Which of these should I play?

One is for pedos and the other is for closeted pedos

Gachafags never learn

>>712502757 (OP)
Why not both?

>>712502936
>Why not both?
I only have 12-14 hours of free time a day.

>>712502757 (OP)
Blue Archive obviously. The gameplay is shit either way, but BA has better girls, interactions and character writing. And that's the real reason to play these games.

>>712502757 (OP)
Blue Archive has had so much powercreep, and limited characters that there is no feasible way for a newfag to catch up. Sure, newer characters powercreep the older ones, but fully invested older characters shine more in higher difficulties of a raid when you need more teams or specific characters from a long time ago to clear it successfully. You'll honestly feel discouraged if progressing through it. Madoka's gacha, on the other hand, is new. You only missed one limited character and it Madokami so she's probably gonna get rerun to hell. It's easier for a newfag to start there.

>>712503735
All of what you said, but for Magia Exedra instead

>>712503871
>actually giving a shit about the medukas in current year
lol lmao
That franchise has been milked dry harder than Luka in MGQ.

>>712502757 (OP)
>>712502757 (OP)
why does new anime look like bright, pastel washed-out bullshit?

After the Tribe Nine bullshit I stop having faith in the Jap now.
>shit at making normal game
>shit at making gacha game
Yeah Jap has fallen. Only the indie scene is worth a salt.
Either you play chink gacha or gook gacha or you stop playing gacha altogether.

>>712504520
But... BA is korean?

>>712503760
Gold is good enough. Gacha games are not real games. Its not the gameplay but the world, characters and/or story that is the main draw. Unlike a real game there is no reason to tryhard. Its something to do while you have a little free time.
Basically if you have to try at all give up and wait till you're a higher level or get more mats/characters. Keeps you from burning out.

>>712504520
I liked Tribe Nine a lot and am pretty sad about the shutdown.

Do you like lolis?

>>712502757 (OP)
The Madoka game is not good btw

>>712504638
Yeah so OP has an answer now.

>>712504725

>>712502757 (OP)
Definitely not BA, it has boring ""gameplay"", shitty load times, dully presented main story and events, annoying dailies(especially when raids or joint firing drills are up), and horrible rates. Pretty much the only saving grace is how cute it is and how much porn gets made of the characters, which you can safely enjoy without ever touching the game itself(which most fans do).

>>712502757 (OP)
Acording to Japan's F2P tier list BA is SSS tier while Madoka ranks D tier

>>712505282
It's because there's nothing worth buying. Everyone simply hoards until bluefes because only meta powercreep units matter.

>>712505282
how did japan collectively create this man's tier list?

>>712505282
What are the rates of pulling an SSS rank gacha out of the gacha game gacha?

>>712505282
not inaccurate, BA is quite generous when it comes to daily/event pyroxene (gems)
More importantly the meta students are very defined and few so you don't have to roll anyone outside of it, the time frame for you to save up to roll meta is plenty, and ability to borrow unit for raid (the game mode that matter) lets even most f2p win platinum ranking comfortably with one OP borrowed DPS
The game is over 4 years old and the raid still use same old 10 meta students

>>712505282
This list is all over the place

>>712502757 (OP)
You clearly don't care about "gameplay" since both of these options are autobattlers, so I am gonna assume you are in it for the story. Blue Archive's story is original. You just start the game, and your enjoyment will depend on which of the volumes you liked or disliked. Now, Exedra biggest problem right now is that it's a giant fucking recap of everything Madoka. The Protagonist and a green kyubey are basically just watching all the Mafoka stories like Mystery Science Theater. There are no new characters, it's all just "member that?". Maybe this wouldn't be a problem if it was just Madoka' story and lost media like Orika since those are quick BUT they are choosing to recap Magia Record too. Magia Record was the first Madoka gacha and it is way too long to get through compared to the other Madoka stuff. I wouldn't recommend unless you are a masochist.

You already know

>>712506486
True, I don't even care about plat because the rewards are so ass

>>712505282
That's a "how easy it is to collect gems" chart, nothing about the quality of the game. And even then he says it's open for dispute.

>>712507082
>Exedra biggest problem right now is that it's a giant fucking recap of everything Madoka
This would have been a problem if people have actually read the other Madoka stuff. Only diehard fans would have ever read Oriko and Scene 0 is only just now getting an official translation

You can pretty easily gold everything in BA as a F2P. That's all you need to fully enjoy the game.
It's the only gacha I've played for this long and only spent like $50 ever (I really wanted S Hoshino and NY Mutsuki) and honestly I didn't even need to spend, I was just retarded.

>>712507082
A Madoka VN adaptation still runs absolute laps around Blue Archives story

>>712507661
Nah. I used to really like Madoka, but god damn have I really soured on the story over the years. I imagine this is what it's like for girls in their 20s right now when they see Twilight stuff.

>>712505282
>D Mahjong Soul, a game with actual gameplay
sasuga

>>712502757 (OP)
One is hyped just for the hype itself, the other is hyped as an actual masterpiece. You know which one to pick

>>712507365
And what do you think F2P means?

Madoka definitely has a better narrative and better girls but Blue Archive is much older so it's definitely more feature rich

>>712502757 (OP)
Blue Archive is only good for porn.

>>712505282
>Genshin
>Fucking A tier
What? That's a fucking lie, Genshin isn't F2P like at all if you want characters

Madoka being a recap is actually in its favor. Most gachas have a ridiculously long first few chapters before the narrative picks up, but Exedra recapping the original Madoka first means it gets right into lore and character arcs.

>>712509535
That tier list is very lenient. You can technically get every character with average luck as a F2P if you grind Primos from dailies + events + abyss from the start.
You won't get any 5* characters to high constellation though.

>>712503760
there isn't even anything worth catching up in, playing blue archive casually is infinitely better than trying to play it at any actual high level.

hurr i need to plat and torment everything so i can... plat and torment everything next time slightly easier. none of it matters, cruising by on silver-gold and doing hardcore/extremes gets you 80-90% of the rewards and the only real downside is you get slightly less roll currency and might take an extra week to build out a character... for the exact same content you're doing to build them anyway.

blue archive is a god-tier casual game and a shit-tier hardcore game

>>712505282
>one guy makes a personal tier list
>this represents all of japan
ok

On behalf of America, I say Exedra is the best gacha game

>>712510598
I like Exedra, but it's not. They're really stingy with currency and more often than not we have dead weeks after dead weeks. I miss Magireco so much

>>712502757 (OP)
Neither, just enjoy the porn or gen it, you dumbfuck. I'm gonna kick your ass.

>>712502757 (OP)
Bipartisan r emi nde r

all gachaniggers deserve to die.