Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:02:14 PM No.712626689
Now that remake is announced, will it capture the kino ambience?
Replies:
Thread 712626689 - /v/ [Archived: 1078 hours ago]
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:04:44 PM No.712626819
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:19:46 PM No.712627553
>>712626689 (OP)
I enjoyed RE2 remake for what it was but it absolutely failed to capture the heaviest emotional moments. But overall I thought it did an alright job
So I think this game will at least do an acceptable job but they're gonna fumble with Lisa's final scene
I enjoyed RE2 remake for what it was but it absolutely failed to capture the heaviest emotional moments. But overall I thought it did an alright job
So I think this game will at least do an acceptable job but they're gonna fumble with Lisa's final scene
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:33:11 PM No.712628306
>>712626689 (OP)
No. It will be yet another over-shoulder woke UE action-slop, made for the "Dark Souls audiences". Just like Homecoming. Just like Downpoor. Just like SH2 demake.
The brilliant camerawork and overall IN-GAME cinematography will be butchered, and they WILL streamline exploration and problem solving aspects, "compensating" with 10-folds more combat. Replay value WILL be cut down as well, replaced with things taking 3-4 times longer with various forms of padding ... just so that they can advertise the game being "bigger than the OG!!", and to appeal to the modern audiences that LOATHE the idea of replaying the same game even once.
And of course they'll slap an $80 price tag on top (+ funny hat DLC tip).
No. It will be yet another over-shoulder woke UE action-slop, made for the "Dark Souls audiences". Just like Homecoming. Just like Downpoor. Just like SH2 demake.
The brilliant camerawork and overall IN-GAME cinematography will be butchered, and they WILL streamline exploration and problem solving aspects, "compensating" with 10-folds more combat. Replay value WILL be cut down as well, replaced with things taking 3-4 times longer with various forms of padding ... just so that they can advertise the game being "bigger than the OG!!", and to appeal to the modern audiences that LOATHE the idea of replaying the same game even once.
And of course they'll slap an $80 price tag on top (+ funny hat DLC tip).
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:38:19 PM No.712628591
SH2 remake was a downgrade from the original in every aspect except graphics. Worse art direction, worse gameplay, way too much padding.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:42:13 PM No.712628805
>>712628591
>*in every aspect INCLUDING graphics
FTFY.
The UE5 vomit is hideous, and runs like ass. Even on RTX4090, even if playing at 1080p, the micro stuttering and instability of the image are undeniable. The forced RT in 100% static indoor areas is also inexcusable.
>*in every aspect INCLUDING graphics
FTFY.
The UE5 vomit is hideous, and runs like ass. Even on RTX4090, even if playing at 1080p, the micro stuttering and instability of the image are undeniable. The forced RT in 100% static indoor areas is also inexcusable.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:46:50 PM No.712629058
>>712628591
James was upgraded so much he basically redeemed the game. Guy fucking blows
James was upgraded so much he basically redeemed the game. Guy fucking blows
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:47:48 PM No.712629106
>>712626689 (OP)
It better let me wander around town ignoring the main objective
It better let me wander around town ignoring the main objective
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:48:30 PM No.712629150
>>712629058
What? James was a downgrade. He rushes the dialogue and talks in a perfectly conscious manner as if he's fully aware of what's going on. No sign of confusion.
What? James was a downgrade. He rushes the dialogue and talks in a perfectly conscious manner as if he's fully aware of what's going on. No sign of confusion.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:49:34 PM No.712629220
>>712626689 (OP)
Objectively speaking, why would someone pick the no option?
Objectively speaking, why would someone pick the no option?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:50:06 PM No.712629261
>>712629150
He can express himself. Guy can't. OG has two emotions: agitated confusion and no emotion/flat delivery plank.
He can express himself. Guy can't. OG has two emotions: agitated confusion and no emotion/flat delivery plank.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:51:12 PM No.712629329
>>712629220
My dad liked to rip on Resident Evil 1 and Silent Hill for giving you the option to say "no I don't want to pick up the important key item".
My dad liked to rip on Resident Evil 1 and Silent Hill for giving you the option to say "no I don't want to pick up the important key item".
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:51:38 PM No.712629352
>>712628805
Ambient occlusion was a mistake.
Ambient occlusion was a mistake.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:52:24 PM No.712629394
>>712629220
In Resident Evil it would be because it takes up a space and so you might wanna circle back when you have more inventory to make whatever trip you need to make.
In Silent Hill It's probably so It's not too suspicious later when you get a key item, but if you didn't do the right thing, you'll die taking it. It's a cheap death, kind of, but it'd be even cheaper if simply examining the key item killed you.
In Resident Evil it would be because it takes up a space and so you might wanna circle back when you have more inventory to make whatever trip you need to make.
In Silent Hill It's probably so It's not too suspicious later when you get a key item, but if you didn't do the right thing, you'll die taking it. It's a cheap death, kind of, but it'd be even cheaper if simply examining the key item killed you.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:54:39 PM No.712629536
>>712626689 (OP)
/v/ will hate it regardless.
I think Bloober can do a good job with Silent Hill 1's ambience though. I'm not sure if they'll ever be able to make it scarier than the original to me, the PS1 graphics go a long way to helping me feel terrified, but they certainly made Silent Hill 2's otherworld grungy enough to invoke a similar terror in me.
I'm really excited to see how they remix Silent Hill 1 as It's my favorite in the franchise.
People get too hung up on whether a remake is faithful to the original or not, but I don't care about that, I already have the original and nothing can replace it. I want a remix -- new content, new twists, new scares.
/v/ will hate it regardless.
I think Bloober can do a good job with Silent Hill 1's ambience though. I'm not sure if they'll ever be able to make it scarier than the original to me, the PS1 graphics go a long way to helping me feel terrified, but they certainly made Silent Hill 2's otherworld grungy enough to invoke a similar terror in me.
I'm really excited to see how they remix Silent Hill 1 as It's my favorite in the franchise.
People get too hung up on whether a remake is faithful to the original or not, but I don't care about that, I already have the original and nothing can replace it. I want a remix -- new content, new twists, new scares.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:55:19 PM No.712629574
It will be a Silent Hill 2 remake asset flip.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:55:53 PM No.712629614
>>712629058
>>712629261
>generic hollywood voice performance directed by fanboys who want the game to seem as AAA as possible
>vs a guy with natural ebs and flows directed by the guys actually making the game
>>712629261
>generic hollywood voice performance directed by fanboys who want the game to seem as AAA as possible
>vs a guy with natural ebs and flows directed by the guys actually making the game
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:57:56 PM No.712629716
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 2:58:51 PM No.712629765
>>712629261
NTA, but the 2001 OG SH2's VA job has much more nuance and emotion. The 2024 demake sounds just as monotonous and grunty as the 2010 HD Collection.
Both nu-versions butcher some crucial character quirks, even some important personality SWAPS. The cell scene with Mary-Maria is the most notable example, but even OG James had his split personality trait: he sounds smart and well spoken when alone, but clearly drops spaghetti when talking to other people, especially women. This was a clear hint of his true character, a sign of him being an unreliable narrator.
NTA, but the 2001 OG SH2's VA job has much more nuance and emotion. The 2024 demake sounds just as monotonous and grunty as the 2010 HD Collection.
Both nu-versions butcher some crucial character quirks, even some important personality SWAPS. The cell scene with Mary-Maria is the most notable example, but even OG James had his split personality trait: he sounds smart and well spoken when alone, but clearly drops spaghetti when talking to other people, especially women. This was a clear hint of his true character, a sign of him being an unreliable narrator.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:01:54 PM No.712629954
>>712629614
>Having a guy that umms and stutters constantly.
no thanks
>>712629765
I found it to be the opposite. the original is one-note, has basically zero inflection, and stumbles over lines constantly. it isn't helped by absolutely abysmal dialogue, but I realize this is like trying to take the turd from a coprophile.
>Having a guy that umms and stutters constantly.
no thanks
>>712629765
I found it to be the opposite. the original is one-note, has basically zero inflection, and stumbles over lines constantly. it isn't helped by absolutely abysmal dialogue, but I realize this is like trying to take the turd from a coprophile.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:02:15 PM No.712629973
>Opening FMV cut
>Next Fear cut
>90% Next Fear unlockables cut
>Secret Options menu cut
>Blooper reel cut
>Good and + ending requirements aggressively signposted
>New endings that contribute less than nothing
>Constant callbacks to Shattered Memories, Origins, and SH3
>Dodge rolls and parries
>every ending is expanded to feel more "conclusive" despite how blatantly obvious Toyama intended the endings to lack such a feeling
>there will absolutely be a Shattered Memories tie in for the Bad End and an SH3 tie in for the Good End
>Every area is now 3-4 hours long of filler
>Elementary School is now somehow twice the width and three floors tall
>Hospital is now the size of Brookehaven
>Sewers are half the game
>Amusement Park just looks like the SH3 one, completely with rabbit dolls
>Police Station and Convenience Store are now mandatory areas
>despite filling the game with so much fluff and filler, not a single element from the Play Novel will be picked up despite it adding:
>several new endings
>a complete Cybil route and full backstory
>a whole new character and scenario
>a good deal of which is lost media that Konami absolutely still has the script for and Bloober absolutely could adapt and add one dose of meaning to this remake's existence
No thanks.
>Next Fear cut
>90% Next Fear unlockables cut
>Secret Options menu cut
>Blooper reel cut
>Good and + ending requirements aggressively signposted
>New endings that contribute less than nothing
>Constant callbacks to Shattered Memories, Origins, and SH3
>Dodge rolls and parries
>every ending is expanded to feel more "conclusive" despite how blatantly obvious Toyama intended the endings to lack such a feeling
>there will absolutely be a Shattered Memories tie in for the Bad End and an SH3 tie in for the Good End
>Every area is now 3-4 hours long of filler
>Elementary School is now somehow twice the width and three floors tall
>Hospital is now the size of Brookehaven
>Sewers are half the game
>Amusement Park just looks like the SH3 one, completely with rabbit dolls
>Police Station and Convenience Store are now mandatory areas
>despite filling the game with so much fluff and filler, not a single element from the Play Novel will be picked up despite it adding:
>several new endings
>a complete Cybil route and full backstory
>a whole new character and scenario
>a good deal of which is lost media that Konami absolutely still has the script for and Bloober absolutely could adapt and add one dose of meaning to this remake's existence
No thanks.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:04:19 PM No.712630116
>>712629536
>I don't care about that, I already have the original
...yet millions of people do not, as all of the SH1-3 are Abandonware.
The amount of nufags wanting to give these "old classics " a shot via demakes (FF7, RE2-4, SH...) is staggering.
It is also a clear sign of generational shift when the average player no longer recalls the 2002 RE REmake, and how that sort of faithful yet expaded version of the classic game was legit everything every fan of any game has asked for since.
There's also the aspect of TS always being against remakes and recycling old content. The modern westoid devs also just like to copy other people's homework for easy dollars.
>I don't care about that, I already have the original
...yet millions of people do not, as all of the SH1-3 are Abandonware.
The amount of nufags wanting to give these "old classics " a shot via demakes (FF7, RE2-4, SH...) is staggering.
It is also a clear sign of generational shift when the average player no longer recalls the 2002 RE REmake, and how that sort of faithful yet expaded version of the classic game was legit everything every fan of any game has asked for since.
There's also the aspect of TS always being against remakes and recycling old content. The modern westoid devs also just like to copy other people's homework for easy dollars.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:06:10 PM No.712630235
>>712626689 (OP)
No. SH1 works because it's a stand out PS1 title. Slapping a modern look and gameplay on it is only going to cause it to drown amongst other contemporary titles. At least it'll have a more variety of enemies compared to the SH2 remake.
No. SH1 works because it's a stand out PS1 title. Slapping a modern look and gameplay on it is only going to cause it to drown amongst other contemporary titles. At least it'll have a more variety of enemies compared to the SH2 remake.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:06:42 PM No.712630265
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:06:54 PM No.712630272
>>712630116
NTA but you can emulate the old games. remastering would sell worse than a remake, much worse, so we can confidently say that no, millions of people are missing the originals, as most silent hill games struggle to crack 1m and remasters sell like dogshit usually. SH stans are quite delusional about their franchise
NTA but you can emulate the old games. remastering would sell worse than a remake, much worse, so we can confidently say that no, millions of people are missing the originals, as most silent hill games struggle to crack 1m and remasters sell like dogshit usually. SH stans are quite delusional about their franchise
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:07:02 PM No.712630279
>>712626689 (OP)
Ummm. Take a wild guess?
Ummm. Take a wild guess?
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:07:24 PM No.712630293
>>712629954
>found it to be the opposite
That just shows that you don't really pay attention to the dialogue, nor are you familiar with the amount of work the devs and actors put into the delivery of all cutscenes.
The 2024 version eeads like an ironic parody of modern tropes, missing important beats, while trying to "nornalise" things for no reason.
>found it to be the opposite
That just shows that you don't really pay attention to the dialogue, nor are you familiar with the amount of work the devs and actors put into the delivery of all cutscenes.
The 2024 version eeads like an ironic parody of modern tropes, missing important beats, while trying to "nornalise" things for no reason.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:08:58 PM No.712630389
>>712630293
The original just comes off as improvised dialogue delivered poorly and mostly one-note. it's often unintentionally hilarious. You sitting there and saying there's all this nuance leaves me unconvinced. no need to get flustered
The original just comes off as improvised dialogue delivered poorly and mostly one-note. it's often unintentionally hilarious. You sitting there and saying there's all this nuance leaves me unconvinced. no need to get flustered
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:10:02 PM No.712630449
I'm only buying it if it's like this
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:10:34 PM No.712630482
>>712630449
legit improvement on the original desu
legit improvement on the original desu
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:10:45 PM No.712630492
>>712630272
I know you can emulate and pirate the PC ports. I've been sharing the info for just that fir decades now.
But the average GenZ normie gamer does not even consider that as an option.
You're also underestimating the sales power of remasters. It was the 2014 HD port of the REmake 1 that literally revitalized not only the RE franchise, but also the remake boom.
The GOG re-releases of OG RE1-3 also sold over million copies ths very first week.
I know you can emulate and pirate the PC ports. I've been sharing the info for just that fir decades now.
But the average GenZ normie gamer does not even consider that as an option.
You're also underestimating the sales power of remasters. It was the 2014 HD port of the REmake 1 that literally revitalized not only the RE franchise, but also the remake boom.
The GOG re-releases of OG RE1-3 also sold over million copies ths very first week.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:12:01 PM No.712630558
>>712626689 (OP)
nah, it'll be a demake 100%
I said it before and I'll say it again SH needed a remake like REmake did
upgraded visuals and audio, tweaked gameplay, changing up enemies spawns a bit and slightly different puzzles for returning players, nothing more
basically imagine SH3 in terms of gameplay and visuals but it's SH1
nah, it'll be a demake 100%
I said it before and I'll say it again SH needed a remake like REmake did
upgraded visuals and audio, tweaked gameplay, changing up enemies spawns a bit and slightly different puzzles for returning players, nothing more
basically imagine SH3 in terms of gameplay and visuals but it's SH1
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:13:59 PM No.712630680
They'll 100% rewrite the obtuse and vague dialogue and remove a lot of the draw that way
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:14:14 PM No.712630704
>>712630492
>2014 HD port of the REmake 1 that literally revitalized not only the RE franchise, but also the remake boom.
Citing the exception as the rule, c'mon bro.
I think you're overestimating it. feel free to look at the remasters of similarly popular titles like Soul Reaver 1 & 2 remastered, Dalkstalkers, Tomb Riader 1-3 that came out last year, etc. all that shit sold like peanuts.
>2014 HD port of the REmake 1 that literally revitalized not only the RE franchise, but also the remake boom.
Citing the exception as the rule, c'mon bro.
I think you're overestimating it. feel free to look at the remasters of similarly popular titles like Soul Reaver 1 & 2 remastered, Dalkstalkers, Tomb Riader 1-3 that came out last year, etc. all that shit sold like peanuts.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:15:18 PM No.712630761
>>712630680
This. its not the same without the dogshit dialogue
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_hX6pTKB3s
You just can't replicate something that good lol with modern dialogue
This. its not the same without the dogshit dialogue
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_hX6pTKB3s
You just can't replicate something that good lol with modern dialogue
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:17:25 PM No.712630882
>>712630761
everything they changed in SH2 they changed for the worse. It's only well-received because it simply replicated a lot of the original. But that's not good enough imo.
everything they changed in SH2 they changed for the worse. It's only well-received because it simply replicated a lot of the original. But that's not good enough imo.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:18:26 PM No.712630946
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:19:09 PM No.712630985
>>712630558
Nigger speaks like REmakes wasn't demakes
Nigger speaks like REmakes wasn't demakes
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:19:20 PM No.712630998
>>712630882
that's terrible dialogue right there. SH2 is full of dogshit dialogue, VA, etc. Trying to change it is retarded too, because of the sentimental value, it's like trying to stop a coprophile from eating a turd
that's terrible dialogue right there. SH2 is full of dogshit dialogue, VA, etc. Trying to change it is retarded too, because of the sentimental value, it's like trying to stop a coprophile from eating a turd
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:19:40 PM No.712631021
>>712630558
>basically imagine SH3 in terms of gameplay and visuals but it's SH1
I don't want that. Silent Hill 1's visuals are scarier.
Silent Hill 3 is a great looking game, but I personally feel the imagined detail of the PS1 graphics, and the actual detail of the PS5 graphics, are scarier than what you got in OG SH2/3/4.
>basically imagine SH3 in terms of gameplay and visuals but it's SH1
I don't want that. Silent Hill 1's visuals are scarier.
Silent Hill 3 is a great looking game, but I personally feel the imagined detail of the PS1 graphics, and the actual detail of the PS5 graphics, are scarier than what you got in OG SH2/3/4.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:21:31 PM No.712631121
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:25:11 PM No.712631328
The part in the opening where you're scripted to die is either getting replaced by a cutscene or removed altogether.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:25:15 PM No.712631336
>>712630998
This is what I noticed too. The games are pointless to remake because SH autists are attached to the flaws. People will try to tell you Silent Hill 2 is well-acted while keep a straight face but it's dogshit. They'll also try to tell you it's """Lynchian""", but really Lynch's characters were affable and could carry on a normal conversation unlike the retarded characters in SH2.
This is what I noticed too. The games are pointless to remake because SH autists are attached to the flaws. People will try to tell you Silent Hill 2 is well-acted while keep a straight face but it's dogshit. They'll also try to tell you it's """Lynchian""", but really Lynch's characters were affable and could carry on a normal conversation unlike the retarded characters in SH2.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:26:57 PM No.712631435
>>712631021
well I agree remakes/remasters and all that shit invetween are pointless, SH is still great nowadays
but if it had to be remade that would be the only way it could still be decent and not a straight up demake
the UE5 over the shoulder action game we're getting will harm SH's legacy much more than a more modest remake could
well I agree remakes/remasters and all that shit invetween are pointless, SH is still great nowadays
but if it had to be remade that would be the only way it could still be decent and not a straight up demake
the UE5 over the shoulder action game we're getting will harm SH's legacy much more than a more modest remake could
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:33:10 PM No.712631754
>>712630449
if Bloober had a sense of humor about themselves, they should have done like a goof ending that was all blooberisms like this shit. Like all the memes people were fearing would happen
>I got a fucking letter
People would unironically love them for it if it was some dumb bonus joke thing
if Bloober had a sense of humor about themselves, they should have done like a goof ending that was all blooberisms like this shit. Like all the memes people were fearing would happen
>I got a fucking letter
People would unironically love them for it if it was some dumb bonus joke thing
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:34:47 PM No.712631840
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:35:53 PM No.712631908
>>712631754
Yeah I think that kind of self awareness would inspire confidence that they know how to turn it off when it's time
Plus no one could say joke stuff is out of place
Yeah I think that kind of self awareness would inspire confidence that they know how to turn it off when it's time
Plus no one could say joke stuff is out of place
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:37:24 PM No.712631997
>>712631840
>Uhh... if you don't cumslurp flaws like me and the other brethren NPCs, you must le frickin hate the game!!!
kek
SH games have great creature design, atmosphere, and music. You're allowed to say they are majorly flawed.
>Uhh... if you don't cumslurp flaws like me and the other brethren NPCs, you must le frickin hate the game!!!
kek
SH games have great creature design, atmosphere, and music. You're allowed to say they are majorly flawed.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:41:33 PM No.712632236
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:43:27 PM No.712632358
>>712630558
>>712631435
OG SH games were miserable and no fun to play and pretty much everyone seems to agree on that. So there has to be some kind of middle ground, homogenized mechanics may make them blander but there's something to be said for a Silent hill game that isn't miserable to play.
They were basically art games that you put up with to actually play, if not back then certainly now.
>will harm SH's legacy
the IP was dead and has always been niche. What legacy is it harming by bringing it back to some form of relevancy?
>>712631435
OG SH games were miserable and no fun to play and pretty much everyone seems to agree on that. So there has to be some kind of middle ground, homogenized mechanics may make them blander but there's something to be said for a Silent hill game that isn't miserable to play.
They were basically art games that you put up with to actually play, if not back then certainly now.
>will harm SH's legacy
the IP was dead and has always been niche. What legacy is it harming by bringing it back to some form of relevancy?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:44:31 PM No.712632420
>>712631997
SH1 is not majorly flawed. Biggest flaw is boss fights, voice acting despite being flawed services the atmosphere and the tone of the game very well, other than that it doesn't really have any flaws
SH1 is not majorly flawed. Biggest flaw is boss fights, voice acting despite being flawed services the atmosphere and the tone of the game very well, other than that it doesn't really have any flaws
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:45:22 PM No.712632468
>>712626689 (OP)
Gyromancy? maybe i just want more memes of harry saying HAVE YOU SEEN A FUCKING LITTLE GIRL?!
Gyromancy? maybe i just want more memes of harry saying HAVE YOU SEEN A FUCKING LITTLE GIRL?!
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:45:42 PM No.712632479
>>712632358
>OG SH games were miserable and no fun to play and pretty much everyone seems to agree on that
wrong
>OG SH games were miserable and no fun to play and pretty much everyone seems to agree on that
wrong
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:46:44 PM No.712632541
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:47:36 PM No.712632597
>>712626689 (OP)
Probably. Survival horror remakes are pretty great. Most remakes are great, only rebirth wasn’t to my taste
Probably. Survival horror remakes are pretty great. Most remakes are great, only rebirth wasn’t to my taste
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:49:01 PM No.712632669
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:50:02 PM No.712632742
>>712632479
>>712632541
I'm a huge Metal Gear fan, but I have the self awareness to realize that most people today, most people 15 years ago even does not have the patience for, or interest in learning those mechanics because the control scheme is unintuitive. So while I have no issues playing mgs1, I'm not gonna claim its fun for everyone.
Silent Hill 3 is a game that came out in 2003 and it requires you to open a menu to reload your weapon. That's zero fun. That doesn't add to the tension because going into the menu freezes the game, it's just annoying and clunky, nothing else.
>>712632541
I'm a huge Metal Gear fan, but I have the self awareness to realize that most people today, most people 15 years ago even does not have the patience for, or interest in learning those mechanics because the control scheme is unintuitive. So while I have no issues playing mgs1, I'm not gonna claim its fun for everyone.
Silent Hill 3 is a game that came out in 2003 and it requires you to open a menu to reload your weapon. That's zero fun. That doesn't add to the tension because going into the menu freezes the game, it's just annoying and clunky, nothing else.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:50:04 PM No.712632747
>>712627553
Compared to the stilted original? You’re on crack. All of it was more powerful in the remake. They did a poor job on the and b continuity, but acting like the story was better acted or more powerful in the original is laughable.
Compared to the stilted original? You’re on crack. All of it was more powerful in the remake. They did a poor job on the and b continuity, but acting like the story was better acted or more powerful in the original is laughable.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:50:33 PM No.712632781
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:52:11 PM No.712632882
>>712628306
Guess we can count on you to shit up future threads with your nostalgic horseshit then. Can’t wait!
Guess we can count on you to shit up future threads with your nostalgic horseshit then. Can’t wait!
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:52:12 PM No.712632883
>>712631997
Then why do you play these remakes, the HD Collection fixed all the issues you had.
Then why do you play these remakes, the HD Collection fixed all the issues you had.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:53:41 PM No.712632975
>>712632742
>I'm a huge Metal Gear fan
Explains the retardation, didn't read the rest of your post, retard.
>I'm a huge Metal Gear fan
Explains the retardation, didn't read the rest of your post, retard.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:54:40 PM No.712633038
>>712628805
What’s wrong with your pc? Doesn’t look like that on playstation. Try playing it there.
What’s wrong with your pc? Doesn’t look like that on playstation. Try playing it there.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 3:57:06 PM No.712633190
>>712630116
>The amount of nufags wanting to give these "old classics " a shot via demakes (FF7, RE2-4, SH...) is staggering.
That’s their choice anon.
>The amount of nufags wanting to give these "old classics " a shot via demakes (FF7, RE2-4, SH...) is staggering.
That’s their choice anon.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:00:35 PM No.712633403
>>712632742
>the control scheme is unintuitive
it's really not, we're not used to it because it was ditched for other alternatives with the rise of movable cameras
but it takes like 10min tops to get the hang of it when you launch the game
press forward -> character walks forward
press left/right -> character pivots left/right
press backward -> character steps backward
there's really nothing complicated and unintuitive about that, the rest of the control scheme is nothing special either
>the control scheme is unintuitive
it's really not, we're not used to it because it was ditched for other alternatives with the rise of movable cameras
but it takes like 10min tops to get the hang of it when you launch the game
press forward -> character walks forward
press left/right -> character pivots left/right
press backward -> character steps backward
there's really nothing complicated and unintuitive about that, the rest of the control scheme is nothing special either
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:00:41 PM No.712633407
>>712630116
Not sure why you would give remake a pass. Because it came out on gamecube? It suffers from all the same remake problems you guys always mention. Better graphics. New voice lines. Expanded story. Different gameplay. Longer hallways. You should hate it like you hate all the others, makes no sense that you don’t. The whole lisa trevor shit is completely unnecessary and kind of dumb, but that gets a pass? Seems quite hypocritical if you ask me.
Not sure why you would give remake a pass. Because it came out on gamecube? It suffers from all the same remake problems you guys always mention. Better graphics. New voice lines. Expanded story. Different gameplay. Longer hallways. You should hate it like you hate all the others, makes no sense that you don’t. The whole lisa trevor shit is completely unnecessary and kind of dumb, but that gets a pass? Seems quite hypocritical if you ask me.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:02:47 PM No.712633536
>>712628306
>action slop
That's pretty funny considering Silent Hill 1's Henry is an unstoppable juggernaut capable of firing a sawed off shotgun like a pistol and caving heads in with his axe and SH3 might as well be the most action packed of the classic era with the amount of weapons you get and the enemies the game throws at you.
SH2H is probably the only game so far that actually takes the premise of a no-guns everyday man having to arm himself to heart.
>action slop
That's pretty funny considering Silent Hill 1's Henry is an unstoppable juggernaut capable of firing a sawed off shotgun like a pistol and caving heads in with his axe and SH3 might as well be the most action packed of the classic era with the amount of weapons you get and the enemies the game throws at you.
SH2H is probably the only game so far that actually takes the premise of a no-guns everyday man having to arm himself to heart.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:03:56 PM No.712633609
>>712632479
The entire series of games in its life time didn’t even out sell re5. Acting like silent hill had anything but a cult following is straight headcanon.
The entire series of games in its life time didn’t even out sell re5. Acting like silent hill had anything but a cult following is straight headcanon.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:06:47 PM No.712633769
>>712633609
yep, so what? just because it isn't as popular as other series doesn't mean it's bad
SH received great critics back then, so those who actually did play it, did also ENJOY it
yep, so what? just because it isn't as popular as other series doesn't mean it's bad
SH received great critics back then, so those who actually did play it, did also ENJOY it
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:07:51 PM No.712633835
>>712633609
To be fair, RE5 is RE at its peak with how much content is packed into it on top of the peak gameplay
To be fair, RE5 is RE at its peak with how much content is packed into it on top of the peak gameplay
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:09:48 PM No.712633941
Yahtzee and his ilk gooning over the shitty production values and VA were the worst thing to happen to Silent Hill.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:14:22 PM No.712634253
>>712633769
Anon said pretty much everyone thought it was miserable to play (I remember not being impressed at all when I rented it when I was young too) and the fact that it never did numbers with sales bears out his point. You said he was wrong, but he’s right. It doesn’t matter if you’re part of the games cult following, you said he was wrong when he was right. You got defensive in your nostalgia and denied reality.
Anon said pretty much everyone thought it was miserable to play (I remember not being impressed at all when I rented it when I was young too) and the fact that it never did numbers with sales bears out his point. You said he was wrong, but he’s right. It doesn’t matter if you’re part of the games cult following, you said he was wrong when he was right. You got defensive in your nostalgia and denied reality.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:15:19 PM No.712634305
>>712633835
RE5 actually sold well for the following reasons
>film series was at its peak of popularity
>RE4 was one of Capcom’s most popular games
>major AAA release during a shit generation
>co-op
It didn’t even have that much content for RE. The following were all DLC
>Most of Mercs
>Versus
>Lost in Nightmares
>Desperate Escape
It was also pretty short compared to RE4 and had a notably shit campaign.
RE5 actually sold well for the following reasons
>film series was at its peak of popularity
>RE4 was one of Capcom’s most popular games
>major AAA release during a shit generation
>co-op
It didn’t even have that much content for RE. The following were all DLC
>Most of Mercs
>Versus
>Lost in Nightmares
>Desperate Escape
It was also pretty short compared to RE4 and had a notably shit campaign.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:15:23 PM No.712634310
>>712633835
Re5 is an excellent game, no question,
Re5 is an excellent game, no question,
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:17:11 PM No.712634425
>>712634305
Better than 4 at least. But lets stay on topic, this is a silent hill thread.
Better than 4 at least. But lets stay on topic, this is a silent hill thread.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:18:52 PM No.712634542
>>712634253
it sold millions, it did numbers with sales
so you're wrong and doubling down on it
again, RE is more popular, but that doesn't mean people didn't like SH
also horror games are less popular than action-horror (there's barely any horror in SH2 yet it's the most popular in the series) so it's no surprise the RE series sells better since there's barely any horror in it too
>You got defensive in your nostalgia and denied reality.
I played SH for the first time last year, try again
it sold millions, it did numbers with sales
so you're wrong and doubling down on it
again, RE is more popular, but that doesn't mean people didn't like SH
also horror games are less popular than action-horror (there's barely any horror in SH2 yet it's the most popular in the series) so it's no surprise the RE series sells better since there's barely any horror in it too
>You got defensive in your nostalgia and denied reality.
I played SH for the first time last year, try again
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:20:05 PM No.712634615
>>712634542
I think people should really keep in mind, if your game got a dozen sequels and spinoffs AND a full live action movie, it’s not niche.
I think people should really keep in mind, if your game got a dozen sequels and spinoffs AND a full live action movie, it’s not niche.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:21:58 PM No.712634730
>>712626689 (OP)
if they go for OTS camera they'll absolutely kill all the atmosphere. someone post the opening alley from the game and how much those dynamic camera angles sell the entire thing.
if they go for OTS camera they'll absolutely kill all the atmosphere. someone post the opening alley from the game and how much those dynamic camera angles sell the entire thing.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:22:02 PM No.712634735
>>712626689 (OP)
Maybe, but since it's Blooper, i expect them to absolutely assassinate the nurse and the doctor, which are the most complex characters.
Maybe, but since it's Blooper, i expect them to absolutely assassinate the nurse and the doctor, which are the most complex characters.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:22:43 PM No.712634782
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:23:11 PM No.712634809
>>712633403
>but it takes like 10min tops to get the hang of it when you launch the game
By that point your average modern gamer has already uninstalled and refunded the game. It's what happens when you homogenize control schemes for three generations.
>but it takes like 10min tops to get the hang of it when you launch the game
By that point your average modern gamer has already uninstalled and refunded the game. It's what happens when you homogenize control schemes for three generations.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:23:59 PM No.712634863
>>712627312
/thread
/thread
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:27:35 PM No.712635094
>>712628306
Guess we can count on you to make trannys ACK in future threads. Can't wait!
Guess we can count on you to make trannys ACK in future threads. Can't wait!
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:30:51 PM No.712635306
nigga that's embarassing
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:33:08 PM No.712635439
>>712634809
>your average modern gamer has already uninstalled
according to steam achievements, that happens to every game regardless of the control scheme
>your average modern gamer has already uninstalled
according to steam achievements, that happens to every game regardless of the control scheme
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:34:21 PM No.712635532
>>712634305
>>Most of Mercs
>Versus
>Lost in Nightmares
>Desperate Escape
That’s a lot of content. It had a better Mercs than 4. Also
>>film series was at its peak of popularity
Nobody liked those movies, even in 2009.
>>Most of Mercs
>Versus
>Lost in Nightmares
>Desperate Escape
That’s a lot of content. It had a better Mercs than 4. Also
>>film series was at its peak of popularity
Nobody liked those movies, even in 2009.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:36:28 PM No.712635653
>>712634735
You mean like how they “assassinated” James, Angela and Eddie by making them better than their originals?
You mean like how they “assassinated” James, Angela and Eddie by making them better than their originals?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:36:53 PM No.712635687
Are they gonna censor the Grey Children?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:36:57 PM No.712635693
what if they give Harry glasses
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:37:22 PM No.712635720
>>712635532
>That’s a lot of content
A lot of content that wasn’t in the game, that was my point. That list was shit you paid extra for.
>Nobody liked those movies
Guys posting about RE lore on the internet didn’t.
They still made millions and were ultimately the most successful part of RE and why the series somehow got more popular in reverse correlation to the quality of its games. Capcom even specifically tried to bank on the movies by releasing 3 games in the same year as Retribution.
>That’s a lot of content
A lot of content that wasn’t in the game, that was my point. That list was shit you paid extra for.
>Nobody liked those movies
Guys posting about RE lore on the internet didn’t.
They still made millions and were ultimately the most successful part of RE and why the series somehow got more popular in reverse correlation to the quality of its games. Capcom even specifically tried to bank on the movies by releasing 3 games in the same year as Retribution.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:37:36 PM No.712635736
>>712634809
I disagree, there are more obnoxious control schemes out there that are still really popular
In another genre, take games like Arma and Tarkov, they still sell well despite being harder to control than CoD (but obviously CoD sells more than those 2 combined)
RDR2 and Elden Ring have tons of button combos for many different actions, and they sold very well too (despite one of the most frequent critics I hear about RDR2 is people complaining about mistakenly killing innocents, that's what I'd call an unintuitive control scheme)
My point with those weird comparisons is a fixed camera + tank controls nowadays wouldn't have the same reach as the over the shoulder cam, but I still believe it can be well received and appreciated if it's made correctly, because in the end the controls are not that unintuitive
I disagree, there are more obnoxious control schemes out there that are still really popular
In another genre, take games like Arma and Tarkov, they still sell well despite being harder to control than CoD (but obviously CoD sells more than those 2 combined)
RDR2 and Elden Ring have tons of button combos for many different actions, and they sold very well too (despite one of the most frequent critics I hear about RDR2 is people complaining about mistakenly killing innocents, that's what I'd call an unintuitive control scheme)
My point with those weird comparisons is a fixed camera + tank controls nowadays wouldn't have the same reach as the over the shoulder cam, but I still believe it can be well received and appreciated if it's made correctly, because in the end the controls are not that unintuitive
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:37:41 PM No.712635743
>>712635653
nice bait
nice bait
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:38:51 PM No.712635813
>>712628306
SH2 Remake was weird. First level starts off 9/10, than moves fown a piont every chapter till the Hospital when it finally crosses over to a bad game.
It had a lot going for it mixed with shit, so hopefully they filter out the bad going forward.
SH2 Remake was weird. First level starts off 9/10, than moves fown a piont every chapter till the Hospital when it finally crosses over to a bad game.
It had a lot going for it mixed with shit, so hopefully they filter out the bad going forward.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:39:47 PM No.712635879
Let's speculate possible new endings for Silent Hill:
>Harry is killed and we see what happens if Dahlia Gillespie succeeds with her plan
>Harry is trapped with Kaufman and Lisa in Silent Hill
>Harry is killed and we see what happens if Dahlia Gillespie succeeds with her plan
>Harry is trapped with Kaufman and Lisa in Silent Hill
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:39:56 PM No.712635889
>>712635094
Bot post, notice the language used.
Bot post, notice the language used.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:40:00 PM No.712635894
>>712635720
K, but my point is that RE5 is a good game. Which it is.
K, but my point is that RE5 is a good game. Which it is.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:41:31 PM No.712635990
>>712635813
Nah, the only bad part was the run from the hospital to the prison when Silent Hill turns into fucking Mogadishu.
Nah, the only bad part was the run from the hospital to the prison when Silent Hill turns into fucking Mogadishu.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:41:56 PM No.712636020
>>712635687
As long as I get to beat helpless nurses with a pipe. Worst part of the remake.
As long as I get to beat helpless nurses with a pipe. Worst part of the remake.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:43:31 PM No.712636126
>>712635990
That was the low piont of the game. You didn't think the start was the highpoint though?
That was the low piont of the game. You didn't think the start was the highpoint though?
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:48:03 PM No.712636489
>>712634735
I think survival horror is at its best when it juxtaposes comfy with horror. RE Mansion, Castle, mountain town, train ect. The first 3 silent hills were comfy to me. What the dumb slavs at blooper really missed was that. They needed save rooms where you just want to curl up and read a book.
I think survival horror is at its best when it juxtaposes comfy with horror. RE Mansion, Castle, mountain town, train ect. The first 3 silent hills were comfy to me. What the dumb slavs at blooper really missed was that. They needed save rooms where you just want to curl up and read a book.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:50:14 PM No.712636648
>>712636156
I wish that was true as they weren't good films but no, after the first one which was supposedly a lost liter it was a license to print money. I fact it's on Wikipedia gor top 10 franchises either somthing ridiculous like 2 billion.
I wish that was true as they weren't good films but no, after the first one which was supposedly a lost liter it was a license to print money. I fact it's on Wikipedia gor top 10 franchises either somthing ridiculous like 2 billion.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:50:40 PM No.712636680
Hopes and dreams?
>Bring the unused enemies back
>Bring Yamaoka back for the OST like SH2
>New endings
>Expanded lore
>Better boss battles like Abstract Daddy from SH2
>Better and less janky Combat
>Cybil as an unlockable playable character
>Bring Ito to supervise and reimagine the enemies
>Bring the unused enemies back
>Bring Yamaoka back for the OST like SH2
>New endings
>Expanded lore
>Better boss battles like Abstract Daddy from SH2
>Better and less janky Combat
>Cybil as an unlockable playable character
>Bring Ito to supervise and reimagine the enemies
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:51:12 PM No.712636720
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:51:32 PM No.712636748
>>712636156
3rd highest grossing horror franchise, right behind Alien. They were wildly popular movies.
3rd highest grossing horror franchise, right behind Alien. They were wildly popular movies.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:55:32 PM No.712637035
>>712628591
Pretty sure Ito was the art designer on both games, at least for the nightmare stages.
Pretty sure Ito was the art designer on both games, at least for the nightmare stages.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 4:59:37 PM No.712637342
I know it's never gonna happen but it would be cool if they bring back Andy from the Lost Silent Hill game called Play Novel: Silent Hill
Nigga was fighting Cheryl lol
Nigga was fighting Cheryl lol
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:00:21 PM No.712637394
>>712633536
>Silent Hill 1's Henry
>Henry
The underaged secondaries ALWAYS out themselves.
>unstoppable juggernaut
As if. Don't pretend like RE1 / SH1 style clunky combat would be on par with the modern Souls-lite trash.
>SH2H is probably the only game so far that actually takes the premise of a no-guns everyday man
The demake James literally dodges and insta-swaps weapons like a fucking 2002 action game character, little nigger.
It's literally the same shit everyone hated about Homecoming back in 09 and onwards.
>Silent Hill 1's Henry
>Henry
The underaged secondaries ALWAYS out themselves.
>unstoppable juggernaut
As if. Don't pretend like RE1 / SH1 style clunky combat would be on par with the modern Souls-lite trash.
>SH2H is probably the only game so far that actually takes the premise of a no-guns everyday man
The demake James literally dodges and insta-swaps weapons like a fucking 2002 action game character, little nigger.
It's literally the same shit everyone hated about Homecoming back in 09 and onwards.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:00:48 PM No.712637419
>>712636680
>Ito to supervise and reimagine the enemies
Most of SH1’s design in general was handled by Toyama and the staff he’d later take with him over to Japan Studio.
Ito’s contributions were primarily on 2 and 3.
>Ito to supervise and reimagine the enemies
Most of SH1’s design in general was handled by Toyama and the staff he’d later take with him over to Japan Studio.
Ito’s contributions were primarily on 2 and 3.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:03:51 PM No.712637646
>>712636748
I'm sorry, despite your delusional obsession, they were still failures.
I'm sorry, despite your delusional obsession, they were still failures.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:07:53 PM No.712637942
>>712635990
>>712635813
The demake was dogwater from the get-go.
>Beginning cinematic completely butchered
>Run from the parking lot to the town shrunk down to 1/3rd
>Yet introduces an obligatory "tutorial" segment to teach kids how to jump into windows and pick up items
>Town segment further shrunk
>Constantly throwing in "Remember this, fellow SH fans?? ;)" easteregg "memories" to annoy the actual fans, and to confuse nufags that don't know what they're looking at
>Jimbo literally chases a naked bloody guy into a blood-soaked hole in a random garage's door and then is instantly ready to pummel the first foe that now makes an ebin Cool Aid Man entry into the room
And this keeps going and going and going.
All the "dungeon" building sections are also now partitioned into clear "chapters", with VERY limited exploration aspects. Essentially you're given a puzzle / lock door (think the lock box in Hospital), then you get to go through a corridor-like loop A, which grants you access to the corridor loop B, then loop C, always cutting you off from the previous sections.
The "hints" to puzzles or "keys" to actual locks are always within the same room, or at very near vicinity, because ADHD zoomers would HATE to have to actually explore and map out an entire multi-floor apartment building, Hospital or old Mansion, exposing themselves to new threats while at it.
And when you're not doing babby's first Zelda dungeon crawling experience (tm), you find yourself being locked in tiny combat arena rooms, a la DOOM 2016. Because that's what psychological horror game all about depression and sexuality is all about!
>>712635813
The demake was dogwater from the get-go.
>Beginning cinematic completely butchered
>Run from the parking lot to the town shrunk down to 1/3rd
>Yet introduces an obligatory "tutorial" segment to teach kids how to jump into windows and pick up items
>Town segment further shrunk
>Constantly throwing in "Remember this, fellow SH fans?? ;)" easteregg "memories" to annoy the actual fans, and to confuse nufags that don't know what they're looking at
>Jimbo literally chases a naked bloody guy into a blood-soaked hole in a random garage's door and then is instantly ready to pummel the first foe that now makes an ebin Cool Aid Man entry into the room
And this keeps going and going and going.
All the "dungeon" building sections are also now partitioned into clear "chapters", with VERY limited exploration aspects. Essentially you're given a puzzle / lock door (think the lock box in Hospital), then you get to go through a corridor-like loop A, which grants you access to the corridor loop B, then loop C, always cutting you off from the previous sections.
The "hints" to puzzles or "keys" to actual locks are always within the same room, or at very near vicinity, because ADHD zoomers would HATE to have to actually explore and map out an entire multi-floor apartment building, Hospital or old Mansion, exposing themselves to new threats while at it.
And when you're not doing babby's first Zelda dungeon crawling experience (tm), you find yourself being locked in tiny combat arena rooms, a la DOOM 2016. Because that's what psychological horror game all about depression and sexuality is all about!
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:17:57 PM No.712638687
his remake self is going to be so hot
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:18:25 PM No.712638731
>>712637942
It’s posts like this that make me pretty happy the we got a good game out of the remake and that it was successful. The meme of “vidya is LE art” is fucking gay and I’m glad SH1/3 are getting remade. It’s fucking video games.
It’s posts like this that make me pretty happy the we got a good game out of the remake and that it was successful. The meme of “vidya is LE art” is fucking gay and I’m glad SH1/3 are getting remade. It’s fucking video games.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:20:31 PM No.712638887
>>712638687
remember what they did to Maria and Angela...
remember what they did to Maria and Angela...
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:21:56 PM No.712639005
>>712638731
>we got a good game
No. We got a disgraceful clusterfuck of ALL the worst cancers of the modern day gaming industry, leeching off the legacy of the OG Silent Hill 2, watering down its impact, atmosphere, and especially gameplay.
>It’s fucking video games.
Correct: games are THE most versatile, the most immersive and capable media and literature format mankind has created. If all you care is hacking and slashing shit and getting the highest score, go play shit like nu-Doom.
In general, the modern remake trend is cancerous and predatory as fuck. Easily free money for lazy hacks who had nothing to do with the original game.
>we got a good game
No. We got a disgraceful clusterfuck of ALL the worst cancers of the modern day gaming industry, leeching off the legacy of the OG Silent Hill 2, watering down its impact, atmosphere, and especially gameplay.
>It’s fucking video games.
Correct: games are THE most versatile, the most immersive and capable media and literature format mankind has created. If all you care is hacking and slashing shit and getting the highest score, go play shit like nu-Doom.
In general, the modern remake trend is cancerous and predatory as fuck. Easily free money for lazy hacks who had nothing to do with the original game.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:23:18 PM No.712639107
>>712637394
>Don't pretend like RE1 / SH1 style clunky combat would be on par with the modern Souls-lite trash.
You’re right, it was worse.
>The demake James literally dodges and insta-swaps weapons like a fucking 2002 action game character, little nigger.
OH NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Who gives a shit? No really. Who gives a shit? They made it less obstructive for the players, and yet you still find a way to shit your pants. You’re an autist.
>It's literally the same shit everyone hated about Homecoming back in 09 and onwards.
The remake did a better job of showcasing a normal man fighting supernatural monsters than its predecessors did. You literally have no argument against this.
>Don't pretend like RE1 / SH1 style clunky combat would be on par with the modern Souls-lite trash.
You’re right, it was worse.
>The demake James literally dodges and insta-swaps weapons like a fucking 2002 action game character, little nigger.
OH NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Who gives a shit? No really. Who gives a shit? They made it less obstructive for the players, and yet you still find a way to shit your pants. You’re an autist.
>It's literally the same shit everyone hated about Homecoming back in 09 and onwards.
The remake did a better job of showcasing a normal man fighting supernatural monsters than its predecessors did. You literally have no argument against this.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:24:50 PM No.712639228
>>712637942
you're slow burn atmospheric bone chilling spine tingling character driven genre redefining psychological horror game focusing on depression and sexuality, xir
you're slow burn atmospheric bone chilling spine tingling character driven genre redefining psychological horror game focusing on depression and sexuality, xir
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:26:39 PM No.712639387
This is the scary classic gameplay trannies coomed too? This is LE HECCIN LYNCHIAN ART you want back?
https://m.youtube.com/shorts/SVmS9N3NLiU
https://m.youtube.com/shorts/SVmS9N3NLiU
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:27:16 PM No.712639442
Has there ever been a remake of any games that don't destroy the original artistic direction of the original?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:28:58 PM No.712639591
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:29:32 PM No.712639638
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:31:49 PM No.712639825
>>712639591
2R did change some stuff, and for the worse, it misinterpreted original meaning of cutscenes re:Pyramid Head, for example
2R did change some stuff, and for the worse, it misinterpreted original meaning of cutscenes re:Pyramid Head, for example
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:32:24 PM No.712639867
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:33:12 PM No.712639930
Bloober more like poopler haha
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:34:33 PM No.712640032
>>712639107
>You’re right, it was worse.
Now you're contradicting yourself, and trying to switch the entire topic. Schizo much?
Also, combat being slower, heavier and less mobile does not make it "worse".
It's just different, and meant to convey a very different vibe and playstyle.
Fighting everything in traditional survival horror has always been discouraged. This is something GenZ troonies always fail to realize.
>Who gives a shit?
Everyone. Literally every single person except you.
>The remake did a better job of showcasing a normal man fighting supernatural monsters
It did not. It made Jimbo into a literal Elden Ring tarnished, capable of juggling four weapons within a second and dodging attacks left and right.
It also completely missed the point of a slow-burn, atmospheric horror game, where the regular enemies being feminine creatures were easy prey for James, a male, who only struggled against other males.
OG SH1-4 were the literal pinnacle of an "everyday guys and gals thrown into nightmarish situation". The post-Homocoming games all want to make the series into a poorman's RE4 x Soulslop.
>You’re right, it was worse.
Now you're contradicting yourself, and trying to switch the entire topic. Schizo much?
Also, combat being slower, heavier and less mobile does not make it "worse".
It's just different, and meant to convey a very different vibe and playstyle.
Fighting everything in traditional survival horror has always been discouraged. This is something GenZ troonies always fail to realize.
>Who gives a shit?
Everyone. Literally every single person except you.
>The remake did a better job of showcasing a normal man fighting supernatural monsters
It did not. It made Jimbo into a literal Elden Ring tarnished, capable of juggling four weapons within a second and dodging attacks left and right.
It also completely missed the point of a slow-burn, atmospheric horror game, where the regular enemies being feminine creatures were easy prey for James, a male, who only struggled against other males.
OG SH1-4 were the literal pinnacle of an "everyday guys and gals thrown into nightmarish situation". The post-Homocoming games all want to make the series into a poorman's RE4 x Soulslop.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:35:25 PM No.712640097
>ruins Silent Hill
>ruins RoboCop
>ruins the entire word "Cyberpunk"
Why do we let these filthy subhumans develop our most important video games?
>ruins RoboCop
>ruins the entire word "Cyberpunk"
Why do we let these filthy subhumans develop our most important video games?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:35:29 PM No.712640109
>>712639825
No, that was Ito’s decision because he was tired of everyone asking if PH was a rapist when PH is supposed to be James’s punishment. Rapists in SH are bad, bad people.
No, that was Ito’s decision because he was tired of everyone asking if PH was a rapist when PH is supposed to be James’s punishment. Rapists in SH are bad, bad people.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:36:21 PM No.712640179
>>712635879
Can't wait for the game to turn out to be Harry being trapped in a timeloop for years after his death in Silent Hill 3.
Can't wait for the game to turn out to be Harry being trapped in a timeloop for years after his death in Silent Hill 3.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:39:14 PM No.712640371
>>712640097
Why are you seething and coping lol they won you lost
Why are you seething and coping lol they won you lost
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:40:33 PM No.712640479
>>712640032
>It also completely missed the point of a slow-burn, atmospheric horror game, where the regular enemies being feminine creatures were easy prey for James, a male, who only struggled against other males.
OH MY SCIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENCE! LOOK AT THE SLOW BURN, ATMOSPHERIC HORROR! I AM LITERALLY SHITTING AND PISSING AND EATING MY PISS AND SHIT!
>It also completely missed the point of a slow-burn, atmospheric horror game, where the regular enemies being feminine creatures were easy prey for James, a male, who only struggled against other males.
OH MY SCIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENCE! LOOK AT THE SLOW BURN, ATMOSPHERIC HORROR! I AM LITERALLY SHITTING AND PISSING AND EATING MY PISS AND SHIT!
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:40:48 PM No.712640498
>>712635990
>Nah, the only bad part
KEK be quiet gay little faggot.
>tlou combat
>random gauntlets
>having to mash every little thing in the game, even just grabbing something requires 5 delayed pushes of the x button, and why is there a cancel function in middle of it? i pressed that shit on accident one too many times
>hold over mash function doesn't work properly if at all
>youre able to cancel out of toggle to sprint, which totally fucks you up while you're trying to start sprinting only to cancel your sprint mid enemy confrontation
>you can get stuck in walls and corners at times and you have to melee your way out, actually this cost me 3 hours of progress in the labyrinth when i soft locked to a fucking table (google this to see how many people were affected)
>shooting during an unexpected reload forces out the shot at the end of your reload, messing up your aim and wasting your ammo, actually theres heavy input lag in general
>the interaction prompt is so often unresponsive you can get attacked by an enemy trying to escape through a duct or crack
>the radio doesn't work half the time, or it'll start working when mannequins are right on your ass because it conveniently doesn't pick up on them while they're playing dead (this isnt thematically or practically consistent)
>checking the map doesn't pause the game which is a problem with the mandarin part later in the labyrinth
>every dungeon layout is objectively inferior to the originals, all the neat square shapes are replaced with unnecessarily large and confusing rearrangements that don't make sense spatially
>way too many wall cracks, i dont even know why they kept the doors since the game is now 90% wall cracks
>the fact that they added grunts is so annoying i had to mute the in game voice audio, the original game doesn't have this sound pollution and is automatically definitive on that basis alone
(cont)
>Nah, the only bad part
KEK be quiet gay little faggot.
>tlou combat
>random gauntlets
>having to mash every little thing in the game, even just grabbing something requires 5 delayed pushes of the x button, and why is there a cancel function in middle of it? i pressed that shit on accident one too many times
>hold over mash function doesn't work properly if at all
>youre able to cancel out of toggle to sprint, which totally fucks you up while you're trying to start sprinting only to cancel your sprint mid enemy confrontation
>you can get stuck in walls and corners at times and you have to melee your way out, actually this cost me 3 hours of progress in the labyrinth when i soft locked to a fucking table (google this to see how many people were affected)
>shooting during an unexpected reload forces out the shot at the end of your reload, messing up your aim and wasting your ammo, actually theres heavy input lag in general
>the interaction prompt is so often unresponsive you can get attacked by an enemy trying to escape through a duct or crack
>the radio doesn't work half the time, or it'll start working when mannequins are right on your ass because it conveniently doesn't pick up on them while they're playing dead (this isnt thematically or practically consistent)
>checking the map doesn't pause the game which is a problem with the mandarin part later in the labyrinth
>every dungeon layout is objectively inferior to the originals, all the neat square shapes are replaced with unnecessarily large and confusing rearrangements that don't make sense spatially
>way too many wall cracks, i dont even know why they kept the doors since the game is now 90% wall cracks
>the fact that they added grunts is so annoying i had to mute the in game voice audio, the original game doesn't have this sound pollution and is automatically definitive on that basis alone
(cont)
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:41:37 PM No.712640554
>>712640097
>ruins the entire word "Cyberpunk"
This pisses me so fucking much. I liked to browse cyberpunk themed wallpapers from time to time. Good luck searching for "Cyberpunk wallpaper" now and not getting the shit game.
And I'm polish kurwa
>ruins the entire word "Cyberpunk"
This pisses me so fucking much. I liked to browse cyberpunk themed wallpapers from time to time. Good luck searching for "Cyberpunk wallpaper" now and not getting the shit game.
And I'm polish kurwa
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:41:53 PM No.712640571
>>712635879
Predictions:
>Bad Ending shows a Harry that looks more like SM Harry
>Good Ending has Harry kill the baby (referencing the SH3 novel)
>Good+ Ending expanded to show Harry and “Heather” in an epilogue
>UFO ending has SH2R James
I can’t imagine SH1 with any other endings honestly (and I think most of the changes I mentioned are bad).
Predictions:
>Bad Ending shows a Harry that looks more like SM Harry
>Good Ending has Harry kill the baby (referencing the SH3 novel)
>Good+ Ending expanded to show Harry and “Heather” in an epilogue
>UFO ending has SH2R James
I can’t imagine SH1 with any other endings honestly (and I think most of the changes I mentioned are bad).
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:42:04 PM No.712640585
>>712640498
>heaven's night was moved from its original location for no reason, leading to one of the most pointless changes in a padded out moonlight grove part
>they solved the mystery of the brookhaven garden being bigger in the map than it actually is, which is a mystery that didn't need solving because it added to the mystique (common pattern in this demake)
>no hair in the box is tasteless and gets rid of one of the funniest quirks in the original game, change for the sake of change
>quiz has no music playing and narrator sounds totally disinterested, you're supposed to feel the narrative dissonance with a happy quiz show in the middle of a horror event
>quiz also isnt solved in the hospital where your memory of the questions is fresh
>pyramid head chase in the hospital is publicly announced in a cutscene instead of happening mid gameplay while the player is caught off guard
>why are there nurses in the streets? and in every dungeon after the hospital
>hangman puzzle is unnecessarily complicated with a two step process of matching the puzzle and then solving the innocent criminal
>labyrinth is now a million times more annoying with the new aggressive mandarins who litter the hallways
>they ruined the final boss with a banal underground section for the 2nd half that takes you out of the kino atmosphere of the rooftop from the original
>the entire game is trying to pull a meta deconstruction meme like ff7r but done in a worse way by pretending the characters have memories of the original game's events and trying to canonize the loop theory which is retarded
>>712640371
Kill yourself Mileikowsky.
>heaven's night was moved from its original location for no reason, leading to one of the most pointless changes in a padded out moonlight grove part
>they solved the mystery of the brookhaven garden being bigger in the map than it actually is, which is a mystery that didn't need solving because it added to the mystique (common pattern in this demake)
>no hair in the box is tasteless and gets rid of one of the funniest quirks in the original game, change for the sake of change
>quiz has no music playing and narrator sounds totally disinterested, you're supposed to feel the narrative dissonance with a happy quiz show in the middle of a horror event
>quiz also isnt solved in the hospital where your memory of the questions is fresh
>pyramid head chase in the hospital is publicly announced in a cutscene instead of happening mid gameplay while the player is caught off guard
>why are there nurses in the streets? and in every dungeon after the hospital
>hangman puzzle is unnecessarily complicated with a two step process of matching the puzzle and then solving the innocent criminal
>labyrinth is now a million times more annoying with the new aggressive mandarins who litter the hallways
>they ruined the final boss with a banal underground section for the 2nd half that takes you out of the kino atmosphere of the rooftop from the original
>the entire game is trying to pull a meta deconstruction meme like ff7r but done in a worse way by pretending the characters have memories of the original game's events and trying to canonize the loop theory which is retarded
>>712640371
Kill yourself Mileikowsky.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:43:38 PM No.712640709
>>712640571
>>Bad Ending shows a Harry that looks more like SM Harry
The remake can be complete and utter shit but if this happens I will clap
>>Bad Ending shows a Harry that looks more like SM Harry
The remake can be complete and utter shit but if this happens I will clap
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:43:39 PM No.712640710
>>712640554
You sound alright little polski. Polish devs just piss me off I'm sorry.
You sound alright little polski. Polish devs just piss me off I'm sorry.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:44:58 PM No.712640802
SH2's original gameplay sucked because there was never any real horror, no real tension because there is no reason to fight enemies. They're slow, prone to stun and easy to maneuver. The only enemies you need to watch out for are bosses. And it's not like you have watch your resources, the game showers you in health kits and ammo.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:45:05 PM No.712640804
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:46:10 PM No.712640884
>>712640585
>and trying to canonize the loop theory which is retarded
The only people who want this are you fags because you want something to bitch about. The devs didn't even canonize it.
>and trying to canonize the loop theory which is retarded
The only people who want this are you fags because you want something to bitch about. The devs didn't even canonize it.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:46:22 PM No.712640906
>>712640804
I'm a red haired Scot you polish little monkey.
I'm a red haired Scot you polish little monkey.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:46:31 PM No.712640921
>>712626819
>>712631121
SH2 remake already proved they didn't add un-needed profanity. It's not a Capcom game.
>>712631121
SH2 remake already proved they didn't add un-needed profanity. It's not a Capcom game.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:47:07 PM No.712640964
>>712626689 (OP)
Dude, Maria rapped the most iconic horror vidya scene in history. They are as stupid as they come.
>>712640884
Have time loops ever be done correctly?
Dude, Maria rapped the most iconic horror vidya scene in history. They are as stupid as they come.
>>712640884
Have time loops ever be done correctly?
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:47:51 PM No.712641012
>>712640498
>>checking the map doesn't pause the game which is a problem with the mandarin part later in the labyrinth
I liked that, it's a horror survival game sweetie.
>>checking the map doesn't pause the game which is a problem with the mandarin part later in the labyrinth
I liked that, it's a horror survival game sweetie.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:49:36 PM No.712641153
>>712640804
You need to stop sucking CDPR dick. They are dead. I hope Rebel Wolves will manage to make a good game.
You need to stop sucking CDPR dick. They are dead. I hope Rebel Wolves will manage to make a good game.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:51:14 PM No.712641285
>remake is better than the original
>the tranny schizos chimp out
Same as it ever was, same as it ever was.
>the tranny schizos chimp out
Same as it ever was, same as it ever was.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:51:32 PM No.712641305
>>712640585
>>why are there nurses in the streets? and in every dungeon after the hospital
They were in the streets of the original game and one was at the hotel because it was a nurse's station, sorry your brain couldn't put that together
>>why are there nurses in the streets? and in every dungeon after the hospital
They were in the streets of the original game and one was at the hotel because it was a nurse's station, sorry your brain couldn't put that together
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:53:45 PM No.712641481
>>712640585
>>labyrinth is now a million times more annoying with the new aggressive mandarins who litter the hallways
Imagine complaining about the game actually making the enemies more threatening and giving you a reason to play smart.
>>labyrinth is now a million times more annoying with the new aggressive mandarins who litter the hallways
Imagine complaining about the game actually making the enemies more threatening and giving you a reason to play smart.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:55:22 PM No.712641606
>>712640498
Exactly why i turn off toggle sprint.
Exactly why i turn off toggle sprint.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:56:55 PM No.712641730
>>712640906
>Polish little monkey
Lol you are definitely brown and a try hard here buddy stop trying to divide whites it don’t work with me
>Polish little monkey
Lol you are definitely brown and a try hard here buddy stop trying to divide whites it don’t work with me
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 5:57:56 PM No.712641819
>>712641285
Lol exactly his a sad Troon brownoid
Lol exactly his a sad Troon brownoid
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:01:28 PM No.712642097
>>712635879
Anon KONAMI game KONAMI why are you expecting ANYTHING new from them.
Anon KONAMI game KONAMI why are you expecting ANYTHING new from them.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:01:45 PM No.712642126
where THE FUCK is my little GIRL
short
black hair
short
black hair
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:05:41 PM No.712642440
>>712642097
Because Bloober did new shit for the remake, and it's Bloober doing it again.
Because Bloober did new shit for the remake, and it's Bloober doing it again.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:25:32 PM No.712644048
>>712630985
to be fair to him he could've meant the gamecube remake of 1 and not the nu-remakes of 2/3/4.
to be fair to him he could've meant the gamecube remake of 1 and not the nu-remakes of 2/3/4.
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:31:51 PM No.712644495
>>712635879
>>712640179
>Harry has been trapped in a timeloop since SH3
>Kaufmann and Lisa have been trapped in a timeloop since SH1
>They realize that the only way to escape the loop is to put aside their differences and team up.
Silent Heroes
>>712640571
>I can’t imagine SH1 with any other endings
Ambulance ending
>>712640179
>Harry has been trapped in a timeloop since SH3
>Kaufmann and Lisa have been trapped in a timeloop since SH1
>They realize that the only way to escape the loop is to put aside their differences and team up.
Silent Heroes
>>712640571
>I can’t imagine SH1 with any other endings
Ambulance ending
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 6:38:42 PM No.712645052
>>712628306
trvth nvke
trvth nvke
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 7:04:08 PM No.712646940
>>712637942
Unironically why everyone is so happy about shit like that box? After seeing dumb fuckers wonder around mindlessly and then a tip box for the retard fuckers pops up to help them so they don't stop playing the game and get frustrated.
Unironically why everyone is so happy about shit like that box? After seeing dumb fuckers wonder around mindlessly and then a tip box for the retard fuckers pops up to help them so they don't stop playing the game and get frustrated.