← Home ← Back to /tg/

Thread 96567693

57 posts 12 images /tg/
Anonymous No.96567693 >>96567872 >>96567896 >>96568785 >>96569419 >>96569485 >>96569984 >>96574441 >>96578081 >>96579989 >>96580514 >>96580531
what is the single most boring campaign setting and or ttrpg?
Anonymous No.96567739 >>96567769 >>96570719 >>96572705 >>96579992 >>96580077
mine
Anonymous No.96567769 >>96580077
mine
>>96567739
No, it's mine!
Anonymous No.96567872 >>96570598 >>96572585
>>96567693 (OP)
D&D 5e, Forgotten Realms.
Anonymous No.96567896 >>96571094 >>96572096 >>96572530 >>96572585 >>96580158
>>96567693 (OP)
Generic fantasy that mixes in modern day elements and sentiments with not-so-subtle comedic/parodic undertones. Like nu-D&D. Or Discworld.
Anonymous No.96568785 >>96571824 >>96578965 >>96579018
>>96567693 (OP)
Honestly my heart says Exandria. I hate it so much.
Anonymous No.96569419
>>96567693 (OP)
Forgotten Realms.
Anonymous No.96569485 >>96571796
>>96567693 (OP)
Vampire the Masquerade
Anonymous No.96569984 >>96570958 >>96575888
>>96567693 (OP)
Eberron.
Anonymous No.96570598
>>96567872
/thread
Anonymous No.96570719
>>96567739
proofs?
Anonymous No.96570958
>>96569984
Glad someone said it.
Anonymous No.96571094
>>96567896
This is the most boring fantasy. Grimdark/derp is the 2nd.
Anonymous No.96571773
probably something like a D&D version of Clerks.
Anonymous No.96571796
>>96569485
you take that back
Anonymous No.96571824 >>96572523 >>96578965 >>96579018
>>96568785
That's the one from Critical Role right?
Anonymous No.96572096 >>96572810
>>96567896

can you give some examples of that?
Anonymous No.96572523
>>96571824
yeah
Anonymous No.96572530
>>96567896
Discworld really isn't that bad. There's a good mix of genres even within Ankh-Morpork.
Anonymous No.96572585
>>96567872
>>96567896
Modern stuff is so fucking bland and sterile.
Anonymous No.96572705
>>96567739
fuck you
t. dwarf
Anonymous No.96572810 >>96572895 >>96572908 >>96577751
>>96572096
This isn't just W*rcraft, it's all throughout games media... what happened? Why is it happening?
Anonymous No.96572895
>>96572810
Corporate takeovers sanitizing everything for mass market appeal. If everything is harmless, cute, and inoffensive then it's okay.
Anonymous No.96572908 >>96572916
>>96572810
>what happened?
You know what.
>Why is it happening?
You also know why.
Anonymous No.96572916 >>96572931
>>96572908
...jews?
Anonymous No.96572931 >>96572990
>>96572916
No, not that /pol/ shit. Far worse.
Anonymous No.96572990
>>96572931
...gobbos?
Anonymous No.96574441
>>96567693 (OP)
"Modern"
Anonymous No.96575888
>>96569984
Eberron can be many things. Boring, it isn't.
Anonymous No.96577751
>>96572810
Anonymous No.96578081 >>96578548 >>96581524
>>96567693 (OP)
My instincts say Grewhawk just because nobody ever fucking talks about it, whereas FR gets a lot of hate for being boring.

Both are pretty generic. Kitchen Sink Fantasies without any interesting limitations are pretty bad, but those can actually be kind of fun if you lean into what massive shitholes they are. Like Forgotten Realms is basically nonstop turmoil: the setting, because there are so many elements constantly fucking up faerun.

Hyborean Age if you're only passingly familiar with Conan the Barbarian can also be a chore. Conan stories use social degeneration in urban settings very extensively and if you don't get that you just have regular people and the occasional le ebil cartoon monster. Same for Black Company, you have to be wading through a very active shitstream of people for the monsters to have the effect they're supposed to.

Generic Dark Fantasy is also kind of yawn-inducing. Like man do I not give a shit about giant spiders, they aren't scary and if they were big they would probably be very polite. Like oh no, they built their webs on some lost gothic architecture in the middle of fucking nowhere. You really have to not get lost in the sauce with dark fantasy or you get inferior stuff like how dark souls 2 is vastly inferior to dark souls 1.

Anything that uses 'solarpunk' as a tagline is soul-drainingly boring, and people who like it bore me to tears with the chiches they throw out to advocate for it with like
>Le having hope is the most punk thing u can do
Or some other vapid, empty statement like that. You hear it from these milquetoast doughey twats on the internet because there are no IRL settings with it that are compelling in the slightest.
Anonymous No.96578097
What would you add/take away from a boring setting to make it less boring?
Anonymous No.96578548
>>96578081
I feel like you can't really ever understand Greyhawk If you didn't follow Living Greyhawk; Faerun is about decline and collapse, your essentially living through the second apocalypse which happened immediately after the first.
Anonymous No.96578598 >>96578662 >>96578906 >>96580543
40k isn’t a boring setting necessarily but it is incredibly hard to do RPGs in with the sheer amount of setting limitations putting player and GM creativity in a box. the results can end up quite dull
Anonymous No.96578662 >>96579010
>>96578598
What?
Anonymous No.96578906 >>96579010
>>96578598
>40k has setting limitations
Either retarded or troll post
40k has a lot of problems as a setting but one of them isn't that it's limited. There are several RPGs set in 40k, and it's easy as shit to homebrew since you at least have some relativity with how things should rate regarding stats because of numerous wargame additions with decades of lore and faq.
Anonymous No.96578965 >>96579018
>>96568785
>>96571824
Especially because its made to franchise.
Also hate how it changed the common perception of Firbolgs.
Anonymous No.96579010 >>96580115 >>96580490
>>96578662
>>96578906
NTA but i keep seeing arguments that 40k is super open and freeform which confuses me. so many of the factions are extremely structured and documented, and deviations from the norm are usually purged in some way or another.
Anonymous No.96579018
>>96568785
>>96571824
>>96578965
What's even "special" about it? I tried to read a bit about it and it just sounds extremely generic so far, like someone trying to make their own forgotten realms but with far less cultural variety. Or maybe more like the sword coast but stretched thin across continents.
Anonymous No.96579989
>>96567693 (OP)
I don't remember.
Anonymous No.96579992
>>96567739
i disagree
Anonymous No.96580077
>>96567739
>>96567769
Try me mother fuckers, I have the most boring game
Anonymous No.96580115 >>96581086
>>96579010
I mean it's not really that complicated.

You have all the information necessary for the factions and how they're -supposed- to operate and what the reasonable expectations are. Those provide templates for encounters, and notions for what you could reasonably deal with.

You also have the fact that 40k, as big as it is, is full of gaps and undocumented holes in its universe that are specifically meant to be filled by players. Up until recent years 40k was very much a homebrew game. Being somewhat cheaper than it was now, players got really creative coming up with their own space marine chapters and their own eldar craftworlds, corsair bands, ork freebooters, etc. Errata and rules gradually shifted to favor buying specific armies because it helped move models by giving it a competitive advantage, but that's relatively recent (like 4th edition onwards).

That's actually where the spirit of 40k RP exists. Rogue Trader is sort of the best about this. Like you aren't expected to be spending time in the canon planets. Because of 40k's narrative structure people often forget that there are like regular, even decent planets out there, because whenever they show up in the books or games they're about to go from 0 to fucked in a day or two.

So nah, the deviations are extremely common for 40k RP if you're playing it normally, and not with like, a massive autist as your GM, which is a big ask nowadays.
Anonymous No.96580158
>>96567896
Discworld works because at it's heart it's a satirical/parodic look at (at the time) modern Britain. Anhk-Morpork is not meant to be taken seriously as a fantasy setting - its a way for Pratchett to explore (and make fun of) the socio-political issues of the time.

Magic and the Unseen University is based on Pratchett's time working with nuclear energy at the CEGB. The HEX storylines are clearly based on his experiences with early computers.

The City Watch series is based on the post PACE policing reforms and the dwarf and troll storylines within are based on the racial issues in the late 80s and early 90s in the UK.


Nu-DnD doesn't work because it's not parody or satire, or to be more precise the world elements are not parody or satire. The world is serious in its modern sentiments and elements and storylines are not about how the modern elements change society (which is a reoccurring theme in discworld) but are instead enforced at a meta-level (for various reasons, some of which are at least partially culture war related).
Anonymous No.96580490 >>96581086
>>96579010
>so many of the factions are extremely structured and documented
Literally every single faction in the universe is designed to enable you to make /yourdudes/ however you want. You can ALWAYS pull another marine chapter out of your ass, another craftworld, another chaos warband, another deldar cabal, another underhive gang, another tyranid hive fleet, another necron dynasty, another admech forgeworld.

Not to even mention inquisitors and rogue traders (and their retinues) who are basically made to be RPG protagonists with the amount of freedom they have.
Anonymous No.96580514 >>96582188
>>96567693 (OP)
Medieval England.

Sorry Pendragonfags, your game is decent in spite of the setting not because of it.
Anonymous No.96580531
>>96567693 (OP)
Forgotten Realms is the most lame and boring setting that I was exposed to, it felt like nothing mattered and Elminister singlehandedly ruins much of it.
Adventurer Conqueror King is the most boring system I've seen. ADnD was already mechanically uninteresting, and all that is is the same shit but you roll more dice, and have a bajillion more things to track while still being mundane as shit.
Anonymous No.96580543 >>96581248
>>96578598
40k lore seems just insufferable
>oh wow everything le sucks and is insane and bazillions of people just suffer and die meaninglessly and the demon aliens kill each other ad infinitum
what exactly am I supposed to care about or want to happen in this universe?
Anonymous No.96581086 >>96581142 >>96581462
>>96580115
>but that's relatively recent (like 4th edition onwards).
brother 4th edition was 21 years ago
>>96580490
>You can ALWAYS pull another marine chapter out of your ass
from one of only 9 primarchs, which means /yourdudes/ must logically have a history that ties into the very well defined narrative of the Heresy. and your chapter can't be too distinct or else it would have been wiped out by now. etc. you get a bit less of this for xenos factions, but your reward is to be a neglected xenos player
Anonymous No.96581142 >>96581575
>>96581086
>from one of only 9 primarchs, which means /yourdudes/ must logically have a history that ties into the very well defined narrative of the Heresy
There are literally canon chapters who have no idea where they're descended from
Anonymous No.96581248
>>96580543
>what exactly am I supposed to care about or want to happen in this universe?
The epic flashy death metal battles of little people who preserve against an impossible system? Sorry it's not another corny wholesome chungus redditslop world
Anonymous No.96581462
>>96581086
actual retard
Anonymous No.96581524
>>96578081
>solarpunk

I am writing a solarpunk setting right now.

Was planning to post it on tg... later today.


I understand there is nothing punk about my setting, but solarpunk is the thjng that better captures the aesthetics
Anonymous No.96581575 >>96581903
>>96581142
>There are literally canon chapters who have no idea where they're descended from
correct, but they *are* descended from one of the 9 loyalist legions. so your choice is to either conform to one of the nine, or have your lore be le ebin mystery (i.e., no pre-scouring lore)
Anonymous No.96581903 >>96582210
>>96581575
idk dude at some point it seems like your inability to write within a setting is more your own fault than the setting's fault
Anonymous No.96582188
>>96580514
The Anarchy and the Angevin Empire are some of the most interesting and (because of their social and political consequences) most globally important eras of European history.

I'd also argue that the Matter of Britain (the mythology that Pendragon aspires to) is interesting of itself because of its influence on the culture of the Anglosphere
Anonymous No.96582210
>>96581903
concession accepted