>A good question..... for another time

>>211683950 (OP)
>JJ Abrams's career as a director in a nutshell

Setups with no payoff

>>211683950 (OP)
Somehow. Lightsaber returned.

>>211683950 (OP)
Did they answer this? Never saw the third shitquel.

>>211683966
An entire trilogy of movies that don't move a story forward but instead just dismantles the previously established story. It was a daring and bold move. But also terrible.

I'm sure some wookiepedia autist wrote an entire book that answers that question

>>211683979

>>211683972
never stops being funny

>>211683979

I saw every movie in the shitquel trilogy and no, they never answered this and they never will.

>>211684005

True.

>>211683979
me neither but i can say with full certainty that the answer is no

>211683950
>A good question..... for another screenwriter

Why don't eternal consoomercucks/redditors abandon this dogshit franchise already? You've had so many chances to drop it entirely

>>211684099
answered your own question there

>>211684099
I haven't watched any new Star Wars content since Last Jedi. I just enjoy seeing the people that ruined it continue to fail now.

>>211684099
>A good question..... for another video essay

>>211683950 (OP)
it was taken from Luuke dead body

>>211683950 (OP)
I BOIPASSED THE PLOT HOLE

>>211683950 (OP)
>hire beautiful black woman
>cast her as a sphincter eyed orange alien

>>211683972
Kek

What a waste. But a necessary failure. Give Star Wars back to Lucas Arts so they can make kino video games and keep the flame alive like they did in the 80s and 90s
>wookiefeet

Butthole eyes

>women in military

>>211684099
some still cling to Doctor Who to proclaim theyre a true
>im le nerdy fan
despite how god awful it is.

>>211685372
I think she was miscast. Could have worked better with another actress.

>>211684099
outside of Disney it's pretty good

>>211683950 (OP)
>YOU GUYS MEMBER STAR WERS????
I fucking hate that movie

>>211685221
>Lucas Arts instead of LucasArts
>wookie instead of Wookiee
Fake fan

>>211683950 (OP)
In the context of this slop film why the fuck couldn’t she just say “This was the lightsaber of Anakin Skywalker.” or something? What is the big secret would it really take that long to quickly explain? Why shouldn’t the hero who is out there single handedly saving the day not be fully aware of all the facts in a given situation? Story for another time wtf does that even mean?

>>211685419
>Could have worked better with another actress.
i dont know if you mean her outfit or her plot, but youre wrong.

>>211685504
Neither, I mean hear acting.

>>211685496
Because Luke lost it, lightsaber fell into Bespin, a gas giant.

>>211685496
Because it's JJ Abrams and thats one of the cheap tricks he uses in his movies.

>The "mystery box" is a storytelling technique popularized by J.J. Abrams, particularly known for its use in shows like Lost and Alias, and in the Star Wars sequel trilogy. It involves introducing numerous enigmatic elements and unanswered questions to engage the audience and create anticipation, often without a clear resolution in mind. While it can initially spark interest and discussion, critics argue that it can lead to unsatisfying payoffs when the mysteries are eventually addressed, or when they are left unresolved.

>>211685419
The character is dogshit. She's barely a character.

>>211685496
Episode 7 script was a mess and things were leaking pretty frequently, same thing with Episode 9 so this is all Bad Robot's fault. Anyway, back to the subject, Anakin's lightsabe was supposed to be an important mcguffin in the early drafts and that changed but you can proof of that is left in the film when Kylo Ren sees Finn igniting the lightsaber from afar and says "that belongs to me" even though he never never saw or mentioned Anakin's lightsaber before.

>>211685496
Had to look up the context, Finn is the one she gives it to so there's not really reason to explain it since it's not for him. The one who asks any question at all is Han(he asks where she got it, not what it is or whose it is) which presumably would be a bit long for a story whilst you're being attacked. Really they should have set it up so she dies or something whilst giving Rey it, with her answer to Rey's question being cut off by an explosion or something

>>211683950 (OP)
This might be a stupid question but is this ever brought up or mentioned ever again or is this an accidental scene left in the movie by accident that should have been on the cutting room floor or something?

>>211683979
Maybe in a comic, there's hundreds

>>211684004
Jews can't create. Only destroy

>>211686730
How many from those hundreds are not shit?

>>211687999
>Should we be aware of the resources and logistics of our enemy?
>LEIA: NO!

Military genius here.

>>211685689
He said it belongs to him because he had been collecting Anakin's stuff.

>>211684099
timesink fallacy

>>211687655
I think you're conflating jews with capitalism and being 60 years old. Lucas and Spielberg used to be cool.

Padme's a new woman since she's dumped Ani.

>>211685419
Admiral ackbar would have worked especially for the kamakazi
>situation hopeless.
->close up to sad fishy eye
>replay the audio of RTJ of the AWing pilot screaming.
>replay the Awing striking the bridge of the star destroyer in his eyeball or whatever looks like a nam flashback
>close up of pissed offf and determined
>kamakazi
It’s like pottery.

>>211685666
Fukkin queers!

>>211683950 (OP)
They havent even bothered to address this in a comic or anything. Yidsney has rightfully abandoned the sequels.
>>211684015
This was in the old EU, how they made Luuke (Bigger Luke)

>>211688120
I'm pretty sure canonically (now anyway) Leia led the cause for the rebellion to disarm completely soon after defeating an intergalactic military force filled with weapons of mass destruction.

>>211690501
Fuck off, baljeet

>>211684099
For me, I like to keep the fires of hatred stoked.

>>211683950 (OP)
>bitch I ain't gotta explain sheit, now take this gay ass lazer sword lmao

>>211691072
Kek. I would unironically pay to watch a blaxploitation version of soi wars

>>211685689
The official novelisation of TFA also had Kylo outright recognise Rey. Supposedly she was pulling a Darth Revan - she had her real memories erased and replaced with false ones.

>>211690762
>notices admiral holdo's buldge
>IT'S A TRAP
>hyperspeed into nearest planet

>>211684359
asians got reparations with rose...

>>211690185
>capitalism

Shitty movie writing that was written by communists was somehow ruined by capitalism

>>211685372
Accurate

>>211691029
It was Mon Mothma, not Leia.
As you can imagine, the woman who saw first hand how a weak republic lead directly to a civil war would be the ideal candidate to advocate for dismantling the military

that's why Rian was so much better director, he didnt leave any question hanging in the air, he answered them

>>211692111
Alan Dean Foster's an old hand at adaptions, and was probably trying desperately to salvage the mess he had to work with.
Looking back, it really is the only explanation that could have justified her bullshit and filled in the mystery boxes without inviting further problems. Wouldn't have made the movie any better, of course.