Thread 213654974 - /tv/ [Archived: 31 hours ago]

Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:05:13 AM No.213654974
IMG_1919
IMG_1919
md5: 2ca6298cfd2a6486625ea4017d6f0dd9🔍
Is Stop Making Sense the best concert film ever made, or is it overhyped?
Replies: >>213655175 >>213655215 >>213655267 >>213655272 >>213655348 >>213655467 >>213655474 >>213655513
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:09:32 AM No.213655077
>Is Stop Making Sense the best concert film ever made
No, it's Halber Mensch.
>is it overhyped
Also no, it's excellent.
Replies: >>213655192
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:13:24 AM No.213655175
>>213654974 (OP)
The Last Waltz is the only other concert film that can compete against it.
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:14:00 AM No.213655192
>>213655077
I haven't seen Halber Mensch yet, found a VHS of it and been waiting to repair my player and stick it on my CRT for the ultimate industrial experience

Pink Floyd's Live At Pompeii is also amazing, saw it in the biggest IMAX here and I wish I was stoned for it
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:14:51 AM No.213655215
>>213654974 (OP)
Yes, no.
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:17:48 AM No.213655267
>>213654974 (OP)
This is Spinal Tap, The Last Waltz
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:18:13 AM No.213655272
>>213654974 (OP)
I like Pink Floyd Live at Pompeii
Replies: >>213655533
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:21:15 AM No.213655348
>>213654974 (OP)
I love them and I have to admit that I like that Byrne never wanted to make more music and fuck everything up
Replies: >>213655559
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:25:53 AM No.213655467
>>213654974 (OP)
Dude, just hype reasonably what you like and let 'best thing ever' bait comments for the plebs.
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:26:06 AM No.213655474
it's really the same shot when you really look at it
>>213654974 (OP)

Early in the Talking Heads documentary Stop Making Sense, David Byrne does a little shimmy directly in front of the camera while performing. It's a centered medium shot with vanishing architecture in the bg, a single male performer performing for the camera. It's brief, but if you know how to see (as I do), you see it:

https://coub.com/view/gglhr

As soon as I saw the shot, I realized that this was the previous composition that Demme based Buffalo Bill's dance shot on. Although the two shots have very different incidental props (or lack thereof), their architecture and content are the same: a man dancing and mugging for the camera which is directly before him. It helps that Byrne was performing the song "Psycho Killer", which also connects the two shots.
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:27:16 AM No.213655505
its probably the most fun i ever had watching one, The Great Curve is really exciting when he gets his suit all unfurled
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:27:42 AM No.213655513
>>213654974 (OP)
It's excellent, but I'm going with the live at Leeds of the Who
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:28:36 AM No.213655533
>>213655272
that one is definitely peak atmosphere
Anonymous
8/14/2025, 2:29:37 AM No.213655559
>>213655348
the last album is pretty good but the 2 (or 3? if i remember) that precede it were weak music and weak art