Thread 712670938

Will the silent hill 1 remake be good?

>>712670938 (OP)
No

I mean even if it isn't we still have the original to play so I don't care either way

I hope bloober has the soul to remake the bloopers at the end of the game

>>712670938 (OP)
yes, SH2 remake was good

Why did they remake 2 before 1? Is 2 a prequel like MGS Delta?

>>712670938 (OP)
No.

>>712671520
No, it wasn't. Zoomies were just excited to play silent hill because they are too dumb to work emulators and find the ISO's.

>>712671748
I've played the original several times and I thought the remake was good

>>712671678
because 2 is the best in the series and is standalone, unlike 1 and 3 which are sequels

>>712672094
Perfect! now it's playable on ps5

>>712670998
FpBp

>>712670938 (OP)
No.
Its a remake made in modern year. It will run like shit, be overpriced as fuck and every female will be fuck ugly.

>>712670938 (OP)
After 2 remake turned out good I'd say it's likely

no remake has ever been good and they're only ever made for zoomers

>>712671678
Because stories about personal struggle sits well with people more so than stories about child abuse.

>>712673507
>"oops, I forgot I killed my wife"
>"nvm, it was a mercy killing and she wanted it desperately"
what a struggle

>>712670938 (OP)
they will try to silent hill 2 it

>>712673665
you only find out she wanted it in one of the endings

>>712670938 (OP)
Nope.
>>712671678
because Konami is a corporation making products to generate revenue from subhumans and does not care about the series itself

Eileen shaving

>>712670938 (OP)
It will be okay, like most remakes these days. An okay game that everyone plays and most people forget about after a week or two.

>>712673767
no, it's more than one ending that says that
and one of them in particular the ending a player is most commonly going to get
it's like how most commonly a player would not be able to save Cybil in SH1, and given she never referenced in SH3 we can presume Harry canonically might not have

>>712671520
It wasn’t bad, but sh2 is much easier to 1:1 because the game isn’t as aged fidelity wise as 1 is. They’re gonna have to be more imaginative to get the atmosphere of 1 down correctly, so we’ll see if they can actually do it or not.

>>712674259
Don't speak to me until you learn how to speak proper english

>>712671678
because 2 is the most popular one like how 3 is the most popular MGS so they remade that one first. 1 leads into 3 so they're probably already locked in to remake both.

>>712672094
she would unironically kill this role thoughbeit

>>712673665
it's all based on your interpretation of James, the events of the game and the ending you got. i suspect a lot of it is cultural as well. the Leave ending is the most American of the available endings while In Water feels like typical Japanese downer stuff. and the Maria ending feels very European, a cautionary fairy tale.

>>712674260
it really depends if Ito and Yamaoka will be involved to babysit them like SH2 remake. if they aren't involved i have very low expectations.

>>712670938 (OP)
i dunno maybe i find 2 remake not so awful but thats cause the og team was there to tard wrangle bloober

>>712670938 (OP)
AHAHAHAAHAAHA

No

>>712674358
what's it like being stupid and thinking SH2 is deep?

>>712671293
A ambitios nipp lives for months in the office to render all the cutscenes, including bloopers, on all the office computers post working hours. It is said he never even got a single shower...

>>712674928
it's crazy how he left Konami to go be another drone in EA and now no one knows about anything he works on

>>712674926
No one said Silent Hill 2 was deep. Guess you can't read or write in English, huh Ranjesh?

>>712675393
>you're brown
>anyone let me talk more about this game I only played recently because it was a remake
sure thing
I know it's upsetting, after ten+ years of watching videos about SH2 on youtube and then finally "playing" it last year, but you need to understand it's gay and stupid

>>712671678
because it's a standalone story and the most popular in the zeitgeist besides the first movie (which explains why it is the way it is).
it was a perfect opportunity of both probing the developers competence with a certain budget/time constraints and public approval, they had to make it or break it.
fortunately for us SH1 chads, this means SH2 was their trainings wheels so it didn't really mattered if they fucked it up, which they didn't, so now we got the better deal of not dealing with the growing pains of what did or did not work with 2, as those will get ironed out with a even better budget and time constraints, worthy of the better game.

>all those SH2 fags who'll be experiencing SH1 for the first time
I'm rock hard imagining they getting fucked in the sewers and the otherworld streets...

>>712672094
I will now buy your game.

silenthillfags, is the cult aspect interesting and compelling for you?

>>712676913
yes, there's no Silent Hill without the cult. but i think SH4 showed you can't do a game focused entirely on it, one reason that game wasn't well received was the boring protagonist and the fact that it was almost entirely focused on the cult.

>>712671678
Konami somehow knew a tragic wife killer (ie hot) would bring in the female audience, and now it's time to the real Silent Hill

SH1 feels so weird and depends on feeling weird

The rock steady over the shoulder cam in SH2R as you constantly jog at an even pace into a short view distance fog just sucks away all the mood, but SH2 doesn't need atmosphere as much as SH1 does because it has a real story and legit characters.

>>712678358
the way the camera make you feel about the events/character is also important. with a fixed camera you're more like an observer to what's happening vs the generic third person "cinematic immersive" camera.

>>712678358
>>712679168
Well with all the bitching and moaning about the camera, I think they might do some segments with a camera similar to 1 because they seem to listen to criticism.
Thanks for beta testing

>>712680336
they tried that in Downpour and it was retarded and superfluous, but Downpour was also made by literal shovelware devs so who knows how it would work in a different situation with Ito there babysitting the dev team.

>>712670938 (OP)
I think it has potential to improve since the first game kinda falls apart after the hospital.

>>712680681
>Homecoming and Downpour are the Silent Hill's Godwin's law

>>712681504
when you're talking about the continuation of the franchise and remakes by non-Japanese studios, sure.

>>712680336
All they need to do is mixed controllable camera + fixed cam for moments of impact (like the alley). Shouldn't be too hard, might be disorienting on a first play but so is regular fixed cam anyway.

>>712670938 (OP)
>Blooper team
Highly unlikely.
>>712671520
lol no kys
>>712676913
Somewhat. It doesn't need to be a part of every story and it shouldn't if it has nothing good to contribute.