'd assume a precon and then tweaking to get rid of the ass is the standard practice
I was once feared across the table.....
>>96257394He's still strong as fuck.
>>96257394is it no longer?
>>96257392Watch out, anon. You might bring in the tourist haters.
>>96257209I agree, but people at my LGS insist that if you start using "expensive" cards (Eldrazi Titans, Ancient Tomb, Gemstone Cavern, Caverns of Souls, Eye of Ugin, to name a few), you fly straight to tier 4.
>>96257267Yes. You can even just crack a fetch, then flash him in to get it back. Lots of generic use cases.
>>96257399>tourist so defensive he brings up boogeymen who dislike him
>>96257373I WILL bling out jasmine boreal with all the GCs because she's my wife
>>96257246Speaking of that, how the shit does yshtola even work? Her precon seems to be a total mess. I get that she's the waifu pick of the bunch, so that's why people want her, but still.
Looking at the brackets again, did they forget to establish a meaningful difference between brackets 4 and 5?
This whole thing reads like a rough draft, maybe even a rough rough draft.
>>962574214 means you're playing land denial, meta cards, game changers, etc. 5 means basically every card in your deck is a $50+ cost card, with some monster shit like Gaea's Cradle mixed in.
>>96257421One of them is CEDH and the other one is not. You're free to guess which is which but if you get it wrong everyone at your junior highschool is going to laugh at you.
>>96257421i know you hate anime but people have waifus and you're just going to have to accept that
>>96257430That's not what it means at all you fucking moron
>>96257421One is cEDH(casual), the other is cEDH(competitive).
>>96257430>Gaea's Cradle>cedhrofl
>>96257450wasnt there a Tana partner deck that used cradle? Some kind of pod monstrosity iirc.
I stopped caring after partners were released and they killed my sweet prince grenzo.
>>96257450>>96257442>this nigga doesn't run overpriced cards just to flex on the poors
>>96257465>they killed my sweet prince grenzoyour waifu still has a home in bracket 4
>>96257465Yeah, the point being most cedh decks do NOT run Gaea's Cradle.
>>96257472sounds like you really didn't have a point to begin with.
>>96257472It works fine in certain decks. Just because every deck isn't running it like tomb doesn't mean it's bad.
6255916
>still triggered by it
>still no counterargument
Well done replying to yourself as well
>>96257469I tried, it sucked. Plus cEDH people aren't exactly the types you hang around with for their glowing personalities. I found more satisfaction in leaving and not looking back.
>>96257492i'm not saying you play with cedh
i'm saying you play with sharuum, prossh, and the guy who loves yuna from ff10 so much he blinged her out
>opponent points out Evolution Witness only allows me to return permanent cards from graveyard, not any cards
>tfw
Haha, yeah. Of course. Was just checking if you guys would notice. Heh. Let me quickly scoop out of rage and shame.
>>96255916So you're response is "nuh-uh"? Got him there, buddy.
It's totally not shitty art now, because it's old. lmao
>>96257510It's furry art and that retard is clearly a a furry. Ignore him.
>>96257504oh, yeah that's basically what I did. Though desu it's still way too strong for a lot of those tables. I keep it sleeved up but it just sits there.
I've even started pulling cards out of it and replacing with proxies.
>>96257366None of that is implied, but keep seething tho.
Werewolf tribal deck, will it be fun? Any unique wolf/werewolf cards or is it mostly good grull cards?
>>96255706I like his new cards more, miss his old artstyle though
>>96257536it will be the worst mtg has to offer and reposting this question every other thread wont change the answer
They really are pushing red as the next color for mana dork
>>96257634Makes up for them not having draw or enchantment removal
https://moxfield.com/decks/gq8s7hWWjkO8b-e3gddV0g
Are your feelings pleasent or unpleasent towards this deck, want to do wacky Grenzo
>>96256756>I understand your religion better than you!Don't listen to the other guy, please keep posting because you're retarded and hilarious.
>>96256874This pissed me off. I was gonna make a Doran deck and then they made that fag
>>96257700>wacky>has an infinite Redcap loopNo
>>96257785Do it anyway Anon. If there's anything Doran has taught us it's that soul is more important than power.
>>96257721Its my religion anon. And considering you told someone they're going to hell, what i said is true. Only God knows where anyone will end up. That added with your vitriolic behaviour (very unchristlike dont bring up the temple we arent there) I can safely call you out, one christian to another, as we have been commanded to in the Bible ^.^
>>96257634Making red a ramp color feels weird, but it is pretty far behind compared to the other 4.
>they need ramp
Meanwhile I'm shitting out endless goblins and just throwing them at everything.
>>96257634>the faggots who earn their living making videos about commander are pushing the narrative of mana dorks bad>wotc starts printing red mana dorks againwho's in the wrong here?
>>96257825>Implying you follow your religion
>>96257910None of the red ones are played so the rampers as always
>>96257944maybe rampers are wrong and should play more red mana dorks.
A 2 mana red mana dork still allows you to play your mv4 commander on turn 3.
>>96257825I never told anyone they were going to hell. In fact I assumed that was the atheist guy. You're mixing me up with someone else
>>96257910Sloptubers are always in the wrong
>>96257910its pretty much always the content creators in the wrong.
>>96255452>>96255457Both auto includes if your playing white
>>96257976You can take it up with Jesus you've been rightfully called out my part is done
>>96257879Cool board anon!
>casts blasphemous act
>>96256325That goofy looking lil shit has won quite a lot of games in its day
teehee
md5: dbb58b0f2706c1dbbcc683e4b6c1a80a
🔍
Bracket 2 legal btw
>>96256774Sundial is probably the best card in my Purphros Bronze Blooded deck, and would probably be the same for Tannuk
>red dorks
I love the shit out of this little guy
He's an absolute all star in heartless het
>>96255457I've never played against the thoracle combo. In response to which trigger do you cast this? People who play that combo are pretty annoying and won't let you stop their win if you do it at the wrong time from what I've heard.
>>96258072idk, looks like that destroys multiple lands at a time
just because its spread over two cards doesnt make the outcome legal.
or maybe it does idk but I have a feeling most people would agree with me
>>96258072>not casting a farewall fuck everythingcoward
>>96258040Called out for what? I think you're gonna have some explaining to do yourself for your own apparent hubris, "friend"
>>96258113while i get your point the issue is that
>if a person wants to stall the game they will find a way, MLD or not, and gavin doesn't realize thisironically the randoms that brackets are meant for don't play shit like this to stall the game for lolz, it's the casual friend group playing in the basement that does this and they'll just rule zero this immediately after anyways
>>96258072>2 card combostraight to bracket 4 my friend
>>96256906>>96257785Felothar costs 1 mana more, and there is no rule that says you can't run Doran in your deck too (or Felothar as one of the 99)
>>96258072It isn't by the way.
>>96258072May or may not be depending on who you ask.
Which again objectively proves why brackets are garbage.
>>96258113But it isn't MLD. Neither card specifically destroys lands.
>>96256874>zoltan boros>borosDid they name the guild or whatever Boros is after him or is this just a coincidence?
>>96258146I've seen edhrec list many 2 card combos as not bracket 4 because they aren't super impactful or just lead to something like infinite mana.
>>96258072I prefer something that is more primal.
RG
>Ass beating of the ages
Splittest second
Until the end of your next turn, if an ability would trigger, it’s controller takes 3 damage instead. (Storm, suspend and annihilator are triggers for example)
>>96258040Remove the beam from your eye before calling out the mote in your brother's
>>96258184>doesn't cantripunplayable
>>96256943it's literally powercreep. you can argue that nobody was using the old card, so powercreeping in that case is fine as it wasn't strong enough to matter before; but it's literally powercreep.
that said, felothar is 1 mana more, which makes a difference sometimes, especially if you want to use doran to beat peoples' faces in with undercosted toughness boosting auras/equipment.
>>96258151>Neither card specifically destroys lands.ok, ill bite on this obvious bait.
the intention of the ban on destroying lands is not that the text on the card is to be avoided but the gamestate of having no more lands on the battlefield. In the same way that mass exiling lands or sunder is not "mass land DESTRUSTION" I think it is disingenuous to argue that it is allowable.
>>96258184Are you too retarded to use a custom card making website to generate your retarded ideas onto a fake card?
Someone try to convince me annihilator isn't the gayest ability out there. Getting bonked by some noodle armed fucker and having to delete my board BEFORE even going for damage is bullshit.
Trying to deside between a colorless commander. Any anons got input, personal experience, etc, to help me decide? Most interested in those with personal experience play with either one of them.
>>96258211Only the smelliest nerds play eldrazi in the first place.
>>96258202>you can argue that nobody was using the old cardI was. Still am but I was then too.
DESU the new art is ugly as sin and I have the cool doran so I don't care to change it.
IMG_1237
md5: 6c651a73e4c61eebd5e1ded648a7d650
🔍
>>96255425I use Thoracle in a deck that has no other obvious win condition (outside of storm combos, but fuck that noise).
This commander is a blast to play, but fucking tell me that this guy can actually win without something like this or lab maniac.
>>96258191You are welcome to point out my unchristian posts anon. I am a kind poster this isnt applicable :D
>>96258204>IntentionIntention is relevant. Rules as written are all that matter.
But again: You having to argue this at all instead of being able to point to a word for word ruling is why brackets are shit.
>>96256874>each creature >each creature YOU controlAre we just going to ignore that glaring difference between these two abilities? Because it's a drastic difference.
>>96258202People absolutely played Doran. He is a popular classic commander. Might as well justify power creeping Khalia.
>>96258221It's pretty important that Doran also serves as a bit of a hate effect. He says all creatures while the newer effects say "your" or even only "your creatures with toughness higher than their power."
As an aside, I've been surprised how relevant this guy has been in draft. Not just "my Lashwhip Predator is a 7/7" but it helps random red 4/5s and 1/3s as well.
>>96257267https://moxfield.com/decks/fSG0BE52AUCtB9d_dhHqbw
>>96258238And one is still objectively worse than the other
>>96258215colorless commanders kinda blow desu, you're only ever doing big eldrazi shit or artifact shit
>heh I just destroyed all the lands but its NOT mass land destruction cause...... im autistic!
>>96258215Kozilek if not focusing on artifacts. Liberator if you are.
Colorless is hot ass and unfun to play.
Tiers or power levels
Which is the superior deck grading?
>>96256774Alternatively things like conjurer's closet
>>96258259I don't grade decks. People bring their decks they want to the table and we play.
So, nothing.
>>96258215there's legitimate reasons to liberator run liberator, but if you're just going to run big eldrazis or play something besides tempo, just play Ultima.
>>96258215Marvin of course.
>>96258237i too like running proxy power 9 in my edh decks because bans are just kvetches from sheldon anyways
>>96258255It's like the difference between "attacks" and "attacking" anon. It's an autistic game.
>>96258237show me where in the bracket 2 rules only card with the words "destroy all lands" are siloed into the term "no mass land destruction".
from what I can see
>any... game plans that mess with several of people's lands or the mana they produce should not be in your deck if you're seeking to play in Brackets 1–3.But I would love to see what you think.
>>96257421I can build a deck that can win at a cEDH table but because it does not have a meta commander it will be labeled b4. What the fuck kind of decks are b4 and what decks T2/T3 cedh decks?
Not a fucking soul will tell you.
>>96258280Except its not because all lands are being destroyed. Both the setup and result are the same.
>golgari
Is this what EZ MODE feels like?
That open islands, USELESS.
>>96258287It's just like pretending to be Christian and being here on 4chan. You wouldn't get it.
Does the graveyard and it's versatility give MTG the edge when it comes to complexity and rewarding game knowledge as a TCG?
>>96258259Going though everyone's deck card by card to confirm their power level. It takes ages and is not worth it.
>>96258259>Which is the superior deck grading?formats
I'm sorry, no more land destruction going forward.
>>96257421since we're still having this conversation,
4 is "anything goes." there are no deckbuilding restrictions. you can be as mean as you want or as fast as you want.
5 is "competitive tournament viable." there is a meta, there are supporting sites, there are tournaments with prizes. you need to be fast to compete with other people who are fast, you need to stop people from winning in order to win. you need to stop other people from stopping you from winning.
>>96258314The rules in general is what keeps this game alive. Only reason why people still play it. Art doesn't matter, flavor text doesn't matter, since most of that is complete garbage since the beginning of mtg. It's the gameplay.
>>96258338right and this is why we have UB now :)
>>96258332MLD stands for mass lend denial, dummy. It's not about destruction. See blood moon.
>>96258215Id go Liberator, Koz would scare the table any likely try to take you out first. Also, flying commander's are good
>>96258314IMO it's the very literal wording, the stack and the allowing of interaction between cards and between players.
A lot of card games tend to say "no" to synergies between cards, mtg says "yes".
My experience with card games is limited to pokemon, mtg and like a dozen FFG LCGs.
>>96257420The 99 deck tries also giving kit for Graha'Tia, which makes whole deck pretty unfocused on specific playstyle.
>>96258335That's not true either, people are talking about cedh and tedh now, because not every cedh player goes to tournaments.
Thoughts on the 75% rule?
>>96258345Shakespeare was added pretty early on, you should've stopped playing mtg back then.
>>96258360>my deck is literally a 7.5It's hilarious how every single time someone tries to solve the restraint problem it boils down to the exact same non-solution.
>>96258306What on earth are you talking about?
>>96258335The problem with this thought pattern is that cEDH is a whole different format compared to tEDH, which means tournament edh. Tournaments have time controls, points politics and shit like that. Seatings.
If you host a cEDH game you do not get a tEDH game.
>>96258366i play mtg for the gameplay as you stated so why would i stop because of shakespeare lol
>>96258366who owns the license for Shakespeare? or Arabian nights for the matter?
>>96258356>A lot of card games tend to say "no" to synergies between cards, mtg says "yes". Infinites get struck down in other games really quickly, but it's fun to go infinite in MTG. Stuff like additional turns are unthinkable in other games, and paper-unfriendly token spam is another concept that I don't really see in other TCGs.
>>96258360>75% rule>the number 75 is not explained
>>96257825I don't think this is the place to discuss this, you religious retard.
>>96258378So the issue is license vs public domain?
>>96258378>it d-doesn't count becauseit's public domainI accept your concession for moving the goal posts.
>>96258371>Tournaments have time controls, points politics and shit like that. Seatings.>just like poker!>no money involved thoughit'll never work, it's a flash in the pan
Anons, in a mono black aristocratic deck, what is a good balance for pingers such as Blood Artist, Cutthroat, etc? Never built a aristocratic deck before
>>96258373I know, right? What's so bad about UB? lol
Imagine getting triggered by cards
>>96258367the restraint problem can only be solved when brackets are treated like formats, because none of this "7" talk is present in standard vintage modern etc
>>96258384It's ai, why even engage with it?
>>96258386for me personally, yes.
that being said I am glad that Arabian Nights was an anomaly of a set and that revisiting the concept later in MTGs history resulted in a significant MTGifying of the settings as opposed to taking a popular IP that I may or may not care about and shoving it whole cloth into an existing franchise that I do care about.
>>96258358you can play tournament level random pickup games at your LGS. not everyone wants to play in an actual tournament because of how annoying they can be.
I'd analogize it to pokemon (the video game). you can join a tournament, which requires placing in qualifying events events, travel, (sufficiently) legitimate 'mons, and sitting down across from people and playing; or you can play on a battle simulator where you punch your team in, queue up for a tournament ruleset match and it runs everything for you.
>>96258399i'm pro UB btw, because at least there i have a chance of seeing pretty women
>>96258404The restraint problem can only be solved by the players.
No amount of rules are going to get you any closer to solving it. The cardpool is too big, the players are too innovative and the worst angle shooters imaginable reside in this playerbase.
>>96258366Yes they did a thing said it was a mistake and said they wouldn't do it anymore. Heck they had an entire UB set in early magic
>>96258422>The restraint problem can only be solved by the players.obviously they can't because no two people will ever agree on anything, an officiating body is needed
again nobody talks about "muh 7 power level" in formats
>>96258367>>96258360You clowntards fail to understand why this framework works. Like the bracket system, it doesn’t exhaustively define itself, to weed out autists who require the guard rails and would optimize the fun out of it.
The point is to just make a deck that you can choose to play optimally if you need to sweat, but ultimately have lots of play for fun cards because it’s a casual format. A four person free for all is not a balanced or inherently competitive format to take seriously.
Example deck: https://archidekt.com/decks/13429111/kefka_max
how many % of your deck is just goodstuff slop that has nothing to do with your commander?
>>96258396>Sephiroth >Blood Artist >Bastion of Remembrance >Zulaport Cutthroat There you go, that is literally all you need. You're in black, you have card draw, recursion, and tutors.
I have never been "pub stomped" in 3 years even when playing a precon. No one ever sets power level in any pod I go to. It's something needed for fags who have a mental breakdown because some dude made infinite non-haste zombies.
>>96258434>1v1 is the only competitive thing>free for alls are not competitive everwhy is sprinting/racing an olympic sport again?
>>96258439I'll just play cEDH RogSi for that. None of the cards in the deck have anything to do with the commander.
>>96258439Isn't it meant to be like 40+ cards? 10 rocks, 10 removal, etc etc?
Some archetypes have 0 cards that do that stuff while supporting their commander.
>>96258434>replies to someone saying essentially the same thing as himWhat is it with /edhg/ and soapboxes
>>96258460Every deck should have 10 sources of ramp and 36 lands bare minimum. You go from there based off of colors and game plan
>>96258447Fair enough, thanks. I have them all, and yea was planning on adding a good ammount of recursion because Im using Vincent as the commander and plan on leaning in hard towards removal since Vincent want everything to hit the graveyard
file
md5: a743d0fb30d9d2b3a6e8079770d0bf9b
🔍
>>96258448Magic needs more maggots
>>96258072>Number Two!>This system (nor really any system) cannot stop bad actors.
>>96258477weird hot potato.
Anyone play her? Go all-in on faeries or flash tribal?
>>96258484>no system can stop bad actorsand yet nobody ever told me i'm a bad actor for running monstrous rage for as long as it was legal in standard, hmm weird how that works
>>96258477We have enough of them playing the game already
>>96258484How is he a bad actor? It's not bracket 2 in the slightest.
>>96258516He's a bad actor for trying to pretend like it is, despite obviously knowing its MLD.
>started playing in 2016
>bought a couple of precons which just released
>stop playing in 2017
>start playing again a couple of months ago
>want to use the partner commanders, but everyone will think that I'm a crazy try hard even though my collection is rather small and my decks are just janky piles of garbage
>challenge: not arguing with the deranged
>status: failed
>>96258539Go to your LGS and have fun. Disregard the sweaty nerds and salty losers.
>>96258539Which partner pairing?
>>962585572016 was the original four color precons with the two color partners everyone in cedh uses.
>>96258475So yes, many decks end up good stuff.
>>96258546I'm Christian and not deranged. The atheist, who I'm sorry G-d for repeating it, wished somebody to go to heck???? On 4chan. Imagine that. Unbelievable really.
>>96258573Can we get new 4 color commanders anytime soon?
>>96258603If you were actually Christian you wouldn't come to a site that screams about jews and killing trannies.
>>96258608R/atheism is that way. 4chan was always Christian.
>>96258608that's obviously a satirical post.
>>96258618actually it was always zoroastrian
>>96258620Not necessarily, have you seen the Bible thumpers and their retarded posts in this general?
>>96258629>On 4chan. Imagine that. Unbelievable really.no it's obvious. are you misinterpreting other satirical posts? are you getting trolled, anon? honest question.
>>96256692>t. pedook dude
>want to get as many phyrexian language cards for atraxa
>A bunch are only in foil
Should I just proxy them so I don't have to deal with dog shit foils
>>96258650>getting cards in a fake language that isn't even written rightI hate you. No one can read that shit.
>>96258608Where do you think we are right now
>>96258667Fake Christian heaven?
onering
md5: cf2b320b786decb3a532f487d86bb13d
🔍
>>96258660WOTC gave up on readability a long time ago.
KINO
md5: 58fde03dc4c22c6bb55ec0a3c5d6c749
🔍
>player 1: I cast Z to make my board indestructible, and then Y to destroy ALL permanents!
>player 2: I counterspell...
>player 1: ok, well my board is still indestructi-
>player 2: ...Z spell that makes your board indestructible.
>>96258697I can read those just fine.
>>96258639Is this satire
>>96257825 as well?
Pretty convenient that every post that makes those idiots look like retard is just a troll.
>>96258660They print cards in French and that's a fake language
My friends know what most cards do and it's easy to look up a quick translation
>>96258701>she doesn't run boseijungmi
>>96258716>xd French is not realYou cannot read that card. No one on Earth can. Even if you some how could, you'd need to turn it side ways because Phyrexian is written vertically.
>>96258650since when is a foil worse than a nonfoil?
(except for pricewise)
>>96258724When they started bending.
So...since Innistrad?
>>96258715it it's definitely not as obviously satirical as
>>96258603 is. at least by how it looks.
but we are on 4chan; weigh the chances of someone being sincere versus someone trying to get specifically you mad on purpose and make your own decisions.
>>96258724The wpn promos like blighted agent curl like shit, I've seen a few of them irl and I've never seen one that wasn't curled. At least the main set phyrexian cards come in non foil
>>96258745>The wpn promos like blighted agent curl like shitjust double sleeve, fucktard.
>final fantasy has a little bit of text showing you from which game this creature/artifact etc. is
Neat
>remember that there were already video game properties in mtg who could've done the same and didn't, because they're incompetent, I guess
Fallout and assassins creed.
>>96258697This is annoying but very readable
>>96258743Doesn't make me mad. Pretending to be be retarded/religious is just pathetic and hilarious.
>>96258757How about this one
>>96258701.........that's not how the stack works? The boardwipe would resolve first. Unless the counterspell player is cheating and wanted to rewind when the sorcery boardwipe was cast. You just made this bullshit up
>>96258667>same exact post as in the last threadDid you make a "I have to defend Christianity" bot or do just act like one?
>>96258767The stack totally works like that if the guy who cast the board held priority.
>>96258781*who cast the board wipe
>>96258771There is a non-zero amount of well poisoning going on. It's probably best not to discuss the merits or demerits of religion in this thread anyway.
>>96258701>>96258767>Sorcery boardwipeHis story seems to imply he casts it after the protection, while the stack is still being resolved. Which instant speed destruction boardwipe could he be talking about?
>>96258781Way to out yourself as someone who doesn't understand the stack.
>>96258781you would have to have cast them in the other order
i guess unless you are unironically playing rout in 2025.
>>96258715>>96258743No thats not satire. I dont see why I couldn't hang out in an EDH thread where NSFW material is not supposed to be posted, and I do not go anywhere but here ^.^
file
md5: f4ff70a837dfea8a273e57573268292d
🔍
>>96258792There's instant boardwipes, but they'd resolve before the all-indestructible spell resolves. His story is 100% bullshit
>>96258211annihilator is the reason why I run Sigarda so often in my decks. Fucking hate that shit almost as much as discard
>>96258789Yeah the atheist redditor realized he's losing so now he's just poisoning the well. Classic
>>96258771it's a quote from a tv show that was popular before you were born.
>>96258759you're reacting very strongly and apparently emotionally. actually mad or not, that's enough for most people, even if they also think that. as sincerely as you can possibly take this statement, ask yourself if you are being trolled.
>>96258794just get jugan for the inevitable DBZ UB
>>96258794Here is a list from a long time poster in this thread.
https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/yosei-a-good-mono-white-edh-deck-primer/
>Last updated 4 yearswhere are you, friend? we miss you!
>>96258794I wouldn't bother, he usually builds as a stasis deck forming loops with a recursion engine. You'll execute it once and the table will never let you get to 6 mana again
I usually go to my LGS on Fridays. But apparently there's a closer, less successful one half the distance away that does events on Tuesdays. Do I go?
>>96258810no, you are as well by acting like a lunatic. You give us a bad name.
>>96258781No you dumbass you made it up. You'd cast a boardwipe, THEN something to give all your shit indestructible, all while holding priority. Then the stack resolves in reverse order, making your shit survive
>>96258831yeah why not maybe you will like the autists there more
>>96258439I'm probably going to regret asking this, but what, in your opinion, is "goodstuff slop"?
>>96258824>yosei will all those rocksnow that's a bracket 4 deck, the guy literally married yosei lol
>>96258824Very based, thank you
>>96258825Stasis is blue.
>>96258834You too, because you're talking about your stupid religion instead of the topic of the thread
>>96258816>ask yourself if you are being trolled.You should do the same. Seething retard. Lmao
>>96258838So why can't he counterspell his protection spell again?
>>96258439>how many % (have) nothing to do with your commander?about 60%
>how many % are just goodstuff slopabout 40%
I like swinging with big creatures, there are only so many good ways to do that.
>>96258850>Stasis is blueThanks for clearing that up
When playing Yosei, the Evening Star as your general in the Elder Dragon Highlander format, your deckbuilding goal is to form what is colloquially known as a "lock" wherein your opponents are unable to untap any of their permanents similar to the blue card "Stasis"
>>96258870He can, the argument is "there's no fucking point" because the boardwipe would resolve first. So either he's telling a story and getting excited about being wrong, or he made it up
>>96258831Go to both. I have like 3 LGSes around me, but I really only liked the vibe of the last one I tried.
>>96258767I figured it was a highly summarized version of events where the guy wiping cast both spells without asking if anyone else had something to do, so someone said "I counter that," forcing a rewind. which isn't a great move on the counter-er's part givin that he's acting on "future" information, but he wasn't given an opportunity in the first place.
What I've learned playing magic with randoms is people have no fucking clue how rules actually work
>Imprison in the moon on someone's commander and they try to put it in the command zone
>Get told "holding priority isn't a thing"
>>96258878I'm not the guy who wrote the story with the counterspell, but I'm confused. Can you not cast let's say day of judgment with pic related with kicker to save your creatures, what?
>>96258831If you have a decent LGS by you I wouldn't roll the dice. I travel a lot for work and visit a lot of game stores, the quality of players has been slipping at an unprecedented rate. Covid fucked something up really bad and it hasn't seemed to have gotten better since.
7 decides the next selesnya commander I build, and the color of chastity cage I wear while playing it.
>>96258906You would need to cast the board wipes first. Then play your protection spell
Stack resolves backwards
>>96258846NTA but he means decks that don't actually utilize the commander. Like a first sliver deck thats just cascading into generic powerful cards, instead of an actual sliver deck.
>>96258878lol, I completely misread this story,
>>96258701because it's so dumb.
I've nevet seen it like that and just assumed he did it how it's normally played.
My bad
>>96258922>don't actually utilize the commander>cascading into generic powerful cardsidk sounds like he's utilizing it perfectly fine, he just doesnt have build-around-me-brain.
>>96258810>atheist redditorHe was clearly trolling you. Don't fall for bait this easily next time around.
He was idolizing Muslims and shitting on Christians, still don't see how that makes him an atheist by the way. Rent free
>>96258934For some reason people think you have to have a deck that can't play without the commander because they play with Timmy's that don't run removal
I had to stop building decks that are turbo commander focused so I could actually play the fucking game
>Wizard wil first make cards in fake languages rather than print Portuguese cards
wow much inclusive maro, really diverse
>>96258959Bootleg spanish
>unwritten rules are for some reason that you don't counter somebody's commander or play targeted removal to remove a commander
>New to this LGS, so I just try to play as as good I can
>don't cast my commander for most of the game, because I don't have anything to protect it
>remember in hindsight that nobody blew up somebody's commander
>meaning I could've cast it no problem and nobody would've done something against it
What do you call this playstyle?
Battlecruiser solitaire lovefest or something?
>>96258959silly anon, only USA diversity (mexicans. niggers and gays) is accepted, everything else is far right nonsence.
>>96258974>make up unwritten rules in your headreality is nobody is playing interaction because the pod is inexperienced.
>>96258992Mentally ill post.
>>96258896>exile it face down, I can cast it and so on >looks at it before passing it to the other player
>>96257634I like how they've totally given up on pretending treasures are red ramp.
>>96258944decks that require the commander are called budget decks
>>96258974>>unwritten rules are for some reason that you don't counter somebody's commander or play targeted removal to remove a commanderliteral gay tranny shit
>>96258996Happened many times in that lgs and they threw tantrums whenever I removed/countered a commander, followed by the whole pod focusing me down, so no, I didn't make up those rules.
>>96258992Mentally sound post.
>>96259018what do trannies have to do with it?
>>96258974>What do you call this playstyle?Someone Brings Tergrid
>>96259027They live rent free in his head, don't mind him
>card fits the general theme of the deck but doesnt advance my game plan to victory at all
this is the moment where I decide if my deck is bracket 2 or bracket 3, isnt it?
Does it kinda work as a space ship tribal?
I'm ever so slightly annoyed that there's no actual true space ship tribal commander, infinite guideline station doesn't even begin to work because most are mono-colored
>>96258906First in last out
>>96258906first in, last out. cards on the stack resolve in the reverse order of when they are played.
cast board wipe first, then protection: protection resolves, board is wiped and your creatures survive
cast protection first, then wipe: wipe resolves, protection doesn't protect because everything is dead
so either anon is a big fat phony, other player doesn't understand the stack, or he didn't give enough time for players to declare they had an action before cadting the second spell
>>96259057card looks good on paper but every game my friend was playing it the deck was fighting against itself.
a +1/+1 each combat is such a weak effect and the charge counters require some very specific cards which is kinda bad in a 99 singleton format.
the moment the second ability comes online it eats instant removal.
>>96258996I've seen plenty of pods like that, people genuinely have meltdowns of you shoot their commander even once
Or get upset if you have more then a single piece of removal in your deck
>>96258539Dude. I played from 2009-2012. I just recently got back into it. It's been fun tuning my decks with new cards.
>>96259089I get upset when two games in a row multiple people are going land go until my turn and answering everything I did while allowing another player to build a boardstate to attack me.
>>96258794Yeah don't. He's an instant kill commander, even though mono-white. He's a good piece of the 99 against a lot of decks.
>>96259090no, he's correct.
>>96259088there is some silly things you can do with charge counters but yes, it's a bit of a crapshoot in singleton
I just wish there was a 5c commander that did something unique with space ships, all I wanted from EOE was to assemble an armada and it's making it so god dang hard, the other space ship commander isn't even good for space ships it's pure landfall
>>96259089the only meltdown my pod had was enchantment based permanent commander removal against mono red.
>>96258539Which? There are different types. Do you mean the original "partner with whatever" ones?
>>96259055>muh heckin efficient path to victory!If you care about this just stop pretending your deck is low powered and accept you're a sweatlord and put the pushed card in Sweaty.
>>96259090explain to me how the stack works
>>96259083>or he didn't give enough time for players to declare they had an action before cadting the second spellThat happens a lot at my lgs
>you can't react to this anymore, hehehe>you didn't pass priority, so it's your fault for rushing this >nuh-uh>...
>>96259090You should read the rules no games
>>96258495Faeries. You want to be casting instants more than flash.
>>96259057No, there aren't nearly enough to make it work. Try again in another decade with the return to edge of eternities.
>>96259055Your intent makes your deck a 3 from the get go.
>>96259102No, he's incorrect.
I cast Akroma's Will. It resolves.
I cast Wrath of God. All creatures except mine are destroyed.
What kind of tranny thinks this doesn't work?
>>96259133I hate I have to wish for it but at this point I'd take a Star Trek UB just to get more ships
>Do nothing all game
>Try to cast my commander
>Bluenigger instantly counterspells it
There should just be a rule that commanders can't be countered.
Ships are awful. Vehicles were already a sketchy card type now we've got vehicles competing for the same niche.
>>96259152what kill on sight high mana commander were you casting that would have won you the game on the spot if it lived for longer than a turn?
>>96259125>First 2 players say they have no response to my toxic deluge >Last player also passes>I go to resolve my effect and the first player tries to activate something when they realize no one else has interaction >Tell him he can't respond anymore and he gets upset >4th player says he just wanted to be greedy with his removal and now he's getting punished >Player 2 starts yelling about people rule sharking him and working against him >He scoops and walks away from the table I've been to some really awful locals
>>96259148vehicle has a single decent low powered commander and the mechanic is 9 years old.
>>96259152>casting commander when two blues are erectblame yourself nigger
>>96259152If your deck is nothing without its commander it shouldn't be a deck. Even my voltron deck has alternate targets in the 99.
>>96259140story reads like player 1 slapped two cards one after the other and didn't wait for akroma's will to resolve.
>>96259165>Oh the blue players all have untapped mana and a full hand I think I should play this immediate threat instead of playing something less threatening
>>96258765What about it? You need words in order for readability to be an issue.
>>96259159My commander doesn't even do anything. I was playing Atraxa (the bad one that doesn't proliferate.)
I was out of cards in my hand. It's already tryhard as hell instakilling someone's commander, but I should at least be allowed to get the ability off so I'm not left stranded doing nothing.
>1 out 4 keeps a super greedy Startin hand
>misses his land drops
>has no creatures
>a mana rock here or there
>me:okay, you have too many blockers, your stuff flies and mine doesn't have reach, so I'll swing at this guy
>everyone at the table:whoa whoa whoa, you don't know how to play edh or something? You never attack a guy who has a bad start
>that guy won at the end, because they convinced me to leave him alone and they ignored him as well and let him do his thing
>>96259176Translation for that card anon? What does it do? You can't play it if you don't have a translation
>>96259185reading the card explains the card
>>96259180I'm just a little guy anon atraxa is just a potential +6 it's not even a big deal just let it resolve gosh
>>96259140that's not what he's describing. this is explicitly just a stack conversation.
if you cast A and B in response, B resolves first, then A. that's it.
>>96259196Store championship wizards of the coast eytan zana
What does that do anon, people explain I'm new to the game
>>96259169Exactly. All these newbs who got into this game with precons think this is the way, when before you picked your commander for the colors, and them being on the field was a bonus. If you pick a strong commander and build your deck to only work with it, then having people easily counter it is your fault.
This card was tailor made for sidisi holy fug
>I play a land
>in response
>uhm
>>96259199No what he's describing is he casts the spell, it resolves, then he plays another spell, and the other player says WAIT I DIDN'T LET THE FIRST SPELL RESOLVE I'M COUNTERING IT FIRST
>>96259211>gossip>a rat drinking teaI love zoomer slang
>opponent turn 1 graftdigger cage
>I can't play anything, land pass for 5 turns
>opponent 2 spends each turn destroying one of my lands because I'm the only one that hasn't missed a land drop and "always have open mana"
>opponent 3 makes me discard my hand because "you have 6 cards and we only have 3"
>he plays a generic goodstuff pile that doesn't rely on the commander
>>96259221I want to see the same cards in every edh game, why don't you understand that? It's so fun.
Only a retard would look at this card and think "whoa a dragon tribal card!"
>>96259221>if your deck works without the commander it is good stuffherp
>>96259057there's just not the support stations need to be an archetype right now. unfortunately for anyone who likes it, it needs a few more sets to get actual support. there's no pilot tokens, there's only one toughness station enabler (he's green,
>>96258246), the precon doesn't come with the right old charge counter support to be good, etc..
>>96259228He genocides dragons
>>96259180so you cast a 7cmc 4 color card into a blue player with open mana and you expected that to go off?
your commander doesn't even do anything unique that could warrant the game being interesting after it hits, it's a generic draw keyword soup
Yes I would counter that one
>>96259180>atraxa grand unifier doesn't do anythingholy gaslighting
>>96259239they must IMMEDIATELY errata all crew abilities to be generic
Something like Pilot 2 (This crews, mounts, and stations with power equal to its power +2) we can't keep doing this shit where new card subtypes invalidate old cards on already shaky mechanical grounds FACT TRUTH NUKE
>>96259180why would I let you unbirck your hand?
>>96259211Level 2 is fantastic for Pride of Hull Clade, as well
>>96258896>lgs owner has a couple of opened precons that anybody can use to play with others>see some zoomers playing 1v1>join them>one of their decks has chaos warp>use it against my commander>Okay, I put it onto the command zone>both of them:you can't do that>well, those rules changed, wait, how long have you been playing edh?>store owner is also a judge and explains it to themOdd times.
>>96259228>draw 1 card and only if he connectsso he's terrible then? dragons are the only redeeming quality here
>>96259239guess I'll wait for whenever they decide to do that
but I am still rather miffed they didn't give us a proper commander for space ships
How hard would it have been to create maybe a 4c (leaving out green) legendary space ship manufactory commander
maybe an effect like, when you station this it stations X amount of other space ships
and then a stupid high charge counter final, maybe a number like 100 or so, that does something big
maybe even add a "vehicles are space ships with station cost equal to their crew cost" or just you know, anything
Don't mind me just posting the best proxied lands
Bob the Spacemyn
1WBG
Legendary Creature - Human Pilot Astronaut Cowboy
When this etb or attack, mill cards until you reveal a vehicle, mount, or card with station and put it into play. Gain 1 life for each card milled this way and create a zombie pilot token.
4/4
>>96259297There's a teenager using Pokémon energy cards as lands at my lgs. He also "shuffles" his deck to have the same opening every game and somehow still loses all the time.
>>96259231There's a difference between a resistant strategy vs just emptying all the expensive mistakes in this game onto the table.
>>96259317I need to do this, genius
>>96259317I have a deck somewhere that has upside-down duel masters cards as lands.
>>96259310 Didn't read
https://cardconjurer.onrender.com/
Use this and I'll maybe read it next time
>>96259185Translate what? There are no words on it anon.
>>96258603Only Jews censor the word God. Denounce the Talmud or fuck off
>>96258896>I play Kaldra Compleat>opponent "that equipment is cool">opponent plays Kaldra Compleat and Sigurda's Aid it to his 5/5>"do you have any blockers?">yeah, my 5/5>"didn't you attack">it has vigilance >"well i have a 10/10 so i can just attack you">okay, but I can block with my 5/5>"you'll lose your creature, because kaldra compleat exiles it">I guess, but it's not that big of a deal>"so I'll attack">okay, I lose my 0/0 token and you lose your 5/5>"but hes's indestructible">i exile it after damage>huh? whats letting you do that?">...we have the same equipment >"this card is crazy"
>>96259360>has never read the Bible>pretends to be a Christian on 4chanMany such cases
>>96259342Well what does the card do, in not gonna let you make up effects
>>96259357I can explain it easily :o its a saga land when it is played and after you draw a card it gets a lore counter, each lore counter adds the corresponding ability:D
1. Tap for colorless
2. Tap 2 and it to make a karnstruct token
3. Search library for 0 or 1 cost artifact and put into play
Then sacrifice the land
>>96259373It doesn't say that on the card
>>96259360Youre replying to a troll anon
>>96259383The atheist from the other thread is real and we Christians owned him hard. He wasn't trolling. He was mad because of us.
unsure
md5: f8a11113ae3e01ef96d174f005e29a8d
🔍
I didn't even really mind the "space" or "scifi" theme, but the set was so extremely uninteresting and forgetful.
There's no cards that had art that stood out all that much, nor any character (beyond based lobster) that stood out or made you care about them.
>>96259382Okay? Still legal and easy to remember what it does.
>>96259373>Search library for 0 or 1 cost artifact and put into playClose but wrong. Unlike other cards with cmc that got errata'd to Mana Value, Urza's Saga specifically only grabs a card with a 0 or 1 cost, but it has to explicitly be a 0 or 1 colorless symbol, so it can't grab Esper Sentinel, Artifact Lands, etc but it can grab Mana Vault, Sol Ring, or Mox Opal.
>>96259392Have fun with your mtg lore and story with the next two sets, oh wait, lmao
>>96259394The phyrexian cards are also legal
It's really simple to look up a translation of someone needs it
>>96259180good bait made me reply
>>96259401>what's it say>here's what it says>ermmmmm you're missing the proper symbolsI said 0 or 1 cost anon... can you show me how to make a generic symbol on 4chan? It's okay to admit i passed youre very easy test
>>96259180Are you the same anon that said Jew the unifier and Muldotrha do nothing?
>>96259392This but Tarkir. Easily the most forgettable set since like 2020. Yes, more so than le cowboys and detectives. Those sucked but they were so bad they weren't forgettable. Tarkir just happened and I barely noticed it.
>>96259402I am skipping spiderset beyond some choice purchases simply because they're good cards, but I'm quite excited for the Avatar set. Very retarded that they don't keep UB sets separated with some actual magic inbetween though.
>>96259283Not at all, you're analysis is clumsy and autistically hyper-focused. Drawing an extra card per turn is quite good on its own and has always been. Especially when you're killing in 1-2 hits. You're going to water the deck down with bad draft cards in a false attempt to achieve some perceived "optimization." Abdel doesn't have to be a soldier tribal deck. Tymna (which is the next comparison) is not a cleric tribal deck.
>>96259418to get a symbol in MSE you type it as (0) and (1), or (W), or (C) for colorless, etc.
>>96259437I'm building estininen with a mix of Voltron and dragons, lots of cantrips to make him big and some value dragons
Blade of selves is great
>>96259426I agree to a degree because they went "okay here is tarki- LOOK OMG FINAL FANTASYYY"
but tarkir had interesting character, cool precons, and several cool cards with lore (flavor text? maybe not quite lore) and nice art.
Worthy Cost, Bearer of Glory, Duty Beyond Death, Voice Of Victory, Dragonologist, Alesha's Legacy, and all of the different Siege cards were very nice imo.
>>96259466And to be fair to EOE, they went "Ok, here is Edge of-OH SHIT IT'S SPIDER-MAN!"
>>96259435Llorwyn (sp?) got delayed and was supposed to be in between Spiderman and avatar. According to rumors
>>96259473They will keep doing this. And have been for a while now
>>96258896I freely admit that I'm not the best at remembering all the rules to things by any means but I always figured priority made a fair amount of sense for simplification. You want to do X so you cast it, see if it resolves, if it does, you move on to Y and repeat the process/ it doesn't resolve due to player interaction and you see if you want to deal with that issue. So if you're casting a board wipe that you want to be asymmetrical, you put on protection first, then nuke the place, you can't nuke the place then put protection on, that doesn't make sense, and everybody gets a chance to deal with one problem at a time if they want to interact with every individual part of the turn. It all seems pretty straightforward. Just don't ask me how the fuck holding the initiative or any of that past the bread and butter shit works, I'll cry
>>96259466Some of those sieges should've been renamed or made into battles
>battle of whatever the fuck is not a battleBunch of retards
>>96259449I wasn't expecting much when I built him, but he's surprisingly good. It's nice to have a different archetype in Orzhov, even if BW isn't that good at spellslinger. He's like a slower, but stronger Tibor and Lumia.
>>96258912Saffi is really fun and strong, especially when you have a recursion engine going.
>>96259297damn son, are you some kind of retard?
>>96259297EXTREMELY based
>>96259484holding priority in this case is "im casting a nuke BUT FIRST I'll protect my guys"
not holding priority is "im casting a nuke" them "I want to protect my guys. what do you mean its too late?"
you can also (not holding priority) say "I want to protect my guys" followed by "i want to nuke"
>>96259221uh oh build-around-me-brain!
>>96259392Agreed in full. Granted I'm always going to be the most assmad that they somehow made Outlaws of Thunder Junction gay and lame. How do you fuck up a cowboy season? It's the easiest shoe in in the world. Give the cards some kind of 6 shooter mechanic, a cool legendary lever action rifle, a hot Indian chick and release it, I would have bought a shit ton of packs. Instead I can't even think of a cool card from it aside from, fuck, Final Showdown maybe? And that's me being really Goddamn generous
>>96259568The only thing I like about Thunder Junction, was Gisa & Geralf getting to do some shit, and also the Big Score having some fun stuff. Memory Holed in my mind's eye, otherwise.
Why does Magic have such good synergy where brand new cards can interact with old cards in a whole new way that gives them a second life?
>>96259579OK I'll give that season one more pass: the alt art for Gisa that was a wanted posters for the card was kinda fun
>>96259183it did at least take a quickie to convince you, right anon?
Why do they hate revisiting old keywords?
>we have to be on the same plane durr
Why though? The lore is completely retarded now anyway with Mario kart, star trek and cheerleaders all (universes within cards by the way) .
>>96259568wotc is just incapable of creating an actual western
>>96259616They're retarded
>>96259611They let me fuck your mom.
>ramp, done
>card draw, done
>targeted interaction, done
>mass interaction, done
>mana base, done
time for the fun stuff of commander synergies and wincons
>84 of 100 main deck cards
>>96259626Nice good stuff deck
>>96259623nice good stuff fuck
>>96259626start with fun stuff first, goodstuffag
>>96259661I didn't play edh when golos was popular, must've been awesome for those good stuff people.
>>96259626Interaction cards are literally the most fun cards in the game
>you paying for that turn 1 Sol Ring bro?
>>96259626Why don't any of those cards synergize or interact with your commander?
>>96259675What's happening in that art? Ridiculous art direction by wotc.
>>96259675>he always starts
>>96259057These things are like shrines right? Where they technically don't have a creature type?
>>96259626>rampCut it down to 4-6 max
>card drawShould match the theme of your deck and be included in "fun" not always possible to do this 100% but if its 0% it's your fault
>interactionThis should also 1. Be on theme and part of "fun" and the ratio between targeted mass and protection should be tailored as such along the same guidelines. Also you probably have to many sweepers in general.
>>96259675Love seeing the bluefag hold up exactly 7 mana for cyclonic rift when I have this.
>>96259690Imagine taking this advice
Imaging giving it
>>96259679He is being weighed. A coin from heaven falls, unless he matches that coin (pays 1) he will lose the judgment.
In much better words
"Those who seek to upset the balance must be taxed for such ambitions"
Stealing someone's turn 3 one ring is really fun
>>96259696>when you look at their 7 lands and forget their one available mana rock/dorkFUCK
>>96259699>your draw and interaction should be on themeIs bad advice now?
>your interaction should align with the needs of your deckIs bad advice too?
Im not the one complaining here anon you are and it seems for good reason.
>>96259699I will add as many draw spells as I can to play my deck, you can never have enough card draw everything else can be cut down
>>96259709Plenty of commanders and deck types have no themed ramp/removal/draw.
>>96259705>turn 3 one ringyeah right
>>96259705People play that shit turn 3? Almost everyone I see use one ring uses it when they need to take advantage of the protection. Which shouldn't really be a thing on turn 2 or 3...
>>96259713>rampI said ramp should be cut to low numbers and I don't care if its on theme.
>NONE!Post ten commanders where you think this is the case and ill be happy to help you :)
>>96259710This. If you have sufficient card draw it will make up for running 7 rocks over 10. If you're drawing 3 cards a turn it tends to get you what you want.
Large amounts of tutors also changes the calculation.
Drawing a lot>redundancy
>>96259717We usually play higher power stuff and the ur dragon player kept a 1 lander with Sol ring and one ring, and drew a 2nd land for turn
I wanted to test out a meme deck I built but it was funny opening yuffie with that start
>>96259713but your deck certainly does, otherwise it is a good stuff deck
>>96259719I've played enough cedh where someone gets a turn 1 one ring, card draw is card draw
>>96259747losing value is also losing value
>>96259437Abdel merely makes soldier tokens, he doesn't actually give you additional draw when a soldier hits a player (if he did, you'd be retarded for not doing soldiers)
>>96259752One ring doesn't protect you from thoracle and I'd rather draw into my counterspells earlier
I'm thinking about my first big batch of proxies of powerful cards. Since there are so many good stuff enthusiasts and haters in this thread what should I proxy?
>>96259776championship version duals
>>96259776p9
fetch lands
duals
shocks, surveils, whatever
cedh combo packages?
>>96259776don't forget contract from below!
>>96259801>>96259779Aren't the p9 banned, what?
>>96259811bans were done by mean ol sheldon/wotc and can be safely ignored
>>96259735The things that all came with precons built around them? I dont think so but even then name a commander anon and we can go from there
>>96259776Proxy expensive cards you need to do funny goofy plays.
Do not proxy shitty boring "b-but they're good competitively!" cards.
>>96259766Isn't losing a thing? So protection from everything should cover that.
>>96259811not all of them
>>96259568>space magic setting>fuck yeah >its babbies scifi hat setThis writing by committee just has to stop. Get rid of jace and those fucktards
Make a villain thats cartoonishly evil, but has a based gothic/slick design show up, permakill bolas and ugin, burn down bloomburrow plane and blow up sothera, kill teferi, make punished loot and him and ubrask fuck with the compleated mirari, which kills karn
>>96259873You mean...the chaos emeralds?
>>96259881massive brain fart on my part
go play Legacy
>>96259892legacy is just the best brainstorm deck though
>>96259887CHAOS... CONTROL!
>LGS gives me a promo pack because why not
>it has Cauldron in it
So how do I abuse this shit out the ass? I'm cooking up a Krenko deck where I'm trying to slap as much obnoxious stuff on my tokens as possible, as well as get +1/+1 counters on them to make the Cauldron work. Any suggestions?
Cauldron
md5: 21ee2d988b4e8d93b748d0a36eb71caf
🔍
>>96259915And pic because I'm retarded.
>>96259921my LGS still has tarkir promo packs as prizes
>>96257326Nta but I love building decks so I have around 45 of them
>>96259938I've gotta find a way to bribe my LGS to give me all the promo shit they have stuffed in a drawer. They have years worth of packs, individual cards, and so on.
834236
md5: c5f76ba2ae2607b0be3dc433ed43db5e
🔍
Can we stop pretending to not notice this card is busted af?
Back when the commit a crime keyword was T2 most cards were limiting it to trigger once a turn (often yours). And cards like Freestrider
still managed to perf in cedh, standard, modern and legacy with this limitation.
Here it's limitless and with a pretty busted reward. This shit will trigger x3 minimum each table turn after turn 3.
>>96259945>45 decksDamn. That's impressive. What are some of your favorites and most creative?
>>96259959>counters out the ass for doing nothingThat's hilarious.
>>96259945i like building decks too but majority of them are saved online and the ones i physically have i make sure they play differently from each other (ramp, control, aggro, reanimator, tokens, combo, etc)
>>96259959Puts in serious fuckin work in my Skrelv deck
Hello, can someone resolve a quick question for me. I am building either Elesh Norn, MoM or Celes deck, and I was browsing cards and I was wondering about a ruling. Say I have a creature on the field, and my opponents casts Path to Exile, I then respond with Cloudscape. Would the proper order of the stack go as follows?
1. Path to Exile targets for cost, 2. Cloudscape is casted and resolved. 3. Any ETB trigger, and if Elesh is on the field, her ability would also trigger. 4. Those steps would resolve, then Path of Exile would fail to resolve, due to the target leaving the field, the creature it originally targeted being a new creature in the state of the game.
>>96259975Sounds right to me
>>96259959Kek i thought i was the only one who nooticed it, Patrolling Peacemaker turbo accelerated a game in my Hamza, shit was cash.
>>96259466Tarkir lore canonized Gay Bolas so it will forever be the most based set.
>>96259986Also, just as a slight aside, do you generally refer to cards worded such as Path to Exile as cards that "target for cost." Or is targeting not considered as a cost in Magic.
>>96259959every other card these days is "busted af"
who the fuck gives a shit at this point?
>>96259975targeting isn't a cost, but yes you avoid removal with cloudshift the way you think, and ETBs would go on the stack above the removal.
file
md5: be46022bf8e7595f53a2db0ac0799f46
🔍
>>96260013Targetting is not a part of the cost, it's a function/requirement of the spell. Any extra costs outside of the mana cost will be declared on the card, pic rel for example
>>96259887making the Chaos Emeralds Lotus Petals was devoid of flavour - you can't even use the full set in a deck. Looking forward to the Dragon Ball secret lair, where they make the Dragon Balls fucking LOTUS PETALS
>>96259959>will trigger x3 minimum each table turnI have my doubts on this. It varies wildly depending on the table I've found. Most of the tables I've seen concern themselves with building their own boards rather than going after their opponent's. Excluding attacking. If it triggered off you committing a crime too then it he great. Otherwise relying on your opponents doing a specific action like targeting seems iffy.
>>96260043They'll be 7 of mox amber
I haven't played commander before. How sweaty does it get on a LGS level? Will people be packing counters out the ass if I try to play Eldrazi solitaire?
>>96260073either yes or they're all also playing eldrazi solitaire
>>96260073No one here can know the local meta of your place.
>>96259959I'm currently thinking of where to slot this and insight engine in tidus
>>96260073Depends. Though if you sit down at a table intending to just play with yourself and win you'll probably get away with that the first game, then one or more other players at the table will switch to more stronger decks.
Commander's Quarters
Whatever happened there?
>>96260096he's back, I've been seeing videos. I guess he went on a break for a bit.
>>96260081Well fine. How's the meta at YOUR LGS then?
>>96260091The way it works at my place is
>you pay $12>you automatically guarantee yourself two boosters of your choice, win or lose>4 player pods>if you beat your pod, you go into the winners' pod and get another 2 boosters>winners' pod players get 1 booster per opponent they knock outWhat this means is you never face an opponent you met previously, which keeps the element of surprise on your side (unless someone is a salty loser and spoils it).
>>96260015NTA, you are correct, but it's interesting in regard to the EoE commander set. I follow each set release, and i've never seen any EDH set with so few value in it. The most expensive card is a $7 multi reprinted staple, and beside a dozen cards worth 3 or so bux, everything is in the $1 range.
Now the prerelease is behind us, no store will want to mass open or even approach this set with a 10-ft pole. On top of EoE being released in the dead middle of summer holidays between two majors UB sets who sucked up all the attention.
Supply for singles will dry up fast if a staple from the new cards emerge. Eventually there is always a winner or 2 balancing the value for each crappy set, even in lost Ixalan, that's how mtg economics work. With EoE singles price being so low and only 20 non-reprints (almost half being lands), you have good odds at identifying the future "cash printer" from the set and make a x5-x8 out of it.
t. evil speculatoor
>>96260098I meant more "why did his viewership crater to nothing?" That usually only happens to a channel after some sort of scandal.
>>96260106yeah, he makes scandalously bad videos with shit takes
>>96260073You will be getting 1v3ed with eldrazi in any context.
>>96260100>Well fine. How's the meta at YOUR LGS then?I play in the same pod all the times so I cannot give an opinion on the rest of the shop.
>>96260106oh, he's actually been uploading the whole time.
maybe it's an algorithm thing? they already don't like list format stuff.
>>96260032>>96260018I figured as much, its just a layover from Yugioh, where it is something we say. On a meta-level, it is technically not a cost, but is easier to say then activation procedure and resolved at the same time as the cost.
Now on another subtle note, are there any instances or effects that resolve where you can choose "targets" but do not specify as so. The only reason I bring this up is due to Hexproof preventing targeting. For this example, I will use the example of an opponent with just a Segarda in play.
Scenario 1: "Take control of target creature." would be an invalid target and would be unable to activate due to not being a legal target.
Scenario 2: "Take control of a target opponents creature." Would resolve due to targeting the player, and not the creature.
Scenario 3: "Take control of a creature." Now, I am unsure if Magic has any effects worded as such, but if such an effect did exist where the word "target" was not specified, it would resolve, as hexproof only stops the creature from being targeted outright. I only specify these semantics out of curiosity. I guess ultimately, are there any cards in this game that effecitvly "target," but do not use the word "target," as boardwipes kill hexproof creatures.
>>96260100Oh you're rewarded for performance? That usually means you're going to see a lot of people playing to win above all else. Prepare for counters then. Most game stores i go to just roll a dice and give a pack to a player at the table regardless of performance.
>>96260117I guess the next question is then how do you protect your ass long enough to start swinging with the titans? Because I'd imagine the jig is instantly up the moment they see wastes or Ulalek getting played.
>>96260105I must say I was pleasantly surprised when I went to pick up my singles assuming it'd be around 50 bucks and it was 12. Set is very cheap which is quite nice. Not an investor just tangentially relevant input
>>96260135My LGS is a mix of both. You always get your money's worth (e.g. $12 entry gets you two boosters), so you never lose money playing. You just win more if you can pull off wins. They claim it's a casual environment, but I suspect that's a fucking lie.
>>96258751theres really only one or two fallout 1/2 cards I can think of in PIP. a bunch more NV cards I suppose.
>>96260106I didn't even notice that. Stopped seeing his videos recommended and I just assumed he took a break or something. Wouldn't have thought he's been posting all this time.
>have a Japanese card
>rest of the table gives me a funny look when I explain what it does
>I was playing it wrong the whole time
>>96260100>Well fine. How's the meta at YOUR LGS then?gay and trans, next question.
>>96260128yes, hexproof/shroud/protection are not valid targets for their respective effects.
>scenario 1correct
>scenario 2correct
>scenario 3there are effects that say "choose a creature," those don't target, but are rare or otherwise weird in some way that mean they need to fall back on the exact order of when you need to make that choice (you 'pick modes' like 'choose one' or 'choose a creature' before picking targets).
"choose a target creature" is still normal targeting, it's just a weird phrasing to make the instructions flow better.
>>96260140Believe me i was the first surprised, especially considering that, well... the set is good. Like really good in truth. Imho it's clearly linked to a very low demand due to a bunch of bad timing circumstances, rather than low-power lack of interest from players. When they will wake up from their summer comatose, they will figure out there is some good shit in there.
If you are already set then good for you anon, you might have saved yourself few future bux.
>>96260158what card was it, anon
>>96260158sounds fun, 'xplain in detail what you did wrong, and how ashamed you felt. It's time for /edhg/ to judge you anon.
>>96260105>EoE Commander set [...] so few value>Watching Prof hype up the bicycle lands and tango lands>The lands in their cycle are like, a dollarI understand he was excited because they're meant to be affordable dual lands for budget players, but I don't know how anybody can get excited for a bicycle land... because it has proper land-typing? It's still a tapland. Versatility, in that it can be turned into a draw? Land-type Matters cards of WORTH are usually outside of a budget players willing to run this cheap shit. I guess he's still riding on the hype of that Nightmare he got 30 years ago, or whatever. Tango lands I wouldn't consider outside of a two colour deck.
>>96260136The jig is up as soon as you show them your commander. You pretty much just have to hope you have all is dust and your little eldrazi can hold down the fort long enough.
>>96260128>layover from YugiohOh. You're in a similar boat as I was. Yeah you don't have to really worry about targeted vs non-targeted removal in this game. Outside of board wipes or being made to sacrifice things it's not really too common. Effectively most cards run under your first scenario. Targeting is the vast majority of this game. There are a couple others but those explicitly say either all of a thing or all of a thing that hit certain criteria like all creatures of a certain mana value.
>>96260172>>96260178Adventurous Impulse. Turns out I was playing it like an Abundant Harvest the entire time. I was literally cheating
>>96260194Just mention it next time you see them, nobody will care.
>>96260146>They claim it's a casual environmentYeah I doubt that too. Of course I don't really know for sure but the moment prizing comes up people usually play to win and causal feelings go out the window. I'd say play it safe and prepare for that mindset.
>>96260186>but I don't know how anybody can get excited for a bicycle landDid you factor in the prof is utterly retarded and still don't know anything about how to play this game even after 30 years? I think that's the answer to your very valid concerns about these dogshit lands.
>>96260194>Turns out I was playing it like an Abundant Harvest the entire timeThat's pretty sad, send me your btc wallet, i'll send you $0.02 so you can afford a real Abundant Harvest for your next game.
>>96260209>that time he was on that EDH channel playing against Post Malone >he plays a turn 2 Dockside for 2 mana that generated 2 treasure tokens >realizes right before his next turn how retarded this play was and makes everyone take back their turns so he can redo his I shan't ever be watching that fags "content" after that blunder
Why isn't this a game changer, it wins the game when it comes down
Gisela
md5: 79a3e72e3acfd3d4fcf1e101faccfe46
🔍
I'm decking up the first draft of my first aggro/voltron/red EDH deck.
>pic related
I threw a bunch of equipment, combat tricks/doublers, a few creatures, tons of mana rocks and removal, including Armageddon. It was really hard getting it from 110 cards down to 100. Hope it works.
>>96260237because it doesnt win the game when it comes down, you need a lot of other things already in place for it to win the game when it comes down or when you hit it with a genesis wave x = 50
>>96260237Ok Marwyn-sama, calm down, not everybody wanna play storm elves in edh.
>>96260237Because it wins the games for your opponents
>>96260231>is a bigger fan and a far better player than Prof Lol
Lmao
>>96260237It is symmetrical, retardkun, and requires set up
>>96260247if i teached my dog to play and gave him a precon he would probably beat prof
>>96260100>Well fine. How's the meta at YOUR LGS then?First win at each table gets a pack.
I try to find the other bracket 3 players, but I'll have to bring a cEDH deck soon
>>96260247>guy works at Costco>cracked a booster box at his LGS for shits and giggles >opens up the One of One >sells it to one of the only actual celebrities Magic players that actually loves the game and actually loves LOTR >is now a multimillionaire Honestly the best fate of what could have ever happened to that card. Better than ending up in some scalpers closet for years, better than ending up in some rich youtube fags pack cracking hands. Just some guy. Beyond life changing money.
>>96260231His product reviews of deck boxes and sleeves are good
>>96260186>Tango lands I wouldn't consider outside of a two colour deck.Good thing I play 2 and 3 coloubdecks :^)
>>96260274Post seems like a really cool guy, but I can't take him seriously with all those tattoos and shit.
How do I get into his pod?
>>96260274that's indeed a wholesome story
>>96260332The thing is, he's really just some nerdy introvert and always has been. He just came in at the right time and blew up. The image is all a front, he always acts like a quiet and respectful dude in any videos I have ever seen of him. I don't care for his music but I'd definitely shuffle up with him. He's a solid player and never salty. Also he doesn't overtune his decks like that faggot football player who only builds CEDH shit to pubstomp with
>>96260374>He's a solid player and never salty. Also he doesn't overtune his decks like that faggot football player who only builds CEDH shit to pubstomp withThat's cool. Is there some links to his decks? I'm interested now. Who is the football player?
>>96260186i was actually looking for a golgari tangoland reccently and was happy about the announcement
>>96260393He brought this deck to Game Knights one time. Super cool deck and he won with Sun Quan which was based. Cassius Marsh is the football player fag and he just throws money at his netdecks and always expects to win. There's a youtube video of him trying to combo off on turn 2 or 3, and he scoops the moment someone had an answer and shut him down. Dead serious. So for the entire rest of the video he's sitting there with his mic ripped off steaming mad. So, not a real Magic fan.
>>96260231so you never make mistakes or what? get ready for it to get worse as you age.
prof has many shortcomings and stupid takes, but him being a airhead and doing dumb shit in games is one of his few redeeming qualities
I love the initiative unironically
>>96260412How do you fuck up playing Dockside?
Lmao
>>96260186having land types matters tbf
>>96260428All things easily accomplished by running basics. Remember kids, basic lands are TECH.
>>96260431the tango lands are great if you run basics though
>>96260393>football playerCassius Marsh. Known to bring the most busted shit, and being a very bad sport. i remember him being on IHYD with picrel as his commander, and him visibly looking at the hand of the player to his right. its taken down though
>>96260408>he scoops lmao where did that happen?
>>96260452That's cool so many celebs are into EDH now.
>>96259022Just don't play with these kinda babies. Why do you think commander plays have such a bad name
>>96260452>visibly looking at the hand of the player to his rightI have a screenshot saved of that but 4chan is being a shit and I can't attach it
https://litter.catbox.moe/f33gwytl37aer92f DOT png
>>96260490lmao is this mid-game?? Come the fuck on
>>96260443I love tangos, they need to finish the damn cycle
>>96260490I'm laughing for real right now.
>>96258912Hope you're hungry, Anon
And the only answer is pastel pink.
>>96258912Only a true selesnya player can pull the 7 from the bussy.
Your new commander, sister.
file
md5: 92aaf769781dc56a0573b09aabf3cd1a
🔍
>>96258912Only hotties allowed
>>96260516>>96260528>>96260535>6>8>5goddammit just end it already fuck
>>96260408>There's a youtube video of him trying to combo off on turn 2 or 3, and he scoops the moment someone had an answer and shut him down. Dead serious. So for the entire rest of the video he's sitting there with his mic ripped off steaming mad. So, not a real Magic fan.Sounds like your average combofag to me desu
>>96258912Okay I'm determined to get this fucking 7
>>96258912Here you go bro.
file
md5: b7849e2bce1f1a64a2696821be537e97
🔍
>>96258912Krenko but shittier
>>96260555Nice trips, but not a 7
>>96258912This time for real
>>96258912Get a bad dragon produced one.
>>96258912We don't migrate until we solve this.
Enjoy a massively undersupported archetype broski
>>96260535Fuck yeah. Instant respect if you pull this deck out.
>>96258912Eventually I will win.
>>96258912Pillowfort go brrrr
sky blue cock cage
>>96259764You'd be more retarded running draft chaff over having a smooth efficient deck. Maybe a couple of the playable adventure ones at most. You don't need to draw 3 per turn of him when your deck is full of cantrips.
>>96258112Once Consultation resolves you get another round of priority so you play this to force them to draw from an empty library
can i get a qrd on the options for playing ttsim edh with randoms and what to expect
:^) please? here. have a cool card from the new set i have been thinking about
Post your underrated voltron target.
>pic related
>it gets in, and fucks up counters/planeswalkers
>>96257309>But then they seethe if the tribal deck has a single creature outside its type1 is not 2. A tribal deck does not have a single creature outside its type
>>96261374Realistically, this is probably gonna draw 5+ in any 3+ color deck, no? 7 mana to activate is still a lot regardless
I'm so fucking sick of moneybags.deck
>decide to finally play irl instead of being a mobile only fag
>no one plays 1 v 1
>buy a commander deck from the new set and slleves
will get rekt if i play it as is?Wizards is really stingy huh,they dont even give you a life counter or die with a 50 bucks deck
>>96261602with all the stupid nonbasics you can run it is likely to draw you 6 or 7 cards on turn 7
yeah i mean its not great but it survives a board wipe and refills your hand while the board is less scary
>>96256554Oh shit when did that come out. Need to get some updates for my dude
>>96257430The shit you made up in your head is not the same as the actual agreed upon rules.
>>96257492That’s funny. CEDH was the only thing I found with even a semblance of balance. Win as fast as possible setup a coherent meta so you could actually game with pickups.
Randoms just want to do “watch me play solitaire for 6 turns and definitely don’t stop this retarded jank combo so I win”
I mean not that hanging out with men in dresses isn’t awesome
>>96262229Depends on the playgroup and your deck, which one did you get?
![ec195607-ac30-4931-acfd-f9d8ac8b047f[1]](/images/tg/1753464407859404.jpg)
![MirrorEntity__01955.1651596281.386.513[1]](/images/tg/1754398034106368.jpg)
