...

>>212133831 (OP)
Why do people hate this so much?

>>212134147
good morning saar

...

...

>>212135465
God I miss the 90's.

>>212133831 (OP)
>Here's that kid I was talking about

>>212136095
Hey, that's a Lancia 037. Neat.

>>212136158
This was the 2000s

>>212133831 (OP)
>movie comes out
>everybody loves it
>one screenshot or webm of a ridiculous or bad cgi makes it to /tv/
>suddenly the whole movie is a joke and everyone pretends to hate it
EVERY. DAMN. TIME.

>>212136440
*ridiculous facial expression

>>212136440
Don't blame me, I always thought it was self-masturbatory shit

>>212133831 (OP)
Editing it down could vastly improve the Irishman. They glaze it because it Scorsese, but at its core it’s a watered down retread of his past greats. Give me Casino any day of the week.

>>212133831 (OP)
>I live for this shit

Scorsese always glamorized the mob life even though he denied it for decades.

>>212136484
>self-masturbatory
isnt that redundant?

>>212134147
I don't think people actually hate it that much, it's just funny upon rewatch how little effort the elderly De Niro had to put in compared to the other actor who had to literally throw himself on the floor and out on the street.

>>212136440
nobody loved the irishman and movies should be perfect, it's the whole purpose of editing

>>212136634
No it's the absurdity of having the ancient De Niro play a young mobster and do a scene like that to begin with.

>>212133831 (OP)
How does the glass shatter without that guy's head actually hitting it?

>>212136677
the breadsticks made contact

Scorsese has had many horribly-edited films. This much is obvious.
Killers of the Flower Moon was by far the most painful; it's obvious there were all the scenes necessary for an absolute 10/10, but WHAT THE FUCK happened? Was it edited the way it was because of Apple? Easily the most baffling thing I've seen in the theater this decade.

>>212134147
It's the fact that despite Deniros senility there are least a 1000 different ways this could have been filmed that didnt look so awful and stupid.

>>212133831 (OP)
they really could have just gotten a younger actor to stand in for this scene. probably wouldn't even need to edit the face or anything since it's a wide shot and his face is mostly obscured. did they really just not notice that deniro looked like an old, old man?

>>212136892
WE all know about Scorcese's co-dependent relationship with De Niro.

>>212136957
do ya think they ever... ya know....

>>212136957
the tech was just 2 years too early. lots of documentation on it, actually.

>>212136974
you fags are no better than the letterboxd crowd

>>212134147
The scene is supposed to demonstrate that deniro is a tough guy who isn't afraid to get physical over disrespect but you can see immediately and obviously that he's an old awkward unathletic man who would have a hard time beating anyone up. It pulls you violently out of your immersion in the plot of the movie and makes it seem comical and ridiculous. The real question is: Why are you defending this abject dogshit?

>>212136995
shame that this flick came out 2 years before the tech to edit out clearly faulty scenes emerged

>>212133831 (OP)
This scene was an insult. Worse than a recent Steven Seagall movie

>>212134147
>Shitty GGI glass exploding from a mere tap
>Horrible angle where it is clear he's not making contact and also looks like he is about to fall over
>Supposed to be a young man despite looking 70

>>212136561
I hate this meme. Nothing in any of his mob movies glorified them unless you are a 14y/o who think stylish cars and stacks of money are cool. Goodfellas opens with them stabbing someone to death and one scenes of Casino has Tommy stabbing an innocent man in the neck with a pen. Just because Scorsese doesn't beat you on the head with morality doesn't mean his mob stories aren't still morality tales. I guess he just expects too much from the audience.

>>212139838
rewatch both of those you stupid fucking retard holy shit.

how they didn't realize that not having a younger actor for the parts of the movie where everyone is young was a mistake is truly baffling

>>212136561
Unless youre a teenager, I don't know how you could think he was glamorizing mob life. Everyone in his movies make money but are constantly afraid of being killed and can never even use the money they've made out of fear of the law arresting. In almost all of his movies almost all the characters you meet throughout his movies dies.

> so fucking lazy they CGI’d the glass breaking

That honestly pisses me off a lot more than how feeble deniro looks

>>212140230
>>212136995 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OF-lElIlZM0

>>212139838
>>212140243
samefag kys dweeb

>>212133831 (OP)
AND CUT! That was great stuff, Bobby. It's like we're making Mean Streets again!

>>212140243
>Everyone in his movies make money but (...) can never even use the money
You absolutely cannot have seen Goodfellas, Casino, Wolf of Walls Sreet, The Irishman. So what the fuck movie do you think you're talking about?

>>212140325
owned and pwned. Even tho you are the same pajeet troll who claims Scorsese just rips off french noir or w/e

>>212140486
want to zoom in a little closer, grandpa?

>>212140426
Please, shut the fuck up. All the "glamor" in this movie might seem alluring to 12 year olds and older sinners, but it's very damn clear what Scorsese (Catholic) thinks about it. Also, get used to some ambiguity.

>>212134147
it's such an obvious mistake that Scorcese should've recognized and changed. Just have another actor do the beating and don't show his face.

>>212134147
it's just an old man stomping on the ground, it doesn't look like the other guy is even there. The kicks to the face look like something someone would do for a youtube video in terms of effects

>>212134147
are you blind?

>>212136440
>movie comes out
>all the corpobots say its good
>one screenshot or webm of a ridiculous or bad cgi makes it to /tv/
>suddenly the whole movie is a joke

>>212140681
so you're saying its yet another example of a disconnect between scorsese thinks and what actually appears in his films

>>212133831 (OP)
This webm is why I never watched this movie. Shameful.

>>212133831 (OP)
Ridiculous! He doesn't look a day younger than 35.

>>212140325

>>212133831 (OP)
The Irishman is Deniro's best performance

>>212142390
mistake, it looks like shit on purpose bc this is a film where Marty atones for glorifying violence

>>212133831 (OP)
>>212134147
>>212136487
>>212139838

The Irishman is a fundamentally different movie from GoodFellas and Casino, the former movies basically glorify the mob life, but they also show how hard you crash living it. The Irishman feels totally different from GoodFellas and Casino, it just feels far more matured, like a cask of aged wine from Sicily or somewhere. I will admit, this scene is impossible to defend, and looks retarded, however, the movie is exceptional and very good.

Joe Pesci said 'he didn't wanna do the gangster thing again', and he was not going to do the project, but Scorcese insisted that 'things would be different', and that's why Pesci did the project. It was different. It's tone is far more muted and old-fashioned than the stylized slickness and punchiness of GoodFellas and Casino. I personally loved the film, and found it a very touching and mature reflection on the nature of violence, mob life, family and crime. It was entertaining too, the uncanny deaging effects really don't distract from the story at all past the first half hour.

It's a great film, regardless of some flaws it has. I've watched it 3 times now, and found it's message and theme to be very touching and important.

>>212136469
Post it

>>212144453
you just answered your own question nimwit, the scene is shit on purpose as to not encroach on glorifying violence, its not a shit scene with a bad director