>entrusted to lead the civillians to safety from the warg attack
>MEH I WANT TO FIGHT
>entrusted to protect the women and children in the siege of Helms Deep
>MEH I WANT TO FIGHT
>entrusted the rule of Rohan upon Theoden's death
>MEH I WANT TO FIGHT
What shortsighted, egotistical moron. Can't appreciate all the honour and duty she's given just because of penis envy.

You know, I don't really care too much about them leaving out Erkenbrand or Elfhelm even though they're both total badasses, but how they handled the whole thing with helm's deep just doesn't make any goddamn sense logistically and it wouldn't have fucked with the runtime at all to establish the actual geography and movements from the book.

>>212577041 (OP)
they needed an unhinged sperg to stand up to the witch king

>brother tells her that war is hell and it fucking sucks that we have to do this, so shut your ignorant mouth
>MEH

>>212577041 (OP)
This was back when girlboss shit was at least a stupid sideplot so nobody cared.
It hadn't forced itself into every industry yet, or started to revolve the main plot in movies around it.

>>212577041 (OP)

>>212577041 (OP)

She's like 16 in the books. That's why she's so retarded and it's also why they tolerate her behavior.

>>212577350
The scene where he finds her on the battle field is heartbreaking. Hackson removed it of course.

>>212579749
Was she wounded? I vaguely remember this from the DC.

>>212577041 (OP)
She was probably the worst thing about the movies. The character in the book is much more sympathetic. I'm not sure though, Gimli being transmogrified into a gruff comic relief character was pretty horrendous as well. Overall, the movies were as good as they could have been and we were lucky they were made in the late 90s, early 00s versus the late 00s and early 10s. They could have been much, much worse.

>>212577041 (OP)
>>212577139
Let us hide in a corner with no exit!

>>212580387
Gotta have that forced artificial tension of the women and children even though they weren't there and were all sent south to dunharrow. Or that the whole gambit was a plan to go and reinforce the garrison already there while waging war on Isengard instead of just being a run and hide move.

>>212579749
It's in the extended edition. Karl Urban nails it beautifully.

>>212580794
>Gotta have that forced artificial tension of the women and children even though they weren't there and were all sent south to dunharrow.
Oh so that's why they have a throwaway line about sending women to the caves/having them go to the secret escape tunnel. Even though seemingly everyone defending Helm's Deep has been massacred and its only Theoden, his squire, and the main cast who are alive in the throne room as the Uruk-hai are banging on the doors. Gimli also somehow manages to just run to the top of the hill to blow the horn.

>>212577041 (OP)
yeah peter jackson fucked up the characterization of multiple great characters from the books turning them into impulsive, unreliable, or evil people.
it was worse with boromir.

>>212577041 (OP)
>Entrust

That shit was a cop out to make her stay with the women. Classic manipulation

>>212577041 (OP)
she was fucking trash

>>212582354
Movie Boromir >>>>>> book boromir

>>212583183
If you're an evil bastard maybe