>>213771950This is the dumbest argument ever. Lucas' preferences have no inherent quality other than the satisfaction it gives him personally. The quality is absolutely in the eye of the beholder, doofus. Just because a creator got to make something his way doesn't make it inherently better. If you decided you wanted to make a beef wellington with pillsbury dough it doesn't make it any better because you, the creator, chose it to be so. It would make it absolute shit.
Directors, producers, and writers make absolute shit decisions all the time. George is not immune to that. Just because he (at the time) owned Star Wars doesn't mean all his decisions were good or were immune to criticism. Do I think he deserves to be crucified for all eternity by millions of nerds? Fuck no. But to claim he made ALL good decisions because that's what he wanted is asinine.
To all the people who want the most original version: it's bad. There are a lot of tweaks that have been made that people just don't realize. It's not just OG '77 release then special editions. TONS of edits were made between those two, and quite frankly before the special editions, the vast majority of them were needed. Star Wars was made on a shoestring budget on a schedule that just didn't allow for good post production.
This is kind of a case of middle-aged women and plastic surgery. Maybe the first few were good and subtle, but they just kept going and soon it turned into an abomination. Where and when is hard to really say, and even if you point at something like the special editions as being bad, there are still some good things in it, like the death star explosion.
The issue today is that IT KEEPS FUCKING CHANGING. Seriously, WTF? It's going to be almost FIFTY FUCKING YEARS OLD. STOP TWEAKING IT DISNEY.