Anonymous
7/9/2025, 10:31:12 PM No.11484884
An interesting situation is unfolding. What do you think about the McFarlane Elite edition line? Does it look like a good portent or a bad one for people who follow toys and how the toy market is responding to high domestic pricing?
At first with Doomguy and Lilith it looked like the line's conception was to be extreme low production run and high prices for an attempt at a return to the "glory days" of McFarlane staction figures when his figures looked good and had an impressive amount of painted detail.
But once the Persona 3 figure got revealed, and even more so after the Fallout one, a bait and switch seemed to occur. The quality, paint and detail has nosedived so far that it seems like it's just $60 DC Multiverse or a $60 McFarlane anime figure.
Even worse for McFarlane Toys, it seems like even if these are limited quantities to lower risk, they are not selling out (barring the madness on Doomguy because he's, well, Doomguy and the best looking of them). Leading to the possibility McFarlane Toys may go the way of Super 7 with online retailers being flush with stock of a bunch of figures they can't sell at anything but a loss. This would not make retailers happy.
What do you think will happen with this line? Will collectors end up embracing it eventually, will it be hit or miss, or will it crash and burn?
At first with Doomguy and Lilith it looked like the line's conception was to be extreme low production run and high prices for an attempt at a return to the "glory days" of McFarlane staction figures when his figures looked good and had an impressive amount of painted detail.
But once the Persona 3 figure got revealed, and even more so after the Fallout one, a bait and switch seemed to occur. The quality, paint and detail has nosedived so far that it seems like it's just $60 DC Multiverse or a $60 McFarlane anime figure.
Even worse for McFarlane Toys, it seems like even if these are limited quantities to lower risk, they are not selling out (barring the madness on Doomguy because he's, well, Doomguy and the best looking of them). Leading to the possibility McFarlane Toys may go the way of Super 7 with online retailers being flush with stock of a bunch of figures they can't sell at anything but a loss. This would not make retailers happy.
What do you think will happen with this line? Will collectors end up embracing it eventually, will it be hit or miss, or will it crash and burn?
Replies: