>no.

>>212345834 (OP)
All I’m saying is if I was in that situation, things would’ve gone differently

women. they defend the rapists, but complain about them, then they make false accusations against innocent men.

>>212347618
I cant decide what made me angrier

This bitch not telling tony the rapist

Janice stealing the layyyge

Camela kicking tony out of his house

>>212348180
why does a woman having principles make you angry? the show repeatedly demonstrates you don't want to be in any sort of conceptual debt to tony, let alone his crew at all.

>>212348180
for me it was the racism

>>212348227
For me the worst part was tonys hypocrisy

>>212348215
Jewish media trope to subdue the public

Dont you get it! Revenge is bad it makes you as bad at the bad guy!

Bullshit no logic to this at all, taking out a terrible person is always a great thing, and she wouldnt owe tony anything he would do it out of angry himself she would never have to ask or even name the guy

>>212345834 (OP)
>filters every woman and brainlet male in the audience
based ending

>>212348315
lol if you really think tony wouldn't lord it over her to get what he wants from her

>>212348427
Ehhhhh you gotta fuck me now because i killed that guy! Afungcoolo!

Fuck off nothing says he would at all, their relationship isnt like that at all, killing an evil person is a GOOD deed kike

>>212348427
This anon gets it

She'd owe Tony one and who knows what that would entail, but it could easily end up costing her her medical license and career. Not worth it

Once mafiosos have you in their pocket they're going to exploit you for their gain, they always do, that's why taking their deal is seldom worth it for people unaffiliated with them

>>212348227
kys whiny bitch

>>212348625
NO SHE WOULDNT OWE HIM YOU KIKE RETARD

They didnt have that setup at all, he wouldnt show up to therapy, have a cry about his mom then stop.and be like so I killed that guy last year here let me take a loan out on your business and also can you stash.these gun

There would be zero repercussions to her at all if you follow the show and logic of the characters

Its a TROPE it was WEAK

>>212347618
What I hate about women is when they get raped by a minority they blame all men for it.

>invites you to a baseball game
how do you respond?

her situation proved why people like tony exists and needed to exist and she couldnt stand. but hey better have a moral high ground and let a rapist run loose

>>212348773
>What I hate about women is when they get raped by a minority they blame all men for it.

literally happening in all of europe. they support the import of savages whos home countries are human right nightmares (especially for women) then get raped but dont wanna hear the racial angle and blame all men

>>212348760
It would’ve been crossing the doctor/patient relationship and currency to guilt her into continuing “therapy.”

>>212345834 (OP)
She was right to keep quiet about it, had the situation been more public it would have reflected poorly on Italian-Americans

>>212345834 (OP)
>just let yourself get raped and forgive the illegal immigrant

>>212349008
Oyyy veyyyyy if you kill the illegal immigrant evil rapist you're just as bad as him!

>>212349428
who said anything about killing? you could just cut off his dick

>>212345834 (OP)

Her being randomly raped was BAD writing.

The rape should have been set up by Tony to get her to ask him a favor i.e. call a mob hit, and ensuring she can never testify against Tony.
You can still have her refusing to ask for revenge, bumping her up in Tonys eyes, and still making him satisfied she won't be used against him in the future (she's very principled).

>>212345834 (OP)
She's a terrible actress and it dragged the show down

>>212347618
>women. they defend the rapists
When did that happen?

>>212349766
>The rape should have been set up by Tony

would have completely ruined his character

>>212348760
Did you even watch the show?

>>212349823
*deep soul crushing sigh*

Tony is the bad guy.
Walter is the bad guy.
Darth Vader is the bad guy.
Hitler is the bad guy.

>>212349766
>The rape should have been set up by Tony

>>212348556
It's not about him fucking her you retarded little faggot. She wouldn't be able to hold the moral high ground regarding anything Tony did after that.

>>212345834 (OP)
No didn’t mean no before that

>>212349878
who defines whats good and evil? its all bullshit

>>212349878

>>212348760
>It's a 90s born queer is too dumb for the sopranos
Many such cases.

>>212348760
Tony in the later seasons is repeatedly shown to capriciously turn on people for reasons even he sometimes can't fully understand. He turns on Hesh and tries to intimidate him for lending him money, which was a favour. He spitefully makes Bobby kill someone just to hurt Bobby for beating him in a fight. He nearly kills Gloria, and although she was doing things more enraging than Melfi ever would, the point is it wasn't a decision, he was just in a rage he couldn't control. He assaults his politician friend in an out of control rage for something he explicitly gave him permission to do. He repeatedly almost kills the bartender at the Bing just for being annoying. He still almost permanently turns on Melfi for not reciporacating his attraction-now add this level of entitlement to that situation.

Tony is malignant, spiteful, violent and unpredictable-that's not to say he acts erratic all the time, one of his actually useful qualities is having a better ability to think and emotionally regulate himself than other mobsters most of the time. But that only serves to put people more at ease for when he lapses and reveals he's fundamentally a savage hateful animal welded to an introspective, depressive, surprisingly smart outer brain that doesn't even really want to win the battle.

>>212349999
Tony did nothing wrong 90% of the time

>>212348843
People like Tony objectively increase the amount of rape that happens. Give a couple of dozen dumb extremely violent males a tonne of unofficial power based on physical force and the rape rate doesn't go down. They're more likely to get paid by an unaffiliated rapist to intimidate their victims than actually punish someone for rape.

>>212348773
Why is it OK in your opinion to punish one demographic for the actions of individuals but not another?

You’ve established that you believe in collective punishment

>>212347618
She's such a stupid bitch

>>212348978
> Italian
He's actually a spic.

>>212348798
>"Sure. Meet you there"
He can't fuck you at the stadium

>>212348315
>Dont you get it! Revenge is bad it makes you as bad at the bad guy!
That wasn't the point. MILFy's main conflict was between:
>her desire to actually treat tony and be seen as a good therapist by her peers
>her desire to maintain a personal relationship with Tony (under the guise of therapy) because he got her pussy wet
If she had told Tony, the second desire would have won and she would have lost all professional/moral credibility. This would have made the therapist scenes in the rest of the series worthless. Why would Tony or the viewer take her judgments of Tony seriously if she has him kill people for her? This was the only way to keep her credibility as a character.

>>212350754
It would've made her a better therapist

>>212350828
Yes, she was a boring character

You can easily skip every Melfi scene/story and not miss anything interesting

>>212351050
fuck you, richard

>>212351050
She was so fucking annoying and had dumb ass voice

if she told tony, she would owe him a debt forever

>>212345834 (OP)
>ok, so anyways about my problems because I’m the one paying for the session

>>212350426
why are you a nigger?

>did you hear?
>john lennon is kill
>no.

>>212352107
bitchy response kek

>>212348773

>>212348760
I know the term "media literacy" gets thrown around a lot...

>>212351690
this is true but that's not why she did it

>>212348760
you want to be smart so bad kek

>>212349482
as if tony would only do that and not brutally stomp him to death shortly afterward

>>212345834 (OP)
she cant let anything bad happen to her rapist!

>>212349766
this might be the most retarded thing i've ever read somebody say about this show. maybe about anything.
the worst part is you're probably not even aware of how fucking stupid you are, and never will be

>>212349766
you will never be a good writer if you think someone like tony was ever meant to be cunning or crafty, the guy is a fucking caveman. he's good at manipulating people but usually only after he finds out about their problems

>>212350018
honey don't waste yourself like this, you will never finish your novel this way

>>212354589
nta but anyone with 115+ iq could knock out a comment like that in under 50 seconds

This guy is actually Ecuadorian.

>>212354666
listen here you little shit

>>212345834 (OP)
That little side plot really went nowhere eh?
What the deal with that?

>>212345834 (OP)
Literally every single act, thought, or statement from Dr. Melfi can be summed up as a woman moment.
Consistently retarded emotional logic that makes every situation she enters worse.

>>212345834 (OP)
The Raped.

>another whiny incel thread
just kill yourself or troon out already

>>212348798
I don't "get" the Vito Star Wars meme.

>>212355923
background has the same color palette

>>212349766

I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve said this but this is the stupidest fucking post I’ve ever seen on this board.

>>212348760
Bro Tony ruined his best friends lives, whom which he grew up with: arty and the terminator 2 guy, they weren't in the game but they got caught up nonetheless

Given the chance he'd 100% ruin her

>>212356118
But have you said why

>>212356200
if tony had her raped it would very early on cement him as irredeemable to most of the audience and it works better as a random thing that happens than the decision of any given character, because that’s life. if she got knockout game’d by a nog would you be mad that someone didn’t order it?

>>212347618
Fact

>>212345834 (OP)
She was asking for it with all those slutty skirts.

>>212350018
best post

>>212350426

>>212348625
Just saying, if some spic burger flipper raped me in the ass I'd take the risk of getting fired if my mob client could have him whacked.

Probably the most embarrassing moment in television history
People always seem confused as to how The Many Saints of Newark could be made by David Chase when it's so terrible and this is exactly why
David Chase is an embarrassingly juvenile writer with absolutely no talent

>>212347618
She didn't want Tony to kill the guy cause then she'd owe him something down the line

>>212358418
>I'd take the risk of getting fired if my mob client could have him whacked.
She wouldn't get fired. She'd lose her license and probably wouldn't be able to get another one in another state. It could permanently ruin her

>>212349766
Jesus, anon.

>>212348215
>principles

Melfi has no principles, she took mob blood money before every session.

>>212349766
KEK you got the wannabe wops upset, based post

>>212347618
>>212348180
>implying Tony wouldnt just use the rapist murder as some kind of blackmail or leverage for some "favor" later

>>212345834 (OP)
one of the hottest scenes in television history

>>212345834 (OP)
>yes.

>>212349766
>tony sets up a rape for a girl he views as a mother figure, respects and wants to fuck

>we are at the incel hours

>>212348556
>Their relationship isn't like that
Bro did you watch the show, she was the one chick Tony couldn't have it was a reccuring theme.

>>212360353
Yeah, she would be completely neutered as a source of help if she asked this of him.. how could she ever tell him that what he's doing is wrong?