>>211835514 (OP)
You seem quite obsessed with such "culturally irrelevant movie".
I keep seeing threads about it, over here.

Because it insist upon itself

>>211835514 (OP)
Because sci fi has been irrelevant for the past 10 years. Don't even try and say superhero movies are sci fi either

>>211835514 (OP)
lack of soul

Why is Denis obsessed with taking 80s kino and making it lifeless, dull, and gray?

>>211836544
This, it’s technically very well made, but it’s lack charm, wit, emotional connection, there are too many big names attached and the leads are like children, their performances have no nuance and they are only there for ‘looks’.

>>211835514 (OP)
it was sooo baaad

>>211835514 (OP)
0 passion behind it.

>>211837007
very baaad

>>211837037
copy paste was used liberally lmao

dunc has been one of the most culturally relevant films of this generation
putting aside my claim, how do you people define what counts as "culturally relevant"

>>211837143
>they would stack their canisters randomly and asymmetrically because... they just would okay?!

>>211836872
David Lynch’s Dune got ripped apart by critics for being too garish and weird. Villenuve was over correcting from that

>>211837180
No it hasn't, all it had going on for it was the memes about its odd popcorn bucket.

>>211835514 (OP)
It has and its culture relevance will further increase. You're witnessing the downfall of the American-Israeli empire in real time and think Dune isn't relevant? How stupid are you?

>>211837503
*cultural

>>211835514 (OP)
Its many reasons
>No relatable protagonists
>Too serious of a show
>Millenials are too old to push a movie to pop culture status, and zoomers/alphas just dont care about movies that much
>Hollywood has lost a huge part of its glamour
>Social media are more addictive than movies

>>211835514 (OP)
>yet another remake of highly influential 40-year-old movie with a vanity fair import ensemble cast about a decade after we got tired of them
>"why isn't it culturally relevant?"

Why was the first one so much better? The acting in 2 is really bad. idk why people think Javier Bardem can act.

>>211838211
It wasn't and he played a joke character.

>>211835514 (OP)
Nothing has anymore. But compared to other movies (and Tv shows, video games, books, etc.) DUNC had a good run and made quite the impression.

>>211837417
answer the question, you sound like you're basing "cultural relevance" on whatever algorithm your screen addiction serves you

>>211837037

>>211836995
the 1 second of paul touching the water before leavening caladan has more emotion and soul in it than the majority off films released the past10 years

>>211835514 (OP)
i really will never understand this boards obsession with hating these movies.

>>211837180
Not really. No one talks about it. I don't ever see anyone mention it. Even /tv/ doesn't discuss it.

>>211837180
Lord of The Rings is culturally relevant. We still see threads and memes of it daily on /tv/.

>>211835514 (OP)
Because it's good sci fi first and foremost and not crowd pleasing slop.
Based Benis doesn't miss

>>211839705
>cultural relevance is memes on a dead bulletin board website

>>211839705
Not really. Nostalgiafags and tradlarpers aside, it isn't all that relevant, is it?

>>211839620
It replaces Lynch's version and the miniseries in the narrative (meaning, when I say Paul Atreides, most people will think Timmy Chamalamet, not Kyle McLachlan or Alec Newman). And autistics have an extremely hard time coping when something that's important to them gets changed. They can mace employees of video game stores over such things.

The books already left their mark on basically all of scifi that came after them.
Logically, the 2nd movie adaptation of those books 60 years later isn't gonna have the same impact anymore when the impact already unfolded

>>211839874
It still was the first introduction to the fantasy genre for millions of people and left its mark on everything thereafter vaguely to do with famtasy.
People who wouldn't have touched a fantasy novel ever still watched it and this if course influenced how the genre is perceived and then created.

>>211840141
Look, I like fantasy. I really do. And I also like LotR. What you seem to overlook is that most popular fantasy is pure cattle slop and nothing but escapism. People may read fantasy but to what end?

>>211837007
This entire fucking action sequence and then later on int he movie it shows the fremen just laser a crawler like nothing.

>>211838420
In a joke movie by a joke director.

>>211842006
Not really.

>>211835514 (OP)
Amongst zoomers at least it was decently memed. People still send the lissan al ghaib clip into group chats and it's still water cooler conversation occasionally. Will it have the cultural relevancy of something like the Dark Knight Trilogy? Probably not but with a popular actor that's semi-regularly in the spotlight such as the appearances at the Knicks games and upcoming news of Dune Messiah releasing next year, I expect this to remain in public conversation for the next year at least, at least until the film comes out, if it flops then that's the end but if they end it on a high note it will probably be one of the only good trilogies anyone born past the 2000s will remember. Admittedly that's partly due to the fact no one else seems to have the urgency to actually complete a trilogy in a short period of time, might The Batman have been more iconic, film for film sure, but we will probably never see a second film, let alone a trilogy. It's a good film series so far, could it be better, 100%, but in the era of mediocrity we currently reside in, you can't call it shit.

>>211837503
> It has and its culture relevance will further increase.
Of course it does. The books are well written and went on to inspire the creation of Star Wars.

>>211839431
Yeah, it's almost like they did the spice silos in the movie the way they did as an inside joke to people who knew the game.
Or, and here's a really wild idea, they did it because THAT'S HOW YOU'D CONSTRUCT SPICE SILOS IN REAL LIFE.

>>211837007
I really wish they'd kept in the idea that a lasgun hitting a shield caused a thermonuclear explosion. It was the reasons they didn't have lasers everywhere in Dune.

>>211835514 (OP)
Momcest.

>>211839561
>than the majority off films released the past10 years
Other versions of Dune already exist, so it has to compare favorably to them and not just to whatever hollyweird has shit out over the past decade.